This is topic Legend of Korra has a release date in forum Books, Films, Food and Culture at Hatrack River Forum.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.hatrack.com/ubb/main/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=2;t=058833

Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
It is April 14th. Take that, Diablo III!

http://www.nickandmore.com/2012/03/14/nickelodeon-upfront-2012/
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
Yeeeeeesssss.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
FINALLY! Man. It's way overdue, and the teasers and interviews have been killing me! If it's even half as good as the original I'm going to be thrilled. Thanks for posting this.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
It certainly looks pretty damn sweet, and in only a month:)
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
This elicits a manly squee from me, if there is such a thing as a manly squee.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
There is not. But we love you anyway.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
What about a macho D'awwwww when you see a week old puppy fall asleep standing up? certainly that is masculine!
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
That sounds far more plausible.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Everyone! We can get the premiere episode 20 days early! Just go here and "like" the page on facebook. 100k of that and we get the episode march 24! (8 days from now) We're just above halfway there, and there are a number of ways in addition to "liking" to *up* the counter. If you click around on the paisho board, there are 3 hidden pieces of concept art, each one you find counts as a +1 to the 100k goal.

The link again:

http://www.korranation.com/

(Wow I sound like some viral marketer, I'm not! I promise, just really excited!)
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
FINALLY! Man. It's way overdue, and the teasers and interviews have been killing me! If it's even half as good as the original I'm going to be thrilled. Thanks for posting this.

The animation is extremely good. (There were a number of clips leaked, battle scenes and the like) And the villain is starting to look actually scary. I have no doubt this will be awesome.
 
Posted by ambyr (Member # 7616) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by T:man:
Everyone! We can get the premiere episode 20 days early! Just go here and "like" the page on facebook. 100k of that and we get the episode march 24! (8 days from now) We're just above halfway there, and there are a number of ways in addition to "liking" to *up* the counter. If you click around on the paisho board, there are 3 hidden pieces of concept art, each one you find counts as a +1 to the 100k goal.

The link again:

http://www.korranation.com/

(Wow I sound like some viral marketer, I'm not! I promise, just really excited!)

But then what will I do at the premier party I've already invited people to? :-/.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Not tell anyone you've already watched it on the nick website [Wink]
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
The first episode was leaked due to incompetence on Nick's part.

It is glorious.

(The premiere will be episodes 1 and 2, though)
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I'm tempted to go find it. But I think I'll wait until the big day. Glad to see you like it though.

I've already heard some of the music from it and it sounds great.
 
Posted by Shanna (Member # 7900) on :
 
Yeah, don't watch it. It makes it that much harder to wait so long fot the second episode.

I was just coming to say how much I enjoy the music styling. The fight scenes were insanely good. Its amazing how they're able to animate such intricate movements.

There's one thing in particular about Korra's background that is annoying me but since the first episode feels very much like a small piece of a bigger introduction, I'll wait to see if they comment on it more.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I watched a teaser on the facebook page, is her mount a... polardog?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Yep!

Polar bear dog.
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
Hey, that's my bday! Freaking awesome.

I loved the first show tremendously, but honestly I probably won't watch this until the entire series is over. I hate waiting for new episodes and I watched the entire first series (Avatar: TLA) all in one week (best. week. ever.) and I'd like to just do that again. Supposedly this series is only going to be about 24 episodes (give or take), but who knows. Maybe it will get more?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
It was only supposed to be half that to start. Something tells me Korra won't get more, or if it does, it'll be a new distinct story since these two half seasons are self contained. But at the very least I bet we get more Avatar. Nick loves it, It's wildly popular, and the creators have already said they have a lot more stories to tell.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
It must be popular to survive that dreadful movie.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Thankfully, it was highly popular BEFORE the movie. It was the highest rated show in Nick's history.

No one who saw the show first then saw the movie would get a bad vibe from a new show. Most of them knew that the creators of the show had nothing to do with the movie.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Nick is our friend. They're releasing the first TWO episodes this Friday (on the korranation website). It will probably be only streaming quality, but oh well.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
Saw the leaked version online so here's thoughts:

1) The animation reminds me eerily of The Boondocks in animation style, it's very Animesque in the sense that American "anime" tends to see the exaggerated shonen expressions and goes a step further, balanced by higher budget so they luckily don't go super deformed on us like say in Fullmetal Alchemist.

2) The new firenation uniforms are AWESOME, they are pretty much how I was designing uniforms for a militaristic nation in one of my own nation (though mine are black/dark purple not red).

3) Everyone IS KungFU FIghT-ING! *plays music* Lots of fanservicy action (the good kind of fan service) this episode, clearly they want to hook people in and not let them go. Only way for the fighting to have been better is to have Jackie Chan fight Summer Glau.

4) Steve Blum as the antagonist. Nuff' Said.

5) Polar Wolf-Bear-Dog! Stephen Colbert will be hiding under his desk.

6) More Zeppelins! Quasi steampunk!

7) Most Epic Trolling of all time. You all know the moment.

Can't wait for more.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
(Psst it's a polar bear Labrador)
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
I'm going with my gut here, as everyone knows there's more nerves in my gut.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
quote:
Only way for the fighting to have been better is to have Jackie Chan fight Summer Glau.
Thanks for making me feel let down, because that will never happen.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
Maybe we could setup a Kickstarter for it.

Every 10k added is an extra minute.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Considering works like The Tuxedo I'm pretty sure it wouldn't be too hard to convince Chan, its Glau that may be difficult to convince.

Guess what! The Legend of Korra facebook campaign was a success and the two first episodes will be free to watch at korranation.com on saturday.
 
Posted by Aris Katsaris (Member # 4596) on :
 
quote:
Most Epic Trolling of all time. You all know the moment
I'm actually not sure which moment you mean. Or perhaps I don't understand what you mean by trolling. A further hint?

EDIT: Nevermind, I realized what you mean. The scene that contained the phrase "I've been dying to ask you".
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Aris Katsaris:
quote:
Most Epic Trolling of all time. You all know the moment
I'm actually not sure which moment you mean. Or perhaps I don't understand what you mean by trolling. A further hint?

EDIT: Nevermind, I realized what you mean. The scene that contained the phrase "I've been dying to ask you".

They know their fandom well.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
It was amazing. Truly.

The animation is so smooth, the backgrounds are so beautiful. The voice acting is great, I heard one line that was iffy. The music was so perfect, sort of "what if china invented jazz"

Ooh. I'm so excited for this, it really lived up to the hype, I'm so impressed.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Okay...get ready, cause I'm about to gush:

I LOVE IT!

The animation is stunning, the music is amazing, it's just as funny as the last one but maintains all the charm and storytelling ability of the original as well.

It's exactly the same and completely different.

I can't wait for more!
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I was very happy to see the Toph statue.
 
Posted by millernumber1 (Member # 9894) on :
 
I was very happy with both the differences and similarities. I will be interested to see both the interstitial history and the way the Avatar being older influences the tone of the show. Additionally, I won't be as annoyed by the romance, since characters are not 12...

I am curious about the anti-bender movement - quite an interesting idea, I think!
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I like the professional bending game they've come up with. It has enough rules and professionalism to make it sound pretty interesting. I'm still not quite sure how the whole rounds versus zones thing works, but I'm guess we'll get more as time goes on.

And the metal benders were awesome!

I'm eager to hear about the interstitial history myself. I'm sure they'll drop some of that on us. I was still hoping Aang managed to find a secret colony of Air Benders, but it looks like somehow the entire race is going to be rebuilt just from Aang's family...though I guess there were never really that many Air Nomads to begin with.

I hope the phonographs guy is the grandson of the cabbage merchant, and we get more of him.

My cabbages!
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
I like the professional bending game they've come up with. It has enough rules and professionalism to make it sound pretty interesting. I'm still not quite sure how the whole rounds versus zones thing works, but I'm guess we'll get more as time goes on.

The rules explained by Bryan here.
 
Posted by C3PO the Dragon Slayer (Member # 10416) on :
 
I came late to this Avatar craze (I only just watched the first episode of the original series last week... and have voraciously watched the rest of the first season by tonight). It's a bit early for me to call myself a fan of the show, but I'm rather liking it.

This Korra series is looking really promising. I am very pleased to see multiple references to the platypus bear, which I consider the most hilariously quotable line from the first season of the original series, trumping even "my cabbages!" I like that they have evolved the setting from the (quasi) medieval roots to a more early-1900s New York feel. It's a great way of doing something new while also showing the flow of time since the original series.

Stellar animation, too. The fight scenes had so much more flow than the original series (which, I must stress, I've only just seen the first season of). The first series did a great job of blending the techniques of Japanese and American animation. It looked like an anime with fewer of the lazy elements of the medium, like lip-flapping, Ken Burnsing, and overly stylized reaction shots, and more of the grace and complexity of American cartoons, with more than one thing happening on screen at a time. The Legend of Korra, however, looks like it could fit in with the Disney animated canon (which is a compliment) in terms of animation quality. I never watched many cartoons, so perhaps I've simply been oblivious to the frontiers in TV animation, but I was genuinely impressed by this.

I waited this long to watch the original series only because when I suggested to my roommate that we watch it, he replied that he had seen it, and he was uninterested because it was "kind of trying to be a kid's show" and "they could have done more with it." (He was unable to elaborate on any details. Now that I've watched the first season of the original show, I should try to weasel out a less vague response.) They certainly have done more with the Legend of Korra so far.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I think the fight scenes get better in TLA as the show went on. The fights in the finale are downright epic, especially paired with the music. I was holding my breath through long stretches of them.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
quote:

It looked like an anime with fewer of the lazy elements of the medium, like lip-flapping, Ken Burnsing, and overly stylized reaction shots, and more of the grace and complexity of American cartoons, with more than one thing happening on screen at a time.

You haven't seen enough anime then. This is really dependent on the Studio. Frankly I'ld argue and did in one of my above posts that Korra and I'll note so did The Boondocks seem to have taken the exaggerated expressions of anime and run with it. Modern!Anime tends to use the eyes more to confer emotion.

If you want complexity go with virtually any Shaft anime from the last 3 years; Madoka Magica and Bakemonogatari/Nisemonogatari come to mind. Though you may want to make a drinking game from the Shaft Head Tilt.

quote:

I waited this long to watch the original series only because when I suggested to my roommate that we watch it, he replied that he had seen it, and he was uninterested because it was "kind of trying to be a kid's show" and "they could have done more with it." (He was unable to elaborate on any details. Now that I've watched the first season of the original show, I should try to weasel out a less vague response.) They certainly have done more with the Legend of Korra so far.

Tell him to watch Transformers Prime it largely resolves the issues he has with Last Airbender. I know what he means, the constant censorship of avoiding saying "die,death,killing" or showing it on screen makes it fairly jarring to have this big war going on but never any casualties or any real actual devastation or destruction. The audience doesn't end up knowing why they should be fighting for things. Is this like a "clean" war like 1870 or is this the Japanese invasion of China with seven million dead?

Its clearly supposed to be the latter but the onscreen evidence seems to do its best to downplay or deflect it. It loses much of its ability to act as a critique on war if it ends up making it look clean, glorious and fun. The problems most modern war films have for instance.

Transformers Prime managed to find a better balance that "works" between being a kids show but still being something of a reconstruction of "Robots fighting each other and they need our help!? AWESOME WHERE DO I SIGN UP!?!" Interestingly they shy away from the films by keeping "official" human presence like the US Military and the Marines fairly minimal, which bugs me a little as I as a Humanist Patriot would feel that if there's anything remotely close to a legitimate use of US military power it would be curbstomping imperialist alien aggressors but the reasoning Optimus gives makes sense; its THEIR war not OUR war and thus they feel they need to do 99% of the work and we should just get out of the way or there would be (as per Movie #3 shows very clearly) unacceptably high human casualties.

Unlike the movies a TV series has more flexibility so if the Humans are to get their chance to go toe to toe it'll very well likely happen eventually and will have the time to properly flesh it out.

