FacebookTwitter
Hatrack River Forum   
my profile login | search | faq | forum home

  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» Hatrack River Forum » Active Forums » Discussions About Orson Scott Card » Harry Potter/Ender's Game

   
Author Topic: Harry Potter/Ender's Game
SkeletonRock
Member
Member # 10563

 - posted      Profile for SkeletonRock           Edit/Delete Post 
Maybe this has been discussed before, but I'm new and curious so give me a break. Does anyone else feel like J.K. Rowling ripped off Ender's Game when she wrote Harry Potter?
Posts: 12 | Registered: Jun 2007  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Nathan2006
Member
Member # 9387

 - posted      Profile for Nathan2006   Email Nathan2006         Edit/Delete Post 
Um... Not really. You mean the whole concept of training children?

I think that's been around for awhile, in lots of books. There have been books before specifically about wizarding school, much less the space station where Ender and his friends were kept.

I can see the similarity between EG and HP, now that you mention it, but I don't think it's a rip off.

BTW, welcome to hatrack.

Posts: 438 | Registered: May 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
SkeletonRock
Member
Member # 10563

 - posted      Profile for SkeletonRock           Edit/Delete Post 
I just feel like too many of the elements are similar. Doesn't Harry even start his own training sessions and more and more children come to those?
Posts: 12 | Registered: Jun 2007  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Itsame
Member
Member # 9712

 - posted      Profile for Itsame           Edit/Delete Post 
Um, I am gonna say not at all. Not all books about children are rip-offs of each other.
Posts: 2705 | Registered: Sep 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
SkeletonRock
Member
Member # 10563

 - posted      Profile for SkeletonRock           Edit/Delete Post 
quote:
Originally posted by JonHecht:
Not all books about children are rip-offs of each other.

Thanks, but I was asking about Harry Potter.
Posts: 12 | Registered: Jun 2007  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
kacard
Administrator
Member # 200

 - posted      Profile for kacard   Email kacard         Edit/Delete Post 
We admit a few eyebrows were raised at our house when we first read it [Smile] But, I think it's not that elements of Ender's Game were ripped off, I think it's that both books hit some very truthful things about adolescence that resonated with lots of people. I think its not that Ender's Game was ripped off. I think it's that they are both popular because the books tell the same kinds of truth.
Posts: 780 | Registered: Jul 1999  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Synesthesia
Member
Member # 4774

 - posted      Profile for Synesthesia   Email Synesthesia         Edit/Delete Post 
Indeed.
Evern story is an unconcious rip-off of some other story anyway.
Or at least most of them are related to each other somehow.

Posts: 9942 | Registered: Mar 2003  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Tara
Member
Member # 10030

 - posted      Profile for Tara   Email Tara         Edit/Delete Post 
I've heard so many people say that Harry Potter was ripped off other books...First Lord of the Rings and then Ender's Game...Both of those claims seem ridiculous to me. The only thing JK Rowling seems to have "ripped off" when she wrote Harry Potter was common witch and wizard folklore, which has been around for centuries and is anyone's property.

When Harry started training other kids in defense, it was because their current Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher was teaching them nothing at all, and the war against Voldemort was (is) imminent. It made perfect sense in the situation, and there was nothing to suggest that Rowling got the idea from anyone else. Plus, it was Hermione's idea, and Harry didn't want to it at first.

I don't really see any good connection between that and Ender's extra practice sessions. Even if there were -- is there ANYTHING else invented in Harry Potter that's remotely similar to anything invented in Ender's Game? If you don't have any other points of argument, I don't see how you have any argument at all.

Sorry to go on about this, but I'm a bit tired of people accusing authors left and right of ripping off others. I'm sure that ARE cases were a some ripping off has been done, but Rowling is one author, I think, whose name is clear in that regard.

