This is topic OSC has question for Pathfinder readers in forum Discussions About Orson Scott Card at Hatrack River Forum.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.hatrack.com/ubb/main/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=1;t=005577

Posted by kacard (Member # 200) on :
 
In working on the 3rd volume "Visitors" right now, OSC has a question some of you might be able to help with.

For Pathfinder readers:

Is Umbo the only character who can project his image into the past in order to give warnings, or does Rigg ever do an image projection (rather than physically going)?
 
Posted by DustinDopps (Member # 12640) on :
 
I don't remember Rigg ever projecting an image. It's been about 9 months since I read both books, but it seems like Rigg always travels bodily.

Having said that, I don't remember anything implying that he *couldn't* project an image. So if he did it, I wouldn't cry foul.
 
Posted by vineyarddawg (Member # 13007) on :
 
I'm pretty certain that Rigg has never done an image projection before, just Umbo. Rigg has always actually physically gone there.

I agree with DustinDopps, though... I don't think it's "world-breaking" for him to figure out how to do an image projection rather than physically travel. The mystery of how the paths actually work and how Rigg travels along/between them is probably nebulous enough that the image projection ability shouldn't be a violation of what's already been established.

Or if what Umbo does is somehow fundamentally different than what Rigg does, perhaps it's a matter of Rigg discovering that he can somehow briefly "hold" himself between two paths/times, while not being fully present in both (almost like a translucent/partially transparent image to both).

Hope this helps.
 
Posted by kacard (Member # 200) on :
 
OSC sends his great thanks and says "OK, that's what I wanted. I wanted Rigg NOT to be able to do it - that it's an Umbo thing But I didn't want to say so if there was a time when Rigg had done it!"

That's all he needed, so thanks so much. Of course, if somebody does have an instance where Rigg sent an image, we do need to know about it ASAP [Smile]
 
Posted by ToRiFn (Member # 13121) on :
 
I literally just finished listening to Pathfinder Book 1 about 5 days ago and now tonight completed book 2 Ruin. I was wondering why Rigg couldn't appear to Ram Oden and himself in the control room with the two knives right when they are about to kill each other. It seems like the face-mask made it so he was better able to control the parts of his power that were similar to Umbo and Param however since he didn't appear to himself and Oden as an apparition and created a duplicate of himself in the process it would seem that he can't do it or hasn't determined how to do so at this time. Please hurry on book 3 I am dying for more of Rigg and these great adventures in time.
 
Posted by Rick (Member # 13133) on :
 
The reason why Rigg can't do it may have to be explained because you have implied that each of their unique-seeming powers are actually just different facets of the same ability. That is why they are able to successfully teach them to each other. At least, that was the impression with which I was left. Great fun! Thank you.
 
Posted by Gwen_Owens (Member # 13138) on :
 
In reading these books, it seems to me that Rigg is the most advanced with understanding his gift and what he is able to do with it. It wouldn't surprise me that he could just use his image to go back in time and not his physical self, it seems like that is a "lesser" part of his power. Maybe Umbo can teach him how to access that? Love these stories!!! Can't wait for the next one!!!
 


Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2