Back to Korra, if I have any real criticism for it it's that it feels a little rushed. The sequence near the end of the first episode with Tenzen says no and then saying yes feels like there was no proper development there as well, on the bright side its a good sign that the series will be fast paced with a lot of action, on the minus hand it may mean there's less philosophy, world of cardboard speech buildups and world building.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
They managed to make Avatar pretty deep despite the fact that any killing that might have happened was mostly offscreen. Also keep in mind that the Air Nomads were killed in a genocide, so it wasn't exactly tame. The themes of the story, the character growth, etc, were what I thought were best about the show. I think an adult version where there's more blood and killing might have been more satisfying for a lot of people, and it might have allowed them to explore different issues, but what they chose to focus on was still pretty excellent.

I'm really looking forward to how they do Korra. She's the polar opposite of Aang in a lot of ways. He was really spiritual, and had a hard time some confronting some of the realities of his position. Given that, it was very easy for Aang to master some of the more powerful aspects of being the Avatar, like speaking with past Avatar and dealing with the Avatar State, because as controlled as he was, even he had trouble with his own emotions. Korra comes at it as a wild child, and can't detach herself the way Aang was raised to. So she has to learn the opposite lesson.

Blayne, keep in mind the context of Korra. Originally it was only going to be 10-12 episodes. All killer no filler. So it was always going to be fast-paced. I'm not sure if the extended order allowed them to add more on the end, or if they just sprinkled it throughout, but we can expect this to have far fewer bottle episodes than the old one did.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
12 episodes is something I am on the fence on, generally all of the very best anime I have ever watched (Bakemonogatary and Nisemongatari for instance) were 14 and 10 episodes respectively, on the other hand some of the 12 episode Baker's Dozen seasons have had problems, such as poor pacing, running out of budget early resulting in bad animation of off model frames and development hell. It can be good, it can be terrible, or is can be good yet flawed.

But rarely has there been both an action packed show AND a show that existed to tell a thematically deep story with introspection and significant character arcs etc etc see Madoka Magica as something that managed to accomplish it but they had a genius as a writer.

This second episode that I just finished watching fills me with a lot of hope, character development, action, theme development, it nailed it. What usually happens in anime is a slow few episodes that picks up episode 3 (aka the "Three Episode Test" where any series that's worth watching gets good by the third episode, Another being the exception is it got "okay" episode 3 but only grew the beard episode 6) with then the gradual ride up the roller coaster up until episode 8 or 9 and then WHOOSH down at breakneck speeds, if we're lucky we get the last episode in which to ratched back down as a breather and to close off loose ends.

Korra seems to have been the opposite here, first episode serving as the fast paced action hook with the second episode slowing down a little but still "fast".

As for Avatar doesn't that just underscore my point though regarding how schizophrenic the show is? Sometimes we have genocide and poisonous tea and sometimes we have clean fun action sequences where people fall seemingly safely into water, it's a little jarring in retrospection. It ultimately underscores how GOOD TLA that we don't really notice it but it CAN be possible to be "darker" without being "grimdark of the future there is only WAGH!". Korra seems to solve this by NOT having genocidal wars of conquests and focusing more on abstract threats such as the downtrodden underclass in a fast moving modern setting. Lots of Jackie Chan like action sequences against thugs, criminals and terrorists/freedom fighters without needing to come up with increasingly bizarre and byzantine excuses as to why a battlefield wouldn't have any bodies littering the area.

Now remember I never claimed TLA didn't have themes, in fact my worry about Korra is that they would have less time to explore them to make room for having more action and character development. Resulting in whatever themes they do end up exploring to be done tangentially and metaphorically if it doesn't tie into the main plot. TLA had three seasons so it had time to take it's time and take a look at a bunch of things pertinent to bending and to fill in the gaps of their world, while developing a number of characters. I have confidence Korra will be good and make a good honest effort at doing the same, but the fact is they do have less time, their main advantage is that they don't have to reinvent the wheel and retread old ground already established in the previous series.

Another note, TV Tropes and Genre Convention Knowledge wil ruin your life, my only surprise this episode is that Korra would use the airbending knowledge she acquired so... SOON. I was like "She's totally going to use the airbending thing here to solve a problem any episode now" and bam, 3 minutes later. Makes me suspect she'll 'master' her airbending fairly soon though I'll be further impressed if they do manage to successfully drag it out a bit more.

Now specifically what did I like about this episode? The pro-bending match was interesting though a little repetitive, though this is certainly because I find sports in general to be repetitive so the show did nothing wrong here and served its purpose to give Korra enough time to finally sit down and use her airbending stance to good effect, my only wish is that something more was done to highlight the transition, like an internal monologue or a flash back or something to make her go "AHA!" and have a more specific epiphany instead of just suddenly "doing it" with no warning.

If I the audience goes "Hrrm, if only/she's going to/she should use her airbending thing here" and Korra does in fact do so then Korra should have had a moment in which she thought to herself "I should do this, aha!"

Tenzen asking "Please promise me your teenaged years won't be like this" and the older daughter going ]:| "No promises." was gold. As was the whole Mako's and Totally-Not-Sokka-Promise interactions with Korra was great and very indicative of the show's style. Especially Not!Sokka's interactions both the Bokke and Tsukkomi (manzai if you don't know what that is, it's having two people play off each other usually one is the straightman and the other the "idiot", what they did is more of a Seinfieldian Americanized version) routine with him bailing her from trouble and then the "I'm totally not trying to sound racist But"-deadpan skit. The brother going "... Sigh, you're the avatar and I'm an idiot" was a great establishing moment.


Tenzen really IS a terrible teacher though he displayed the wisdom to notice it when irrevocable proof is shown to him, and the airbenderness of adapting to what is best for Korra. Korra isn't philosphically an airbender, and thus as with Aang to learn airbending she has to adapt the teachings of the basics of airbender, their very most basic basics to suit her own needs; thus from that basis she has a foundation to build from.

For Aang Earthbending collided with him on a basic and fundamental level which Toph recognized was his flighty nature vs the confrontation nature of earthbending. To Earthbend he needed to be able to confront things "head on", in short he needed to learn a different sort of courage.

Airbending is about being adaptable, about following the flow of things, being patient and evasion. Simply trying to find her center and jumping straight to avoiding windmills isnt going to do it.

She gets it, sorta, finally, when shown that there are some mountains that refuse to be climbed and no amount of brute force will overcome it, forcing her to try to find and follow the flow of things because it helps her reach her goal by another means (which is kinda an airbender tenet, finding and trying different solutions to a problem). My problem with the sequence is that we never really see any intermediate steps between "GRR KORRA SMASH PUNY WINDMILLS" and "Zen. I am. There is the way, and it is the Tao." (I exaggerate) which is why I would've preferred some kind of internal realization of "Tch, fine! I'll try it his way..." Relenting on her stubborness makes a good first step, I just wish it was more developed.

Ah Korra, being so tsundere you! I'm calling it now, any romantic development if any will be between her and Mako and entirely bromantic with Not!Sokka.

I still continue to dislike the Air nomad clothing. Firenation's this time around looks really good, Water's is fine and very Canadian. Earth's is too cosmopolitan and diverse to really nail down as a single consistent style. I think Aang looked best in his firenation scrubs.

Not decided on who my favorite character is going to be, I REALLY liked Toph as she was a Badass Deadpan Snarker in the body of a young girl. Being blind was to insure she couldn't single handedly beat up Chuck Norris but right now no one in particular gives me a Toph sort of feeling of woopass in a can.

I like the older daughter of Tenzen but she hasn't had a chance to do anything; Mako is too aloof and lacking in charisma and Not!Sokka is too goofy. Crazy Bush dude in the park while crazy is too much of a one scene wonder at this moment. I'm hoping Jinora (the older daughter) can be this series "Toph".
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
It may be a bit subtle and soon to notice, but I appreciate that Korra has an athletic build. Usually when a female character in an animated show is represented as being physical and strong they are still petite and shorter than the men, I can't even remember any women in TLA breaking the short skinny mold. I think its good for a kids show to feature a positive female character who happens to be the antithesis of Katara.

I'm not sold on the polarbeardog, those little back legs creep me out.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Katara was tall enough for a twelve year old. Keep in mind how much older Korra is than Katara or Toph.

And Kyoshi was massive.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I meant in terms of personality and disposition, Toph was the only girl who had attitude and it was mostly for comedic moments while Korra's basic character would traditionally be interchangeable with a male character more like Zuko. And like any animation style they have physical archetypes and rules to make sure everything is right, aside from Kyoshi they didn't have any other females who were taller or thicker than the regular male build, barring the older characters who while much shorter were a bit fat.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
Though Suika from Touhou has noticible muscle mass as well ^_^

But yes, Korra looks very athletic and the character designs are all pretty good overall.
 
Posted by umberhulk (Member # 11788) on :
 
I hope uncle gets a cameo. Best uncle ever. Even the Jackie Chan uncle. Ayaa!
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
Katara was tall enough for a twelve year old. Keep in mind how much older Korra is than Katara or Toph.

And Kyoshi was massive.

Katara was 14. She was only a few years younger than Korra.

That episode where Aang dresses up as Kyoshi was hilarious, with her size 20 shoes.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t6a5OHvhQTs
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Blayne Bradley:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t6a5OHvhQTs

Seeing as Blayne did not add a disclaimer, I will. If you click that link and have a soul you will cry.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Anyone catch Episode 3 today?

Another great one!

And they have a red panda ferret! I love it!

I love how they managed to recapture the Appa/Momo thing with Naga/Ferret thing. The two of them are adorable.

SPOILERS

It seems like they've managed to incorporate almost every element of bending from the original show. They've included lightning bending for power generation, chi blocking for the anti-benders, and even the powerful life energy bending that Aang used on Ozai (which I'm really curious to see where that goes). Though it looks less dramatic than when Aang did it.

Still, are we headed back to the spirit world? Where did he get that ability from?

I like that they've managed to make the Equalists pretty serious badasses. I mean we knew it was possible, since Mai and Ty Lee held their own against the Avatar and his two friends on a daily basis, but now there are a whole team of them, and frankly, it doesn't seem like Mako or what's his name are the equal of Toph and Zuko. And it also comes down to more than pure bending, their martial arts skills (which Aang always excelled at) are coming into play more directly.

Very good start so far. I'm surprised I've gotten sucked in so fast.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
SPOILER?

I'm really interested to see who the big bad is behind that mask.

END SPOILER?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
SPOILER

Part of me wonders if it's someone we actually know, or a descendent of someone we know.

END SPOILER
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
That's been more or less what I've been thinking about the situation as well.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I think it should be the Cabbage Merchant's grandson.

After all, who suffered more at the hands of benders than the poor cabbage merchant?
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
That would be pretty amazing.
 
Posted by Scott R (Member # 567) on :
 
quote:
who suffered more at the hands of benders than the poor cabbage merchant?
I've got serious suspicions that it's...

SPOILER
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Firelord Ozai
.>.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
But the cabbage merchant's son would be fantastic.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
SPOILER

Yeah I thought that too...but it'd really be stretching the rules for the show for him to have lived that long unless they have some bizarre supernatural explanation as to why he's still alive 100 years later.

If Amon was voiced by Mark Hamill, it'd be even more suspicious, but their voices ARE similar enough to make you wonder. And there's the fact that Ozai was the only victim of energy bending in the last couple thousands years, so he's the only one with experience in it. And it gives him an excuse to hide his face.

But I really hope it isn't. It just doesn't seem like it'd make as much sense.

I am curious how the Equalists learned chi blocking. Ty Lee taught it to the Kyoshi warriors...so you have to wonder if maybe Amon is actually related to Sokka and Suki.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Let me throw out another theory.

Amon's face is shielded because he visited the spirit world and it was stolen by Ko. So he has no face, but Ko taught him how to energy bend.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
Let me throw out another theory.

Amon's face is shielded because he visited the spirit world and it was stolen by Ko. So he has no face, but Ko taught him how to energy bend.

By far the best theory.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
On another note, I'm 20 minutes into the live action movie, which I've never seen before...and it's horrible.

I mean, just awful.

The graphics, the costumes, the Fire Nation ships, all of that stuff is pretty damn sweet actually. I feel like with the exception of the music, the NAILED it visually.

But this story is terrible! I can't believe they used this script.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I retract that. Some of the martial arts and bending are comically slow paced and lame. They sort of failed on the follow through. Sigh.
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
On another note, I'm 20 minutes into the live action movie, which I've never seen before...and it's horrible.

I mean, just awful.