[edited to remove some things that weren't actually true]

Posts: 930 | Registered: Dec 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
SkeletonRock
Member
Member # 10563

 - posted      Profile for SkeletonRock           Edit/Delete Post 
I'm glad we can talk about this without getting emotional.
Posts: 12 | Registered: Jun 2007  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
docmagik
Member
Member # 1131

 - posted      Profile for docmagik   Email docmagik         Edit/Delete Post 
Or sarcastic. [Wink]
Posts: 1894 | Registered: Aug 2000  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
DDDaysh
Member
Member # 9499

 - posted      Profile for DDDaysh   Email DDDaysh         Edit/Delete Post 
I have to admit, the thought never even crossed my mind. Besides, if she DID rip off Ender's Game, it wasn't done very well. Harry Potter is fun, but it isn't in the same league as Ender, though I'm sure Mr. Card wished profits followed talent a little more closely.

Rowling is an OK author. Her first four books were entertaining, and even thought the books have gotten alot less fun, you can see she's refined her writing style alot too. However, she's a MUCH better businesswoman than she is author. Still, nothing to hold against her. All in all, she's done a pretty good think with Harry Potter, so even if she DID rip it off from somewhere (definitely NOT Ender), who cares? Ideas are pretty much fair game, and if she could pull it off better than the others, then good for her.

BTW... If you want to REALLY see idea ripping off, compare "Star Wars" (the original book) to the first Dune.

Posts: 1321 | Registered: Jun 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
theamazeeaz
Member
Member # 6970

 - posted      Profile for theamazeeaz   Email theamazeeaz         Edit/Delete Post 
Not at all. The concept of "the one" is as old as they come, as is special training.

Harry doesn't have to fight Voldemort. He chooses to. When the final showdown happens, Harry will know it's the big one, and if he kills Voldemort, he will know that Voldemort is dead, provided it doesn't kill him in the process. Hogwarts doesn't train dark wizard catchers, it trains students who do what they want in life with their magical abilities. The Battle school students, while some went on to other military endevors, were trained to fight that big battle in the end- a battle they didn't know they fought until after it was over. Ender didn't know that he killed Bonzo, Stiltson and the Hive Queens until well after he did it. At the end, Graff described Ender as his weapon. A gun does not know it kills- a human fires it and it spits out a bullet into the air with amazing momentum.

Unlike Ender, Harry Potter has peers. While Ron and Hermione are aware of Harry's fame, power and potential, at the end of the day, they fight, laugh about rule breaking and Harry is just another kid. Ender had no peers. The commanders singled him out from day one. Remember when Val wrote that letter signed "all my love turkey lips, still paddling the old knew"? The teachers had noticed Ender's depression. He had written "poor Ender" after the students laughed about the time they had fended off the attempts at disrupting their sessions Ender had walked in on them and they stopped laughing, becaue he was there. They regarded him as an adult, and not another student who just happened to know a lot. He realized he had no friends and it hurt him. Even in the end, he protests so when he is told by the jeesh he'll "always be our commmander".

You take away different elements from each book. Ender's Game was inspired by concept of 3d weightless battles, but I see it as a look into the head of a perfect hero, who thrived on winning, but just wanted to be loved in return. It's about finding a place after your world gets shattered time and again- when you can never return to your family, or even your planet. After all that had been taken from Ender, he still responds with love- he does menial spaceship labor before Val arrives at Eros because he has nothting better to do, and it's useful. He governs the colony as a way to escape with Val, but earns the people's respect as a legitimate leader, letting other people take credit for his ideas so things would get done. He invents speaking for the dead so that humans understand that killing the buggers was bad. He makes it his life's work to be an ambassador for intelligent alien life. By all rights, Ender should have retired to the house by the lake that he was given, hired a bunch of servants as well as a shrink or three, done parades and tv gigs as well as a ton of drugs. But he doesn't, even when he believes the most important part of his life was over, even telling Val not to write about his governing work in his biography.