You already knew I didn't eat a hat right? honest question, don't watch this movie
 
Posted by Marek (Member # 5404) on :
 
I kind of wondered if Amon might be Aang's other son Bumi, the only non-bender among a family of extremely powerful benders. Or Bumi's son, so the rest of his story could be true, about the farming, and being shaken down by a firebender, and if his father were the son of Aang and Katara, it's pretty likely he would stand up to some one trying to threaten his family, even if he couldn't win.

So if Amon looks like Aang, or like Tenzin, it would explain hiding his face, and might also explain how he could have a power that only Aang has ever used.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
SPOILER

quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
Let me throw out another theory.

Amon's face is shielded because he visited the spirit world and it was stolen by Ko. So he has no face, but Ko taught him how to energy bend.

For some reason, I doubt this will be the case, but this would definitely be the coolest explanation I've heard so far. I'm hoping the new series acknowledges the spirit world's role in the Avatar mythology at some point in it's apparently brief run.

In other news, I'm kinda bummed most reports seem to suggest Legend of Korra is only supposed to run for two seasons. I'm hoping the fan support will help sway that tide a little.

END SPOILERS?
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
I think it should be the Cabbage Merchant's grandson.

After all, who suffered more at the hands of benders than the poor cabbage merchant?

The cabbage merchant goes on to form Cabbage Corp. which supplies cheap satomobiles to the masses. (His company is probably the largest after Sato's)

Amon did learn energybending from a spirit, and that spirit would have to have been old enough to remember a time when energybending was more common. (Or just be best buds with the Lion turtle) This plus the fact he draws so much attention to his lack of a face made me and my brother think immediately of Koh. (One of the oldest spirits, old as the moon and ocean)
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
Y'all are making me feel like I need to rewatch the original series.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by SteveRogers:
For some reason, I doubt this will be the case, but this would definitely be the coolest explanation I've heard so far. I'm hoping the new series acknowledges the spirit world's role in the Avatar mythology at some point in it's apparently brief run.

The way they're playing up how un-spiritual Korra is, I'm really excited for her first avatar state. (I feel like it's going to be a horrible disaster, and just turn even more people against benders)
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
After the first few episodes, I still feel like the pro-bending thing is one of the cooler elements added to the mythology of the show. I'm excited to see more of that if it plays a role in the show. I thought it was very well done how they integrated pro-bending into Korra's avatar training.
 
Posted by Scott R (Member # 567) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
Let me throw out another theory.

Amon's face is shielded because he visited the spirit world and it was stolen by Ko. So he has no face, but Ko taught him how to energy bend.

By far the best theory.
I really dig this theory.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by SteveRogers:
SPOILER

quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
Let me throw out another theory.

Amon's face is shielded because he visited the spirit world and it was stolen by Ko. So he has no face, but Ko taught him how to energy bend.

For some reason, I doubt this will be the case, but this would definitely be the coolest explanation I've heard so far. I'm hoping the new series acknowledges the spirit world's role in the Avatar mythology at some point in it's apparently brief run.

In other news, I'm kinda bummed most reports seem to suggest Legend of Korra is only supposed to run for two seasons. I'm hoping the fan support will help sway that tide a little.

END SPOILERS?

It was originally supposed to only be 10 or 12 episodes. Thankfully they doubled it. Supposedly there's still a chance for more, but they'd have to do it soon, otherwise all the material will already be written, at which point it's hard to tack more on without it being weird.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
I'd rather the series be lean and perfect than stretched out (based on the third episode, which cuts directly into some gritty action and introduces a menacing threat, I'm happy with the decision to have no filler episodes).
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
Well, I don't mind shorter seasons, but I just wish there was going to be more of it than just around 24 episodes total.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
I'm pretty confident that if they have more good material, they will find a way to make it happen.

One thing I really love about this new show is that they are *not* rehashing anything. Literally the only part that makes me feel rehash is the Naga/Fireferrett duo. Everything else, from the cast to the setting to the plot, feels very different from the original show, yet captures everything that makes the Avatar world awesome.

This shows me that the original's success was not a fluke. These guys have an amazing grasp of how to tell a good story, period.

I much rather see shows that have a goal, tell a particular story, and then end it, rather than drag it out for the sake of dragging it out.

If they have a new way to keep it fresh after 24 episodes, either with the current cast or yet another series, I'm sure they will.
 
Posted by Scott R (Member # 567) on :
 
All the big budget, live action fantasy/sci fi shows that are currently running in prime time should be ashamed that a group of people from a kids network are writing better stories.

(Not that stories for children are inferior-- just that the stories explicitly for adults are not nearly as well written as the Avatar series has been)
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Scott R:
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
Let me throw out another theory.

Amon's face is shielded because he visited the spirit world and it was stolen by Ko. So he has no face, but Ko taught him how to energy bend.

By far the best theory.
I really dig this theory.
Certainly an interesting theory, but you'd have to explain why Amon has eyes.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
Do we know for definite there are eyes behind the mask?
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
He definitely has eyes. You can see them open and close from behind his mask as he relates his story of firebender oppression.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I don't believe his story at all, it came across too easily for these writers to leave his past at that. I don't think Ko took his face, and I especially don't think Ko would teach anybody spirit bending even if it knew how. The giant turtle was so special that there was no history of spirit bending despite the fact that it seems to be the precursor to all bending in general.

I love how well they are playing both the kids angle plus the quality storytelling! For instance, Amon telling everyone that bending is the reason for everything that is wrong in their lives is fear mongering and then he uses spirit bending and calls it from the gods, using spirituality to wage war on all spirituality and justifying it with spirituality. And it all fits perfectly.

I have no guesses as to how Amon learned how to spirit bend, but I find it hard to believe that he isn't a bender in the traditional sense as well. Aang was in full avatar god mode and it still took a pretty light show to cancel Ozias bending, meanwhile Amons demonstration was more akin to a televangelist healer with some high flying action tossed in.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Yeah I found that odd as well. It didn't look anything like the energy bending we've already experienced...so either he isn't really doing it, or what we saw with Aang was some sort of special window into it, rather than what it would have looked like to anyone else.

There's also the question of will. Energy bending is inherently dangerous because it's a contest of wills. Ozai was an incredibly strong person, both as a bender and just mentally, so Aang struggled. Amon was bending street hoods and crime bosses, so it's not like he had a major challenge. Maybe it didn't need to go to the same level.

It's going to be interesting to see what the answers are.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
I'm kinda wondering if we'll find out if any of the new technology being showcased was either invented by or derived by designs from the Mechanist from the original series.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
It was originally supposed to only be 10 or 12 episodes. Thankfully they doubled it. Supposedly there's still a chance for more, but they'd have to do it soon, otherwise all the material will already be written, at which point it's hard to tack more on without it being weird.

Each season is a self contained story, it won't matter to much how long they take before getting the oppurtunity for more. (Yes, Amon is only the villain for the first 12 episodes) ETA:source
quote:
Yeah I found that odd as well. It didn't look anything like the energy bending we've already experienced...so either he isn't really doing it, or what we saw with Aang was some sort of special window into it, rather than what it would have looked like to anyone else.
The energy bending Amon uses is pretty different than Aangs and the lion turtle's. Instead of the Yin Tang and ru zhong he touches the Yin tang and the AMON.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
That's actually slightly disappointing. I was hoping for a longer payoff. For all the drama we've already seen, it's actually kind of a let down to know Korra will solve the problem in 9 more episodes. The end of TLA was so much more dramatic because the tension had been building for so long.

Still, it'll be nice if they can carry enough of the story over, and if they do get a third season with this show, that they can do something interesting and contiguous with it. I just fear they won't be able to dig as deeply as they were able to with Aang.

Out of curiosity, T:man, what is the significance of your energy bending analysis there? Maybe he's blocking rather than removing?

ETA: More on energy bending

There does seem to be some theories out there that the bending is fundamentally different, and that he's chakra blocking (chak blocking jokes anyway? No? Okay.) That could explain why all his followers use chi blocking.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
We only know of one other chi blocking character, but we know nothing of how she learned. Ty Lee was last seen joining the Kyoshi Warriors, it would certainly be surprising if she and the protectors of Kyoshi Island have something to do with the anti-bending movement.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
That's actually slightly disappointing. I was hoping for a longer payoff. For all the drama we've already seen, it's actually kind of a let down to know Korra will solve the problem in 9 more episodes. The end of TLA was so much more dramatic because the tension had been building for so long.

I agree with this. I'm worried a shorter season will make it seem like less is really at stake. [Dont Know]
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
Well, it's the scope of the thing. At the very core, Amon is just a thug. He has a couple of minions, perhaps an edge in energybending. But he's no Firelord, capable of deploying multiple armies of firebenders and fleets of ships.

The instability to Republic City caused directly by Amon can very easily be solved by beating him in combat. I can see how a single season would be enough.

The greater problem of bender/non-bender inequality, though, is probably too large to be taken care of in a single season. Amon is simply riding the wave of anti-bender sentiment. He's not the source of the problem, only a symptom. If the show creators declare that "balance is restored" just because Amon is gone, then I could see a problem. But if the world is still off balance, despite Amon's defeat, then, I would see it as a sign of greater things to come.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Just finished watching the third episode, finally. Man, it is a hella rad show, and I'm glad they made it:)

The idea of the Fire Nation colonies being carved out into their own independent nation is, well, perfect. I really liked that. Neatly solved the problem they posed. The head fake towards telling Fire Lady Ursa's story was great:)

Republic City really does feel authentic to me, though of course I'm a fan and thus biased. You know what it reminded me of? One of the opening scenes in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Obviously I might've been reminded of that anyway, because of the music and martial arts, but in several scenes in that film, small villages, large inns, or pieces of a city, are portrayed and it didn't feel like just a backdrop. If that makes sense.

The character stories are all compelling and well done, I think, even the parts that are pretty obvious (Korra and Mako, der der der!). But perhaps they'll throw some twists in there besides just telling the cool smart girl meets broody-troubled-boy story. I suspect even if they do, they'll tell it well, though.

A neat spin on Aang's problems, that Korra has no problem (even relishes) fighting and physicality and conflict, but is so far totally deaf I think to the spiritual side of things. This would need to be resolved anyway, but obviously it's going to come into much sharper focus as this whole bending removal story gets told. If memory serves, Aang performed that on Ozai by actually severing his connection to the Spirit World, and that means that she will never be able to achieve long-term success as Avatar until she can deal with this on some root level. I suspect part of her overall arc will be journeying more towards the 'touchy-feely-healy' sides of bending, because what the Avatar can inflict (originally, anyway), it makes sense the Avatar could learn to remove.

I don't have any guesses at all about Amon, but I really like the ones I'm hearing:) All I know for sure is that I don't for a second believe his backstory. Aside from being told entirely too early in the show, it's just too pat.

Liked how apparently Toph's daughter isn't especially fond of Korra, because of Korra's intrusion into her domain. Heck, Toph didn't like Aang either, at first, for different reasons.

I've got to admit, though, I'm attracted to the idea of Amon being one of Aang's children. That has the potential of dealing with the inherent imbalance and unfairness of the world-I mean, some people are just born with a tighter connection with the Spirit World (obviously an important, sacred thing in this setting), and they get super powers on top of it? The Equalists have a pretty compelling political message there. Actually, an example of that would be that I think so far Sokka's only mention in the show, at all, is in the beginning and title credits, where he is shown and not actually named. I mean, descendents of Aang and Katara obviously abound, as well as Toph, and Zuko obviously left a huge legacy as well, but so far (and it's far too soon to say of course) Sokka appears to be getting written out of the story, though the world would've been burned without him.

Another fun spin that I'm not actually committing to, but think would be neat: Amon is either Aang and Katara's non-bending child or someone very close to him, and that child was himself very close to Sokka (which would be understandable, the nonbending son cleaving to the nonbending uncle). Throw in a heaping helping of interference from Ko to put the nastiest spin possible at all points, do some mind-warping and face stealing, and hey-presto! Amon.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
As for the differences between Aang's energybending and Amon's (if that is what Amon is doing, it could be some sort of steampunk tech), bear in mind that not only was Aang performing it as the Avatar, possibly accounting for visual differences, but Ozai was right in the midst of the comet's incredible surge in firebending power.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
quote:
Well, it's the scope of the thing. At the very core, Amon is just a thug. He has a couple of minions, perhaps an edge in energybending. But he's no Firelord, capable of deploying multiple armies of firebenders and fleets of ships.