The best bits of morality take people take away from Harry Potter are usually one liners from either Dumbledore or Sirius ("it is the choices, not our abilities that define who we really are", "if you want to know what a man is like take a look at how he treats his inferiors, not his equals", "the world isn't divided into good people and death eaters", I know I'm missing some here). For me, Harry is one of the least interesting characters. I want to know what happens with Harry's parents and their contemporaries. What really happened to Regulus Black? Yes, Harry is the one everything happens to, but the brilliance of the Harry Potter series lies in the way everything comes together, how charcters play subtle roles inside and between books and all of it was hinted at pages ago. Harry lives in a fully developed world. My biggest fear about book seven is that it will be like Lemony Snicket's The End. Snicket ends the Series of Unfortunate Events rather clearly, but ties up very few loose ends and answers very few questions. I have a huge expectation of book seven that everything will play a role, but I know it's impossible.

Posts: 1757 | Registered: Oct 2004  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
GaalDornick
Member
Member # 8880

 - posted      Profile for GaalDornick           Edit/Delete Post 
quote:
Originally posted by SkeletonRock:
I'm glad we can talk about this without getting emotional.

Who got emotional in this thread? And if you're not being sarcastic that's kind of a weird thing to point out.
Posts: 2054 | Registered: Nov 2005  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
TL
Member
Member # 8124

 - posted      Profile for TL   Email TL         Edit/Delete Post 
quote:
BTW... If you want to REALLY see idea ripping off, compare "Star Wars" (the original book) to the first Dune.
Well, yeah, some of the same elements are there. For example there is a young man....who.... lives on a desert planet for the first twenty minutes of Star Wars. And, oh, also, uh, the stories are similar in the sense that they are both....about.... guys. Who? Let's see. Save the day! And have some kind of second sight.
Posts: 2267 | Registered: May 2005  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
LargeTuna
Member
Member # 10512

 - posted      Profile for LargeTuna   Email LargeTuna         Edit/Delete Post 
skeleton is calling Tara emotional, i think
Posts: 856 | Registered: Jun 2007  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
pooka
Member
Member # 5003

 - posted      Profile for pooka   Email pooka         Edit/Delete Post 
I'm just going through the Harry Potter books for the first time now, and I don't see much in the way of similarities. I've compared it with Alvin Maker before, but just in the general way of comparison and not as a rip-off.
Posts: 11017 | Registered: Apr 2003  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
BlueWizard
Member
Member # 9389

 - posted      Profile for BlueWizard   Email BlueWizard         Edit/Delete Post 
The thing is, aren't all stories essentially the same story?

Aren't all mysteries the same?

Aren't all suspense stories the same?

Romance stories?

Isn't all Sci-Fi the same?

Aren't all Cowboy stories the same? You have the handsome guy in the white hat, the beautiful girl in the gingham dress, and that nasty guy in the black hat, from there on, it is just a matter of moving the characters around in different ways.

In school stories, there is always the nasty teacher, the generally clueless adults, and a mystery to be solved.

In detective stories, you have the hard-bitten, hard-drinking, slightly seedy detective sitting in his office when suddenly the rest of the story walks in in a slinky dress.

The fact that stories have similarities means nothing other than, just that, they have similarities. To be a 'rip-off', an author has to have blatantly told the same story, or ripped off aspects that are unique to that individual story. For example, if Hogwarts had been called 'Battle School' and Quidditch has been called 'the battle room', that would have been pretty blatant.

As it is, we don't, each and every one of us, live a completely unique life. Just because one real live person plays football doesn't mean all others are forbidden to play it. Everyone's life has similarities, so logically everyone's fictional story has similarities.

To illustrate a point, someone once said that Shakespeare told every story there was, and from that point on, people are just repeating variations on the themes that Shakespeare created. Though it must be noted that even Shakespeare has been accused of getting his inspiration and story ideas from other sources.

Stories are similar because life is similar. It take FAR MORE than that to constitute a 'Rip-Off'.

Steve/BlueWizard

Posts: 803 | Registered: May 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
TL
Member
Member # 8124

 - posted      Profile for TL   Email TL         Edit/Delete Post 
Hmmmm... Okay, well-said, Steve.
Posts: 2267 | Registered: May 2005  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
   

   Close Topic   Feature Topic   Move Topic   Delete Topic next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:


Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2