The instability to Republic City caused directly by Amon can very easily be solved by beating him in combat. I can see how a single season would be enough.

The greater problem of bender/non-bender inequality, though, is probably too large to be taken care of in a single season. Amon is simply riding the wave of anti-bender sentiment. He's not the source of the problem, only a symptom. If the show creators declare that "balance is restored" just because Amon is gone, then I could see a problem. But if the world is still off balance, despite Amon's defeat, then, I would see it as a sign of greater things to come.

We don't actually know that's what Amon is 'at core'. It's certainly possible that he's the running dog of someone else, but if he is his own agent, well...

Should he achieve success in Republic City, he would be poised to utilize the populace and infrastructure of what is (or at least might be, we don't actually know) the biggest, most powerful metropolis on the planet. Warlords have started from humbler beginnings and managed to go further, and we don't even know just how extensive Amon's network and resources are right now. If his base of powerful fighters are just the dozen or score or so we've seen, then clearly he's got a long way to go: he was able to draw a crowd for his revelation, but it was an insignificant sum of people compared to the total population.
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
How many episodes are they into it now?

I haven't started it yet because I'm waiting until at least the first seasons is over. It's too addicting to just watch it one episode at a time. I'm glad to hear you guys approve (the critics are digging it so far), so that leaves me hopeful.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Three are on nick.com so far. As for liking it, well of course I can't promise anything, but I'll put it this way, Jeff: if you enjoyed AtlA, or especially if you really liked it, I would be very, very surprised if you didn't at least think the show was pretty good so far.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Aang's only non-bending child was Bumi.

I've read guesses that it's Bumi, and also that it's one of Sokka and Suki's children. Lots of possible candidates.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
I've also wondered if Amon might be some sort of servant of the knowledge spirit last seen being buried in his library in the desert. Surely, he'd have access to the knowledge to energy bend or chi block, and he'd certainly have a reason to view benders as dangerous to themselves and the world.
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
Oh man, was that a Sokka/Toph/Aang sighting in episode 4?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I don't know, it doesn't air for another 9 hours...
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
Oops, spoilers!
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
I won't be able to watch the episode today when it airs because I'll be at work. Do they stream the episodes on Nickelodeon's website or something like that?
 
Posted by Vadon (Member # 4561) on :
 
Yes they do, that's how I caught last Saturday's. I hope they continue to upload them to Nick.com. Link--Warning, they have advertisements auto-play. Just click "Full-Episodes" to check.

Actually... I'm sick and as such am up already, I might as well just catch it on the television. Do I even have Nickelodeon? Guess I'll find out.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
Thank you. [Smile] My internet access to anything which streams videos is incredibly limited here at work, so I had no way to find out myself while I'm here.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Wow! Spoilers ahead.

That whole episode was just crazy, and utterly terrifying.

Bolin continues to be really cute, and I'm digging Asami. I kinda hoped the foreshadowing of Korra and Mako was just Bryke trolling the fans, I really like Bolin and his flirting with Korra is awesome. The animation was also top-notch as always, the raid scene was just brutal.

After we saw the flashbacks I'm hearing theories that Aang's 'decisive' action somehow caused Toph's death, and that's why Chief Bei Fong hates Korra so much.

Lyr: Because Amon is not using the same pressure points and such as the Lion Turtle and Aang I'm assuming what he is using is not energybending and just some advanced form of chi-blocking.

I kinda hope Amon is not related to anyone from the first series. It would fit with the whole new generation theme better.

I do think he's going to be related to Yokhan and the past troubles of republic city though.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Ep. 4 SPOILERS

So I'm thinking there's basically zero chance either Hiroshi and/or Asami (was it Sasami?) Sato are uninvolved with this whole Equalist business. Partly it's for meta reasons, but hey, thinking about it, I can see how a rises-from-poverty apparently non-bending ambitious young man would have some ingrained sympathy for antagonism towards benders, particularly if his starter loan came in the form of a generous 'gift'-which would tie in with the other gifts portrayed in this episode.

The dread of Korra and others over Amon and bending removal was powerfully done.

quote:
After we saw the flashbacks I'm hearing theories that Aang's 'decisive' action somehow caused Toph's death, and that's why Chief Bei Fong hates Korra so much.
I don't know, the most straightforward reason for the Chief to dislike (I wouldn't really say *hate*, not yet anyway) Korra as much as she does is that she is a serious-minded professional cop, and a super-powered bumpkin Avatar being feted in her city is not the sort of thing such a person would take kindly to under any circumstances, much less in the midst of a long-brewing crisis.

The flashbacks we saw do seem, at least to me, to be hints of Sokka, Toph, and Aang himself, all middle-aged.

Tenzin & Family continue to be enjoyable and well portrayed:) They seem to strike a very nice compromise between experienced, wise monk at peace with the world with harried family man father of three, teacher of avatar.

Love Chief Bei-Fong, who is of course almost entirely right. Korra hasn't actually done much that was especially heroic, with the exception of the rescue of Bolin. Not that she SHOULD have, yet, I mean she's new to the heroing gig.

Got to admit, at first I was sighing a bit over Councilman Korlak's very thinly-veiled sleazy ambition, but they did a pretty good job of having him trick Korra into doing just what he wanted. A sort of more complicated look at the standard 'beware of peer pressure!' message so often preached.

The ending, though, man. Had some serious oomph. I wonder, did Aman leave her bending intact for politics, or because he couldn't actually take it? The latter seems like a very real possibility. It stands to reason stripping the world's bridge to the spirit world of their connection to the spirt world would be a more difficult task than neutering a top gangster.

I doubt I'm the only one who noticed that for all of Korlak's supposed cynical cunning, apparently at least a dozen of Amon's commando chi-blockers as well as Amon himself were able to sneak onto that island when he was supposedly watching it. Incompetence borne of arrogance, or a sign of a connection to the Equalists?

Good show:)
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Another thing I appreciate so far is another meta angle: Korra is unabashedly feminine*, without being what I would call a 'tomboy' as is often portrayed in shows. She's athletic, adventurous, confident, snarky, and powerful, but so far at least (and I don't expect this is something that will change), I haven't caught a whiff of it being in spite of her being female, or somehow more special because she's female.

But then, that goes all the way back to the first series too, with the differences between Toph, Katara, Mai, and Ty Lee. It's often difficult finding a 'grown-up' show or film in which a female character isn't pigeonholed in many ways, so to see it in a kids show is refreshing, but unsurprising given the first series.

I wonder if as time passes, there will be more special discoveries in bending? Because if memory serves in the first series, lightning bending and metal bending came from very special, unique (at the time) forms of mastery, on the one hand from Iroh's study of other forms of bending and incorporating them into firebending, and on the other from Toph's total immersion in earthbending. It seems neither of the two are unheard of at all anymore, certainly metalbending is something that can be reliably discovered or trained in people, given the police, and lightning bending is far from unheard of too.

I wonder if the show will throw any other such innovations, ongoing sorts of things, at us-along with chi locking, too. Perhaps they already have, someone in this thread suggested it might not be energy bending at all that we see Amon doing, but rather a specialized, permanent chi blocking.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
I'd rather the series be lean and perfect than stretched out (based on the third episode, which cuts directly into some gritty action and introduces a menacing threat, I'm happy with the decision to have no filler episodes).

Agreed.

I'm loving this show. A buddy sent me an email with the following insightful point.

quote:
I also love that they've got the villain speaking out against the inherently elitist nature of an inherited power like bending -- something Star Wars has never addressed in a major way. It will be interesting to see if the writers keep it balanced (treating the inequality created by bending as a problem to be resolved) or if they take an Incredibles/Ayn Rand approach (in which "special" people must deal with the jealousy of the less talented masses). I hope for the former.

 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Yup, I really like that as well. A sci-fi/comic book sort of spin on haves/have-nots that's interesting for more than just the story's own sake.
 
Posted by Scott R (Member # 567) on :
 
I'm interested in the justification for the revolution, which the series so far has not shown at all. The only reason that's been given that the Equalists are bad is that Korra opposes them.

I'm inclined to be sympathetic with the Equalists; I liked that

SPOILERS
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Amon ambushed her with his goons in direct opposition to the "rules" she'd set out for their duel. It really heightens the menace he presents-- it implies that this is a guy who can/will do anything to achieve his purposes. I have to think, though, that whoever said that he's not really capable of stealing benders' powers is right. I expect that he WILL block Korra's power at some point, and that she'll be forced to either fight him without, or regain them.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
/SPOILER
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
That's true, Scott, I hadn't thought of the way in which Amon completely breaks the 'rules' really amps up his menace in a story-telling perspective. Of course in one sense, his treachery (though not really, I mean it's not as though he ever agreed to abide by the rules of that duel, or even to duel her at all) was totally to be expected. In good stories, the bad guys are more often willing to violate convention than not, in fact.

But for a story more geared towards kids than cynical audiences, I suspect it carried additional oomph.

As for the Equalists being good or bad...hmm. Thinking back, I'm not recalling anything, actually, they did that was especially heinous. Even the bending removal, who did they target? A bunch of triads who were making life miserable for the ordinary citizens of the city. Well, actually, permanent removal for all such thugs is probably excessive, but it's not super-extreme villainy either, rendering them as ordinary human beings, that is.

SPOILER in response to Scott:


My money is that Amon will, at some point, remove or seriously weaken Korra's bending, and this will be the make-it-or-break-it high stakes pressure cooker sort of challenge that will lead to her developing the spiritual side of her Avatar abilities. It's episode four, what is that, 1/3 through the first season?, and the only whiff of anything spooky has been a very brief vision? Memory? of past events.

ETA: If speculation as to Amon's involvement with the Face Stealer is right, though, I think it would be totally possible the removal would be permanent, at least until the Avatar did something about it.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
As much as I love the Face Stealer theory, the fact that we see his eyes move is having me doubt it.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
After having to purchase the episode on iTunes today to watch it, I can say I feel the suspense in this new series is a much more noticeable element than in the original series. When the episode ended, I found myself desperately wanting more as much as when I watched LOST. The pacing of this most recent episode was almost breathlessly brisk, but it was astounding.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
Anyone else really weirded out by Mako's new girlfriend? They hook up faster and blandly than I'd expected a long-term TV relationship to have hooked up in. At first I assumed she'd somehow be evil. But she really doesn't show any signs of being evil.

I assume her father will continue to be a character as the team sponsor, so she'll be involved for awhile.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
(Also, on top of the cliffhanger nature... damn these episodes end on really sad notes)
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
I think there's something TOO convenient about his new gal pal being the daughter of a guy rich enough to get the Avatar and pals into the pro-bending tournament. I think that'll end up playing a role in the show. Seems like something diabolical is afoot.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Rakeesh-

Kidnapping and attacking while preaching violent revolution against a minority who are different only because of their spirituality is not sounding good. (I can remember a time in the not too distant past where a demagogue riled up a group of people against a certain minority that was perceived as having too much 'power')

The Equalists are completely wrong, yes, the council is populated entirely with benders, but the richest man in Republic City (and probably the world) is a non-bender. And we have also the fabulous bending brothers, who grew up completely poor and don't have a lick of power at all.

Asami doesn't trouble me at all, I think it's pretty cute. Remember they met and dated for almost two weeks before Korra met her.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
T:Man,

A few things. One, I'm not saying I'm a fan of the Equalists in the show, just that their ideals as stated aren't as awful as one would expect from the traditional evil gang of a cartoon. Two, unless I'm mistaken the people they kidnapped so far have been entirely Triads who were suiting up for a well known turf war, the likes of which in the past caused serious problems for the ordinary citizens. Applying the same punishment to all members, from boss on down, though, is excessive.

I don't know which demagogue or which minority you might be alluding to, but whichever it is in the real world, the comparison falls flat on its face for a simple reason: real world minorities don't have superpowers. I mean, that's obvious. It's not just a matter of 'greater spiritual connection'. An airbender can *fly* with a cheap handheld glider. An earthbender is almost always moments away from durable shelter wherever they go. A waterbender can heal and has instant refrigeration, and a firebender never needs worry about energy or heating. And, heck, those are just the very easily imagined examples-there are so many more. In more practical terms, any bender has at least quite a few job opportunities available to them by default than ordinary citizens.

All of these benefits are forever totally excluded to the rest of humanity, and they're things that are available in a genetic lottery. Hiroshi Sato, if he wants to fly, must build or hire a dirigible. An airbender focuses a bit and whips out a glider.

ETA: Right there in Sato's backstory, do you think he would've started off with a shoeshine stand had he been able to earthbend? How much help would have been needed from his unnamed benefactor? As for Mako and Bolin, not only are they poised on the brink of fame due to their bending skill, but Mako himself has made ends meet and who supported two orphans for years, a least in part due to bending. Would be have been able to do that as a non-bender? Well, perhaps, but probably his job would not have built spiritual bending muscle he could use to help his pro fighting, know?

It's unavoidable, the Avatar world has some pretty serious built-in unfairness. That's fine, it's realistic, and I like that they're not just pretending it's a fake unfairness.

[ April 30, 2012, 12:37 AM: Message edited by: Rakeesh ]
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Not all benders are created equal, we've seen a lot of masters but we also saw quite a few airbenders back before the genocide that couldnt keep up with aang at all. We saw waterbenders who could barely splash water.

And yes the benders are benders only because of their greater spiritual connection. That's why we see so many air acolytes on air bender island. They're trying to gain a greater spiritual connection and better grasp the philosophy of the air nomads so they can become air benders. Uncle Iroh spelled it out in the second season in ATLAB, I forget which episode, but I think it was around the chase.

The genetic benefit that Asami Sato got was much better than any bender. She will never have to join a triad just to survive.

I think what this series is moving towards is a future that is less and less more favorable to benders. We saw men like the mechanist building flying devices, we've had the ability to make fire for thousands of years, propelling ourselves through water, and medicine we've also had. (I'm not so sure how water bending healing works, though)

I agree though, they do have much greater depth than most villains and is a great improvement on the pure evil that was Phoenix King Ozai and I'm super psyched to see what the rest of the season has to offer. I just have this feeling in my gut that Amon is just out for power, his story about his face rings false and his, I don't know, image just, well it really gives me the creeps.

I feel like these posts are coming off as hostile and I don't mean them to at all, and I'm sorry if that's how I sound.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
quote:
The genetic benefit that Asami Sato got was much better than any bender. She will never have to join a triad just to survive.
Than ANY bender? Nonsense. Tenzin, Chief Bei-Fong being two very easy prominent examples. You can't really say Asami is vastly better off than either of them, both have major power.

As for the spirit thing...yeah, I know why according to the story they have bending. But that's not why people are unhappy. They don't chant thst it's unfair some are born connected to the spirits, they are unhappy some are born with access to superpowers while most aren't. And yes, of course not every bender is equal, but an average bender will have more options than the average son of a farmer.

As for flying machines...yeah. Ordinary people CAN fly, if they've the money and access to aircraft, which itself takes major money and skill to create and operate. An airbender needs a stick with some fans on it. To build a fire needs tools and/or expertise. All of these examples highlight my point.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Not all benders are created equal, we've seen a lot of masters but we also saw quite a few airbenders back before the genocide that couldnt keep up with aang at all. We saw waterbenders who could barely splash water.

And yes the benders are benders only because of their greater spiritual connection. That's why we see so many air acolytes on air bender island. They're trying to gain a greater spiritual connection and better grasp the philosophy of the air nomads so they can become air benders. Uncle Iroh spelled it out in the second season in ATLAB, I forget which episode, but I think it was around the chase.

The genetic benefit that Asami Sato got was much better than any bender. She will never have to join a triad just to survive.

I think what this series is moving towards is a future that is less and less more favorable to benders. We saw men like the mechanist building flying devices, we've had the ability to make fire for thousands of years, propelling ourselves through water, and medicine we've also had. (I'm not so sure how water bending healing works, though)

I agree though, they do have much greater depth than most villains and is a great improvement on the pure evil that was Phoenix King Ozai and I'm super psyched to see what the rest of the season has to offer. I just have this feeling in my gut that Amon is just out for power, his story about his face rings false and his, I don't know, image just, well it really gives me the creeps.

I feel like these posts are coming off as hostile and I don't mean them to at all, and I'm sorry if that's how I sound.
 
Posted by Aris Katsaris (Member # 4596) on :
 
quote:
And yes the benders are benders only because of their greater spiritual connection.
Utterly unsubstantiated. If the only airbenders arise only from the descendants of the air nomads, and earthbenders only arise among people with Earth Kingdom ancestry, and firebenders only arise among Fire Nation descendants, and waterbenders arise only among the water tribe peoples, then it's obviously quite likely that there's a significant genetic component at work as well.

Either way it doesn't matter. The series has established that whether someone is bender or not is pretty much determined from birth. If it's genetic or the soul's spiritual connection, or whatever; it doesn't really affect in-world politics.

quote:
I can remember a time in the not too distant past where a demagogue riled up a group of people against a certain minority that was perceived as having too much 'power'
Though the situation is rather reversed; Jews had no significant political or military power, but had disproportional influence in finance and the sciences.

In both Avatar:The Last Airbenders and The Legend of Korra, benders have all the political and military power, but the leaders of industry and science seem to be non-benders.
 
Posted by Scott R (Member # 567) on :
 
quote:
Applying the same punishment to all members, from boss on down, though, is excessive.
I disagree. Someone who owns a weapon and shows himself willing to use that weapon in order to threaten others should AT THE LEAST have their weapon taken away from them.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Well, sure, but what if that weapon is, say, a part of their arm, literally, and the given criminal was a first time offending kid? Snatching off a part of their arm forever would seem excessive in that case to me, whereas it wouldn't in the case of the career, boss criminal.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Aris Katsaris:
quote:
And yes the benders are benders only because of their greater spiritual connection.
Utterly unsubstantiated. If the only airbenders arise only from the descendants of the air nomads, and earthbenders only arise among people with Earth Kingdom ancestry, and firebenders only arise among Fire Nation descendants, and waterbenders arise only among the water tribe peoples, then it's obviously quite likely that there's a significant genetic component at work as well.
I've been wondering about the genetic component at play some myself. In the original series, I recall only seeing benders with familial ties to benders of the same element.

So, what's the deal with Bolin and Mako? If they're biological brothers, how is one a fire bender and the other an earth bender? I imagine one of their parents would have to be a fire bender, and the other would have had to be an earth bender? This seems to support the notion of a genetic component to bending.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
I suspect there's a blood component but also, whenever they feel like it, a 'whee! Spirits' component too.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
I'd felt the Spirit World connection to be more on a voluntary basis. In the original series, the prime example I can think of is the differing ideas between General Zhao and Iroh when the former killed the Moon Spirit. Toph doesn't seem to give much creedence to the spiritual aspect either.

[ April 30, 2012, 11:07 AM: Message edited by: SteveRogers ]
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
They've stated explicitly that there is a genetic component, and spiritual component, but that the rules are fairly loose. Air Nomads had the highest density of benders because they were the most spiritual of the nations.

The point of Bolin and Mako is that Republic City is a cosmopolitan melting pot.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
Maybe it's just that some people who take the time to explore the more spiritual aspects are better able to take advantage of the inherent biological potential to bend?
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
Pretty much. It's not that different from how talent works in the real world. Natural potential + work.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
They've stated explicitly that there is a genetic component, and spiritual component, but that the rules are fairly loose. Air Nomads had the highest density of benders because they were the most spiritual of the nations.

Or maybe the smaller air bender societies had a genetic sample better suited for passing on the bending trait?
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
http://www.avatarspirit.net/interviews.php?id=19

quote:
MDD: Yeah, Katara's mom and dad weren't benders. Maybe it's a recessive gene. I've always seen it as more spiritual connections, though. A little bit mysterious...

BK: I mean we've definitely talked about it. I think, again, sometimes we might not know...it's more of what we don't want it to be. We didn't want it to be like there is a lineage...a royal family or something...and these people can bend and then there's everyone else as non-bending, people who never will. Some sort of caste system. Mike and I are more attracted to more of the flux type universe. The only constant is change, variation, that sorta thing. I'm sure it's a bunch of factors.

***Interviewers note: About 20 mins after the interview, Bryan came back to me and we spoke a little more about the basis of bending off recorder. He described bending as more of a talent. You have some genetic basis for potential, but you could go your whole life without developing the talent into ability. Some people have more inherent talent than others, while others with minimal inherent talent can still develop it through hard work and practice. He reiterated a connection to the spiritual energies is the underlying basis. How it manifests is based on upbringing and experience.

quote:
BK: We always have liked the idea of who will be a bender and who won't be to be kind of an ambiguous mystery, even to the people in the Avatar world. From early on we thought the Air Nomads would be all benders. Again it's like Mike was saying, it's more of a spiritual connection. But they have...they had...the smallest population. Earth Kingdom has the biggest population but the smallest percentage of benders. So yeah, there were these notions we kicked around that is wasn't going to be regimented or ruled through specific lineages. We liked the idea that each of the cultures have a different spiritual vantage point...coming at it from a different angle.

MDD: Then the Air Nomads would have been the most spiritual...the most connected to the spiritual energy of the Earth.


 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
Ah, see, I was unfamiliar with those interviews; I was purely making speculation.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by SteveRogers:
After having to purchase the episode on iTunes today to watch it, I can say I feel the suspense in this new series is a much more noticeable element than in the original series. When the episode ended, I found myself desperately wanting more as much as when I watched LOST. The pacing of this most recent episode was almost breathlessly brisk, but it was astounding.

Psst, you can stream it off Nick.com
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
It wasn't on there on Saturday or Sunday.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Just popped on today. I've been watching closely since I missed the live airing.

For future reference.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
I will remember that for next week.
 
Posted by Marek (Member # 5404) on :
 
One thing I find neat, is that benders seem to have the strongest connection to their nations. Most benders seem to dress in a way that relates to their home nation. There has been no mention of any type of "Earth Town" or "Little Water Tribe" like most major cities with huge populations of foreign ancestry develop. Maybe it is because they already know. I really have no idea where my family comes from, but if I were a firebender, and all firebenders were of Irish descent then I guess I would know.

Also I am not sure where it was stated that Sato was not a bender, maybe he is one, he just figured it wasn't worth mentioning. Still I found the rhyme of Satomobile,and automobile amusing.
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
It's stated on the Nickolodeon website.
 
Posted by JonHecht (Member # 9712) on :
 
SPOILERS


I am betting that Tarlock is either in league with Amon or is in fact Amon.


END
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Did anyone notice the mention of Cabbage Corp? I KNEW the cabbage merchant would have a descendent who was a tycoon of some sort.

And yeah, Tarlock is certainly looking suspicious right now.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
I lied, Lyr. Latest Korra still isn't showing up on iTunes, so I haven't seen it. [Frown]
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
This cuts deep.
 
Posted by hef (Member # 12497) on :
 
What's the deal with the metal benders? Is it a specialized subset of earth bending or an entirely different kind of power?
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
quote:
What's the deal with the metal benders? Is it a specialized subset of earth bending or an entirely different kind of power?
In the first series, Toph Bei-fong was able to metal bend, though not easily. She pioneered the skill, and it was due to her immersion and mastery of earthbending that she was able to do it at all. I think Bumi might've learned it too, eventually, but I could be mistaken.

----

Whew! This episode certainly makes up for the last one in terms of plot advancement and action. Man.

Yeah, I noticed Cabbage Corp too-not entirely clear what they manufacture, but to rate an advertisement in the championship match things probably turned out OK for him:)

Goodness, Korra could really use some lightning bending techniques as well as airbending. It's a world with flying machines. Pretty important!

Tarlock doesn't look any more suspicious to me than he has already, actually. The voice is...ehh, kind of similar I suppose, but his reasoning did seem sound to me-he didn't seem committed to his initial vote because of any kind of moral stand, but rather one of public safety. And since apparently Lin (Lyn?) has a pretty stellar record in that department, her committment would serve as a good backup. Unless y'all are suggesting they were betrayed from within the council? That's possible, but really it could've come from so many places. From within the arena, from the police, or from the council.

More than a little peculiar that Amon didn't target, y'know, Tenzin and Lin while they were totally incapacitated and the entire crowd was subdued, instead going for the (admittedly compelling, in this case) political statement. Given that it doesn't make sense that he would fear making a martyr of them, I'm going to note that down as another sign that there's more to this bending-blocking schtick than simply performing a few moments of technique followed by irreversible removal. I won't be surprised if dealing with an honest to goodness master of their bending such as either of them (both of them extremely willful people, too, in their own ways) might be entirely different than snuffing out a smug crime lord or an absurd cheater.

Korra seems to have handled her nigh-crippling fear of Amon pretty well, it seems. Was that handled off-screen? Her actually getting over it, I mean-I remember the episode with the ambushed duel...which actually makes me think the council or the police force are thoroughly infilitrated, actually, given that this is two major operations Amon has managed to stage right under the noses of the authorities, in both cases when they were actively searching for trouble. Anyway, this time Korra showed no hesitation, and given her last encounter with Amon, I gave her some more rad points in my head:) Though she never actually faced him directly.

Also seems clear her straight-up fighting has improved dramatically. If memory serves, earlier in the season she fought that particular goon of Amon's and he beat her quite handily, whereas this time even after taking a beating in the arena, she was still able to handle both him and a few others of his stooges and beat him head on.

The flashback was interesting. Clearly it's seen through the Avatar's eyes, looking at both Tenzin and Lin, I think. I wonder who the third person was?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Tarlock gets put in charge of the anti-Amon task force. Tarlock discredits the city's peacekeeping force and sets himself up to be the new chief of police. What's he going to do next to discredit a power rival and take their place?

It's starting to look at lot like Phantom Menace in that regard. First you create the problem, then you step in with the solution.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
You could very well be right, but it seems to me that if he discredited anyone with his task force shenanigans, he also discredited himself. Unless his promise to be vigilant for any treachery on Amon's part the night of their duel was secret somehow, or the entire incident (which actually seems likely) was brushed under the rug.

We'll know more next episode, though. Amon is certainly in a position to make some pretty nasty political power plays. I also think a lot depends on just how much bending presence there is in the police and city government.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
This cuts deep.

It cut me too!

It wasn't a lie of intent. I did what I said: went to settle down in bed to watch Korra.

Then I discovered Korra was not available. So I went to sleep sad instead. [Frown]
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
That's not Tenzin and Lin in the flashback, that's Aang and Toph. You may want to deny the Lincoln beard, but it is there, and it is his.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Yeah, you could see Aang's tattoos briefly glow in the flashback. Korra keeps having random extremely brief flashbacks.

I can't WAIT for a scene when Korra finally interacts with Aang either via the spirit world or meditation like Aang did. I imagine we won't get that for awhile, unless there's a solstice or something, because Korra is so much less spiritual.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
I saw the tattoos, but is that strictly an avatar thing, that they glow? I can't remember. Any Air Master gets them, I believe, but Aang is the only real example from that series.
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
If the flashback is showing the Yakone incident, then forty-two years ago, Tenzin and Lin would have been around ten. The Airbender in the flashback is quite a bit older. Plus, only the Avatar glows like that.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Rakeesh:
I saw the tattoos, but is that strictly an avatar thing, that they glow? I can't remember. Any Air Master gets them, I believe, but Aang is the only real example from that series.

It's never been explicitly stated, I suppose, but I think we're meant to assume that the tattoos only glow for an Avatar.
 
Posted by C3PO the Dragon Slayer (Member # 10416) on :
 
Still not on iTunes? Bitterness and rage.

We were going to have a Korra party for the new episode last night, but it still isn't out! I paid thirty bucks for this season, dagnabbit!

What's worse is that I hear Episode 6 is a really good one.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Rakeesh:
I saw the tattoos, but is that strictly an avatar thing, that they glow? I can't remember. Any Air Master gets them, I believe, but Aang is the only real example from that series.

We only ever see aang and yangchen's tattoos glow.

I'm forgetting where but they do explicitly state somewhere that you get your tattoos when you becomea master.
 
Posted by Shanna (Member # 7900) on :
 
According to the Avatar Wiki the information regarding airbender tattoos as a sign of master status comes from the old Nick website. Aang actually got his, not for being the avatar, but for inventing the air scooter technique making him the youngest master ever at the age of 12. The show's creators have also said that the tattoos glow because they run along the body's chi paths, so I sort of suspect that the glowing feature is something specific to the Avatars. The only other tattoo that is similar to the airbender markings was probably Combustion Man's third eye.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by C3PO the Dragon Slayer:
Still not on iTunes? Bitterness and rage.

We were going to have a Korra party for the new episode last night, but it still isn't out! I paid thirty bucks for this season, dagnabbit!

What's worse is that I hear Episode 6 is a really good one.

It'll be available for streaming on Nick.com sometime today, if it already isn't.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
Pretty obnoxious to not allow iTunes subscribes to get it before it's legal to view online anyway.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
Yeah that's really bothering me. We paid for it and everything. [Grumble]
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
Unlikely to have an effect in the near future, but might be worth writing an angry letter about. TV companies seem to have their head in the sands when it comes to internet media. In the piracy age, if you want to retain the people who actually pay for stuff, you need to not leave them feeling like they got ripped off.

(This in no way endorses piracy - I'm just as annoyed by people who act like they're somehow entitled to all this free content. But that doesn't mean the companies aren't stupid for not responding to a new environment)
 
Posted by Vadon (Member # 4561) on :
 
(It has just been uploaded to nick.com.)
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Combustion Man! (I prefer, what was it, sparky sparky boom boom man?) I wonder if/when that unique manifestation of bending ( ? ) talent will reveal improvements or offshoots in Korra?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I think we can assume he was using some sort of specialty form of fire bending combined with some sort of enhanced chi thing.

It was certainly powerful, though it had its limitations. There are a lot of unique abilities I'd like to see crop up again at some point in some way, but there's really not much time left. This season is already more than half over.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Well, there were limitations, it's true, but he was basically a walking grenade launcher. No other kind of bending has matched that for potential lethality, I think, with the exception of blood bending and possibly lightning bending (though when you think about it, air bending has some pretty obvious seriously-fatal techniques for killing a person from within too).
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Sucking the air out of their lungs? Stuff like that?

I suppose you could metal bend the iron out of their blood like Magneto too.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Sucking the air out would be one. Starting a miniature hurricane would be another, or reversing the air flow in the throat and lungs with each breath. On the microscopic level, affecting the oxygen within the bloodstream and lungs themselves, on a cellular level, not unlike bloodbending-though if I'm not mistaken there's much more water than air or metal in the blood, rendering that trickier.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
I have to confess that I don't really like Tenzin. =( How did Katara's and Aang's son turn out like this?
 
Posted by Shanna (Member # 7900) on :
 
Tenzin reminds me of Katara alot with that strong sense of responsibility. He's trying to raise a family, keep alive the traditions of a nation that is barely hanging on, and continue his father's legacy of peace. And now he has this girl to look after and while she may be the Avatar, she's also a wild teenager.

Tenzin is not Iroh. He's not the mature guiding voice of wisdom. He's a character that will probably grow and evolve through his mentor role to Korra. She's really only started her airbending training and is no shape to be using it in a fight.

I'm actually really looking forward to their relationship getting stronger as Korra embraces her role as the Avatar.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
I guess he got all his mom's officiousness and sense of responsibility, and none of his dad's love of play and fun. He seems so worried all the time and frazzled. He doesn't seem like a spiritual master at all to me. He doesn't seem like someone who understands and accepts what is, or who moves lightly like the feather through the spinning panels of life, so to speak. You know?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Well, we also have to take into account that Aang was a young kid. We have no way of knowing what Aang was like when he was older.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
I don't think he could've been a squeeze of Lin if he had no sense of fun-or have the sort of children he does, for that matter. I get the impression he's carefully controlling himself to be the sort of teacher he thinks is needed-one could say Katara hardly needs to more embrace her sense of fun and whimsy, after all.
 
Posted by Avin (Member # 7751) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by JonHecht:
SPOILERS


I am betting that Tarlock is either in league with Amon or is in fact Amon.


END

Since Tarlock is a waterbender from the Northern Water Tribe, and Amon has the golden eyes of the Fire Nation nobility, I think that's doubtful.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Is anyone else chomping at the bit to see Aang and Kotara's other children? The premiere pointed out that Tenzin is the most serious of them and therefore the most reserved, and I want to see some wreckless airbending! The chi-blockers may be well trained to deal with the other three elements but I would love to see them get pwned by a single airbender.

Also, Pabu and Bolin continue to be a highlight for me.
 
Posted by mr_porteiro_head (Member # 4644) on :
 
quote:
Is anyone else chomping at the bit to see Aang and Kotara's other children? The premiere pointed out that Tenzin is the most serious of them and therefore the most reserved, and I want to see some wreckless airbending!
I thought that Tenzin was the only child of Ang's that was an airbender.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
He was the only airbender of Aang's kids.

He's currently the only airbending master in the world.

Good thing all his kids are benders. They have an entire race to repopulate.

But I would still like to see the other kids.
 
Posted by mr_porteiro_head (Member # 4644) on :
 
I want to see Ang's kid that isn't a bender at all.
 
Posted by SteveRogers (Member # 7130) on :
 
I still need to watch the episode from Saturday. I'm assuming it's streaming on Nick's website now.
 
Posted by JonHecht (Member # 9712) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by mr_porteiro_head:
I want to see Ang's kid that isn't a bender at all.

You mean Amon?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by mr_porteiro_head:
I want to see Ang's kid that isn't a bender at all.

Kids.

Kya and Bumi.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Edit to redact, and replace.

I just found an Avatar Wiki that says Kya is a waterbender and Bumi is a not a bender at all. I don't know where the portraits came from for each of their entries but they both are sporting the Southern Water-Tribe skin tone, while Tenzin is pale.
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
Aang and Katara had three children: a waterbender, a non-bender, and an airbender.

http://botanymajor95.tumblr.com/post/22159766256/swagbot9001-legend-of-korra-lineage-family
 
Posted by ambyr (Member # 7616) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by manji:
Aang and Katara had three children: a waterbender, a non-bender, and an airbender.

http://botanymajor95.tumblr.com/post/22159766256/swagbot9001-legend-of-korra-lineage-family

Am I the only one who finds it mildly creepy that Katara, Aang, and Toph aren't aged up in that graphic? 10-14 year olds should not be in the "parent" slot of family trees.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Where did that chart come from?
 
Posted by ambyr (Member # 7616) on :
 
Promo material for LoK released to media sources.
 
Posted by Marek (Member # 5404) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
I think it should be the Cabbage Merchant's grandson.

After all, who suffered more at the hands of benders than the poor cabbage merchant?

Well the cops seem to think he has something to do with it, though not being Amon himself
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Woah. I love the return of the cabbage joke.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Especially since it would appear he was actually innocent after all. Once more benders wreak havoc on the cabbage man! [Frown]

Initially I expected this was a ploy by Tarlack, who being the real villain planted a fake informant to send the Chief and Tenzin after Sato, who would've been innocent but it would've been a humiliating debacle for them, and Tarlack's hands would've remained clean. Thinking now, though, that's not really a 200m series kind of plot.

I guess it makes sense the Chief doesn't use her special sensory bending all the time-living in a bustling metropolis, that is.

I'm a bit disappointed by the whole conspiracy thing being found out by eavesdropping through a door after hitting the crapper, but hey, 10 episodes.

I thought this might be an Avatar-state episode what with the dire peril and all, but I suspect that won't happen until the very end and be the culmination of the whole spirituality angle.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
I can't wait til we have an avatar state episode.

I still have a feeling Tarlok is some sort of villain. He's just way too slimy.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
My prediction now is that he is a villain, but a very mundane, political self centered sort of villain, not tied in (except perhaps to serve his own ends) with the Equalists.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
My prediction now is that he is a villain, but a very mundane, political self centered sort of villain, not tied in (except perhaps to serve his own ends) with the Equalists.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Maybe he'll be related to our second season villain.

It seems strange the way he's wresting more power away from Lin, and now that she will no longer be chief of police his task force will be the law.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
I kinda predicted hiroshi was the villain here, he and his daughter were just too conveniently placed in the narrative. While weaning being evil herself would've been waaaaay too convenient a way to wrap up the.love triangle.
 
Posted by Olivet 2.0 (Member # 12719) on :
 
My boys and I had to pause it after she said "Cabbage Corp." Because we totally knew what was coming. We had to pause it again after "Not my cabbage corp!" for a round of high fives. I don't even know why that was so awesome, but it was. [Big Grin]
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Rakeesh:
My prediction now is that he is a villain, but a very mundane, political self centered sort of villain, not tied in (except perhaps to serve his own ends) with the Equalists.

He may just be like the head of the Dai Lee from the Earth Kingdom.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
That's the sort of vibe I get from him: ruthless and completely self-centered and self-interested. He wouldn't object on moral grounds to alliance with Amon, but he wouldn't take that step because to empower Amon is to weaken Tarlock. He's Burke in Aliens.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Does anyone else watch it on the nick website? because I'm getting lag worse than watching a youtube video on my phone with only two bars.

Every minute or so it starts skipping and stalling on frames about eight seconds apart while the audio is just fine. The episode won't load past fourteen seconds so I can't leave it alone while it gets everything loaded up. I think I spent about six minutes extra tech-raging and skipping backwards because the player doesn't hold on to anything its already loaded and shown either.

I prefer to watch a show the way the makers of the show intend it to be watched, and in making the show free to the public I know Nick is paying attention to how many views they get and that all references to their sponsoring and whatnot. Legend of Korra is not going make me hungry for a happy meal or want to play a monkey game but I still like to show Nick the courtesy and that I want to see more of the show. But if they can't even play video online correctly when it is so easy to pirate it does become tempting to torrent instead.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
AH, I've been watching it on Nick with no problems. I've been hitting it at odd hours, though, so maybe that helps.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
The last two episodes I watched the lag wasn't so bad. But I've watched a couple times where it took 40 min to watch a 20 min episode. It was awful.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
Pay to watch it on iTunes.

It's cheap, and it's worth it. Quality has been crystal clear.
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
I am sad. No episode on Memorial Day weekend. What a tragedy.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I know you're not supposed to cry over no episode...but....iz just so sad!

I miss Iroh.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
Lyrhawn, I miss Iroh too! I wonder if we will get some master in this series who is something like him? One can only hope!

I think Bolin is a lot like Sokka. Are there any other characters that remind people of ones from the original series?
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
On the other hand, Zuko's whiney gripy anger is something I don't miss at all. I'm terribly relieved there's no new Zuko person. =)

Am I alone in thinking Azula kicked all kinds of butt? She was my favorite character from the first series. The Beach is the episode that showed her awesomeness. I loved it when she utterly destroyed the other team in the volleyball game and then went "well, that was fun!"

We don't really know much about the kids of the fire nation people from the last series, unlike those of Katara, Toff, Aang, etc. I wonder if something about that will come out. Maybe even among the equalists? Interesting to speculate.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Azula was deliciously evil. I mean she was just plain nuts, but she did evil so well.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
New episode tomorrow, w0000t!
 
Posted by Scott R (Member # 567) on :
 
Azula was kind of boring after she locked May and Tai-Lee up.

Now Toph-- she rocked socks.
 
Posted by Stephan (Member # 7549) on :
 
Anyone read The Promise graphic novel? Part two came out yesterday. It is a wonderful bridge between the two series.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Scott R:
Azula was kind of boring after she locked May and Tai-Lee up.

Now Toph-- she rocked socks.

You didn't find her total unraveling compelling at all?

I really impressed with how they handled her actually going crazy, and then her unhinged battle with Zuko and Katara.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Stephan:
Anyone read The Promise graphic novel? Part two came out yesterday. It is a wonderful bridge between the two series.

I read the first one and found it interesting. I pre-ordered the third because the price was only like $5. Haven't ordered the second one yet, but I will soon. They're doing well with them, I just wish they were longer.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
Toph was awesome. I'd like to hear more about her life as an adult. I notice her daughter carries her family name rather than that of her father. Is that usual in this society?

I sort of think they slandered Azula at the end, and her story didn't really go that way. She was too awesome to lose it like that. But you know how the victors always write the story of the war. Maybe we'll never know the true tale.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by ak:
Toph was awesome. I'd like to hear more about her life as an adult. I notice her daughter carries her family name rather than that of her father. Is that usual in this society?

Well Toph was the only character we knew the surname of. I bet Sokka and Katara, as peasants, wouldn't have surnames. Toph was from a rich influential family and her name was known world-wide, so it's entirely possible her name would have been better to give to her child, and it's also possible the father of Lin never even had a surname.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by ak:
Toph was awesome. I'd like to hear more about her life as an adult. I notice her daughter carries her family name rather than that of her father. Is that usual in this society?

I sort of think they slandered Azula at the end, and her story didn't really go that way. She was too awesome to lose it like that. But you know how the victors always write the story of the war. Maybe we'll never know the true tale.

Azula was nuts from day one. She didn't go overboard until Tylee and Mai left her, but it was a long time coming.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I would also point out that with the entirety of the Fire Nation resources at Azula's disposal she chose to make use of an apathetic nobleman's daughter and somewhat insane circus girl. Those two and her relationships with each were a very big part of her ego and stability, she thought they were her kingdom and hers to rule, when they betrayed her she lost some of her sociopathic confidence that would have served her well as Fire Lord.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
HA! HA! I CALLED IT! TARLOK!

WOW!

Wow!

That episode was INTENSE.
 
Posted by Marek (Member # 5404) on :
 
Yeah, it was
 
Posted by Belle (Member # 2314) on :
 
*spoilers if you haven't seen 6/2/12 episode*
*
*
*
*

Are we supposed to think Tarrlok is Amon? I got that vibe from his reaction. Or is he just using the scare over Amon to seize power?

Also, in that vision was someone bloodbending Aang?

What are the odds that wherever he is taking Korra, she will run into someone we've heard about but haven't met yet? Like, maybe Bumi?

What's Naga going to do when she realizes Korra hasn't come out of the building? Poor Naga, she warned her not to go....
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
His reaction didn't strike me as "I've been caught!" Plus the eyes are still different. But either way, Taarlock is playing right into Amon's hands by creating even more animosity between benders and non-benders.

How awesome was that fight by the way? It's the first time I feel like we've really seen Korra unleash.

I can't wait to see what finally happens when Korra connects with spirit Aang and we finally find out what happened!
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
He's an UrFascist, his ideology requires that there be an enemy to fight in order to maintain power. That his increasing bender resentment just means that the "war" is perpetual, with benders being at war with non-benders and having always been at war with nonbenders.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I'm super curious about his blood bending though! One would guess that Katara would keep that knowledge to herself, maybe telling her water bending daughter and Korra but never anyone else who might try to use it. So does this mean that there have been more than the one blood bending savant? or did Katara make a mistake somewhere in her life.

Glad to see Sokka kept his "wolf-tail."
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
quote:
Azula was nuts from day one. She didn't go overboard until Tylee and Mai left her, but it was a long time coming.
I wouldn't say she was actually insane from the start of the show, but...well, psychopathic or sociopathic, certainly. Even in a kid's show she was willing to maim, kill, torture, or kidnap to get her way. Granted it's not as though she arrived at that outlook without quite a lot of help, but still.

--------

quote:
HA! HA! I CALLED IT! TARLOK!

WOW!

Wow!

That episode was INTENSE. [/quite]

Well, I mean Tarlak being a bad guy was a pretty easy get, man! But yes. Intense to say the least.

[quote]Are we supposed to think Tarrlok is Amon? I got that vibe from his reaction. Or is he just using the scare over Amon to seize power?

Also, in that vision was someone bloodbending Aang?

What are the odds that wherever he is taking Korra, she will run into someone we've heard about but haven't met yet? Like, maybe Bumi?

What's Naga going to do when she realizes Korra hasn't come out of the building? Poor Naga, she warned her not to go....

It's certainly possible. They're doing an excellent job of keeping that up in the air. It would seem a strange choice, though, for a bending blood bender to make a move for power by...manipulating non-benders into supporting him for a violent takeover? I mean, why would he need to? There's hardly a shortage of scuzzy benders in the world to try for such a thing. It just seems so unnecessarily roundabout. My money is on him being an also-villain, though much more fearsome than I would've expected.

I think you're right on the money about those visions being of Aang being blood-bent. It would explain the flashes of him seeming to be powerless.

I'll bet solid Republic City currency that these revelations will necessitate Katara's re-entry into the show. She's surely one of the most skilled waterbenders alive anyway, with a unique insight into the whole Aang angle...and she has her own history of blood bending as well. If anyone might know a way to handle that power, it would be Katara, just as Iroh was the one who knew how to deal with lightning bending (which apparently is also sufficiently accessible that even gifted youths can perform it).

quote:
I'm super curious about his blood bending though! One would guess that Katara would keep that knowledge to herself, maybe telling her water bending daughter and Korra but never anyone else who might try to use it. So does this mean that there have been more than the one blood bending savant? or did Katara make a mistake somewhere in her life.

Glad to see Sokka kept his "wolf-tail."

Well, what one bender can discover, surely another could independently. It would even seem likely, because if I'm not mistaken, particularly powerful water benders can sometimes even feel the water in an opponent's body when the moon is full. There being a whole lot of water benders all over the world, and it being a century later, well...
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I don't think Katara will leave the south pole. I think Aang will explain the whole thing to Korra when she finally hits the spirit world. She'll have to have a breakthrough at some point in the next few episodes.
 
Posted by TheTick (Member # 2883) on :
 
Korra will finally reach Aang/the spirit world while meditating in the car, and will be rescued by Lin Beifong. That's what I'm expecting.

This post has an interesting theory of what is happening in the flashbacks. I'd be surprised if that's not right, or at least mostly right.
 
Posted by Foust (Member # 3043) on :
 
That's very clever.
 
Posted by Foust (Member # 3043) on :
 
I saw the first episode of TLA a while back, and hated it. I gave Korra a shot on a whim, and have been loving it. I'm halfway through season 3 of TLA now. I've been converted.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
Yeah the first 2-3 episodes of TLA I felt were pretty weak introduction to the series.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Rakeesh:
quote:
HA! HA! I CALLED IT! TARLOK!

WOW!

Wow!

That episode was INTENSE.

Well, I mean Tarlak being a bad guy was a pretty easy get, man! But yes. Intense to say the least.

Well I had a bet going with my girlfriend, I had bet Tarlok was going to eventually be the, or one of, the main antagonist.
 
Posted by Olivet 2.0 (Member # 12719) on :
 
My kids and I have been watching all along, but this was the episode that finally won my oldest over. He's of the mind that Korra needs to see a bit of the world outside Republic city and he's really hoping this will be part of it. I'm not so sure that it being Republic City-centric is a negative, though.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
After all the wilderness hopping of TLAB I've enjoyed the city, but it will be interesting to see the outside for a while not to mention where exactly Tarlok is taking her.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
I'm excited for an appearance of Zuko, and I think this is just the time to bring him in.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
Aaarg! That episode doesn't seem to be posted on the Nick site. I knew that would happen eventually. What are my options?
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
e-z no sub version:

tv-links dot eu

hunt for a good download
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
iTunes.

It's cheap. And it's worth it. Seriously, this show deserves your money, don't be a jerk.
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
they get my money anyway, it's just that we like to watch on release and nickelodeon likes to fail to provide it, whee!
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
We are sort of being a jerk to HBO though; we are trying really seriously hard to give them money but they are really having a hard time at making obviously good decisions about money
 
Posted by TheTick (Member # 2883) on :
 
I would've sworn that episode was on the site a few days ago. You know, it was on our cable's On Demand feature and then dropped off, too. Though I figured it's because it had been entered in with the wrong information (just appeared as "6/2" on the episode list instead of "Korra 108" like the rest) and they were working to put it back.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
It's there now. I just watched it. Phew! But I'm still waiting for "Out of the Past".
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Wooh.

Spoilers ahead, don't read unless you've seen Out of the Past.

*************************************

*************************************

*************************************

I guess I was wrong, he only lasted for one episode!

I hope we get more insight into Amon, I'm really liking the Amon is/is backed by Koh theory.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
More Spoilers.


*************************************

SPOILERS

*************************************

SPOILERS

*************************************

SPOILERS

Also, its weird that the visions of Yakone always appeared when Amon was around. There must be more to Yakone.
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
Just out of curiosity, how many episodes are left this season?
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
This was episode nine, so... three more? It is twelve episodes for the first season right?

Edit to confirm.

Yup, season one is twelve episodes and season two will be fourteen.

Three episodes left to wrap up the Amon arc.

[ June 10, 2012, 07:44 PM: Message edited by: AchillesHeel ]
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
In two weeks is the one hour finale.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
tarlok went down fast, wish he had a bit more of a fight to him. I like villains who are more like Gilgamesh, people with the Will To Power and what not.

Amon continues to be interesting, kinda still bummed that Katara hasnt had a heart to heart with Aang yet and instead just visions.

Increasing the tensions in the love triangle and Asami being all worried and clingy seemed a little contrived.
 
Posted by Foust (Member # 3043) on :
 
Eh, they're teenagers.

I liked Tarlok's downfall; after all, Amon did something that should have been completely impossible. It was a great reveal.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Has anyone else entertained the abstract possibility that Amon is Aang? Amon has done two things so far only The Avatar can do, and Katara has yet to airbend even a little.

Aang could have glitched the Avatar line when he did the whole disconnect/reconnect thing.
 
Posted by manji (Member # 11600) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by AchillesHeel:
Katara has yet to airbend even a little.

I should hope so. Katara is a little old lady living at the South Pole.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Hahaha...
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Korra has demonstrated a little air bending in the tournament arc. She moved instinctively like an airbender.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Moved. Not airbended.

She has spent her life learning forms, it stands to reason that Korra could learn the physical form but if she is somehow not a full Avatar she has no way to access the power of airbending.

If Aang learned how to use energy-bending to block a persons ability to bend he could have also learned how to open the chi passages manually. When Aang was at his most powerful as an adult Avatar the city he built was still filled with benders oppressing innocent people. Amon has caused no fatalities and when he first showed his ability to remove a persons bending it was on the worst criminals, Bolin just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. If Amon is amoral then why does he go so far to not take lives in his revolution?
 
Posted by Vasslia Cora (Member # 7981) on :
 
Didn't Korra use airbending to cut the ropes thrown at her in the last episode?
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by AchillesHeel:
Moved. Not airbended.

She has spent her life learning forms, it stands to reason that Korra could learn the physical form but if she is somehow not a full Avatar she has no way to access the power of airbending.

If Aang learned how to use energy-bending to block a persons ability to bend he could have also learned how to open the chi passages manually. When Aang was at his most powerful as an adult Avatar the city he built was still filled with benders oppressing innocent people. Amon has caused no fatalities and when he first showed his ability to remove a persons bending it was on the worst criminals, Bolin just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. If Amon is amoral then why does he go so far to not take lives in his revolution?

No one ever said Amon was amoral - he's just on the opposite side of the main characters. It's entirely possible for him to be a random guy who genuinely cares about peaceably shifting power away from the benders.
 
Posted by Belle (Member # 2314) on :
 
I still think Amon is Bumi.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
quote:
Originally posted by AchillesHeel:
Moved. Not airbended.

She has spent her life learning forms, it stands to reason that Korra could learn the physical form but if she is somehow not a full Avatar she has no way to access the power of airbending.

If Aang learned how to use energy-bending to block a persons ability to bend he could have also learned how to open the chi passages manually. When Aang was at his most powerful as an adult Avatar the city he built was still filled with benders oppressing innocent people. Amon has caused no fatalities and when he first showed his ability to remove a persons bending it was on the worst criminals, Bolin just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. If Amon is amoral then why does he go so far to not take lives in his revolution?

No one ever said Amon was amoral - he's just on the opposite side of the main characters. It's entirely possible for him to be a random guy who genuinely cares about peaceably shifting power away from the benders.
Right.

He stripped Lin's cops of their bending too. He's clearly sincere about his desire to remove all bending, not just bending from those who misuse it. That doesn't sound anything like Aang to me.

Don't get me wrong, I think Amon is awesome. He's a great, and surprisingly sympathetic given how enigmatic he is, villain. I was hoping he'd be the one to rescue Korra from Tarrlok, and that played out better than I could've possibly imagined.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
If Aang taught Bumi energy-bending it still wouldn't account for Amon pushing through the blood-bending. Also I don't see a child raised by Aang and Katara resorting to terrorism and anti-bender activism, they were the shining examples of how bending can be used for the greater good. No matter how weird it must be to be the only non-bending child of a water-bending master and The Avatar.
 
Posted by mr_porteiro_head (Member # 4644) on :
 
"Good" people end up with "crappy" kids all the time. We have almost no information about what it was like growing up in their family. It's easy to see how a non-bender child of the Avatar could grow up resenting bending.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Amon=Yakone is where my money's going right now.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
My friend's new theory is that Amon is a robot. That's why he was immune to bloodbending. No blood. The slight discomfort was probably Tarrlok bending his lubricant, but there wasn't enough to actually stop him.

At first I dismissed this idea as obviously foolish, since Lin would've noticed immediately if Amon was made of metal. Unless, of course, he's a platinum robot.

Now it all makes perfect sense.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
quote:
He stripped Lin's cops of their bending too. He's clearly sincere about his desire to remove all bending, not just bending from those who misuse it. That doesn't sound anything like Aang to me.

Don't get me wrong, I think Amon is awesome. He's a great, and surprisingly sympathetic given how enigmatic he is, villain. I was hoping he'd be the one to rescue Korra from Tarrlok, and that played out better than I could've possibly imagined.

I don't actually stand by my point because the giant war machine robots suggest otherwise. But my point was Amon could want to remove all bending (because he sees bending as a source of inequality and evil) while still wanting to minimize casualties and avoid bloodshed.

I like the robot theory but I don't think it's true - he did STRUGGLE to resist the bloodbending. I saw it as a "Amon has majestic control over his own energy" (necessary for energy bending), and presumably bloodbending can be at least somewhat resisted (if people didn't have some ability to fight back, it wouldn't normally require the full moon)
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
quote:
He stripped Lin's cops of their bending too. He's clearly sincere about his desire to remove all bending, not just bending from those who misuse it. That doesn't sound anything like Aang to me.

Don't get me wrong, I think Amon is awesome. He's a great, and surprisingly sympathetic given how enigmatic he is, villain. I was hoping he'd be the one to rescue Korra from Tarrlok, and that played out better than I could've possibly imagined.

I don't actually stand by my point because the giant war machine robots suggest otherwise. But my point was Amon could want to remove all bending (because he sees bending as a source of inequality and evil) while still wanting to minimize casualties and avoid bloodshed.

I like the robot theory but I don't think it's true - he did STRUGGLE to resist the bloodbending. I saw it as a "Amon has majestic control over his own energy" (necessary for energy bending), and presumably bloodbending can be at least somewhat resisted (if people didn't have some ability to fight back, it wouldn't normally require the full moon)

Oh god, the robot theory had better not be true! She didn't mean it seriously in the slightest!
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
Amon's identity is going to be a big surprise, I think. I just saw "out of the past" today. Is there another one up yet?
 
Posted by Vadon (Member # 4561) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by ak:
Amon's identity is going to be a big surprise, I think. I just saw "out of the past" today. Is there another one up yet?

SPECULATIVE SPOILERS!

That's the most recent one I've seen. I've spent the past couple weeks rewatching the original Avatar. One thing worth noting is that energy bending is not restricted to the Avatar. The Lion-Turtle which taught it to Aang said that before the time of the Avatar when the elements were divided, people would bend pure energy. Another thing the turtle explained is that the person who uses energy bending to seal a person's bending must stem from an absolute spirit or some such. Basically, unless you're completely in control, it will back fire. This suggests that Amon, having successfully energy bent, must have some pure motive which he believes in fully-even if it's pure evil.

I like the idea of Koh(?) the face-stealer having taught it to Amon, but given that he seems to still have eyes, it doesn't seem like his face was actually stolen when there was that monkey thing without a face in the spirit world--including its eyes. Also, Koh is accessed via the spirit world, which supposedly only the Avatar can link to. This builds credibility to the argument that Amon is (in some way) the Avatar (a split, a fluke, whatever.

My two theories:

Amon was taught energy bending by the owl creature in the desert library. He would have information on energy bending as his library is the accumulation of all knowledge. The Owl's objection to people in his library is that they use the information for violence or to gain an advantage. Amon's stated goal is equality. That might have convinced the Owl to let him use the library.

My second theory is that Amon is somehow related to Fire Lord Ozai. If Ozai had a son after the events of the original series (perhaps in a banishment after prison) he could have told his son about how he had a dream that all people would unite under the flag of the fire nation, but the avatar and benders of other nations destroyed his dream. Amon could be acting to either 1: seek redemption for his family by getting rid of bending so another event like that could never happen again or 2: believes that his father was right and that people need to be united under a single flag but cannot do so with the national divisions rooted in bending.
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
This is just something I wanted to share with all of you (click play at the top).

That's a remake of the song "Leaves on the Vine". It's so sad and I really like the part where Iroh sings it. For those who don't remember, Iroh lost his son in the war and every year on his son's birthday, he sings this song in rememberence of him. It's quite possibly the saddest thing I've ever seen in a kid's cartoon.

Edited to add: I also found a youtube version of the song here. Check it out!

[ June 17, 2012, 10:22 PM: Message edited by: Jeff C. ]
 
Posted by Scott R (Member # 567) on :
 
quote:
Koh is accessed via the spirit world, which supposedly only the Avatar can link to.
Uncle Iroh went there as well.

In the episode where Aang went to see the Face-stealer-- the ones where the network did pop-up bubbles of trivia- it was hinted that Iroh's son also went there and lost his face to the Face-stealer. That was why Iroh went.
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
I'd like to see a comic or maybe a one or two episode arch that explains Iroh's backstory more. He was such a cool character and you could tell that he had a vast history, full of adventures and character growth.
 
Posted by mr_porteiro_head (Member # 4644) on :
 
I always wanted to know more about him as well.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
Anyone else catch the science error in Ammon's plan for subduing Korra in "Out Of The Past"?

The metal cage would act like a Faraday cage, making it impossible to shock her even if she were touching the inside.
 
Posted by JonHecht (Member # 9712) on :
 
I pointed it out to my girlfriend, then ended up explaining Faraday cages to her.

It was pretty cool, because knowing about them seems to get me a lot of mileage in terms of "random trivia" at bars and on Facebook (why don't microwaves hurt you, why are you safe in a car/plane during a lightning storm, etc.). Plus I always get to rewatch with them a video of a guy in a Faraday cage next to a massive Tesla coil.

So, in conclusion, spotted it.

Edit: Apparently the internet did too.
http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/faraday-cage

Edit2: And the response was quick. I don't know anything about Faraday cages past my memory from high school so I can't assess this:

"I just wanna say that I appreciate people flaunting their physics knowledge. Physics is rad. But I’m pretty sure out of all the people working on LoK, SOMEONE took Electromagnetism in school. This “Toph box” (as I heard it referred to on the latest RCDispatch) looks to be solid metal (platinum maybe?) except at the top, where the grating is spaced out large enough that Korra could probably fit her hand through. In a Faraday cage, electricity is distributed throughout a uniform surface, resulting in a total charge of zero volts. The Toph box is NOT uniform. If Korra hadn’t been quick witted, she would have been toast."
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
Well, no cage is perfectly uniform. Whether the deviations from uniformity in Korra's box would be enough to make it possible to electrocute her through it, I couldn't say. It would probably also depend on how strong the battery was.

But volts are a unit of potential, not charge. [Razz]
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
For example, the cage the two girls are in two posts down on your Tumblr link doesn't look much less uniform than Korra's box.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Brave choice, bringing back the Zuko voice actor. I don't know if I like it yet, it may prove to be a hurdle in separating my opinion of the two characters. Unless they are supposed to essentially be the same anyway.

My question is, son? or grand-son?

If Zuko had kids around the same time as the rest of team Avatar Iroh II would be old enough to have grey hair, so I'm thinking grand-son.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
Yeah, he's the grandson.

Once I realized that I became more okay with the same voice actor being used. The Dante Basco gene skips a generation, y'know.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I hear it is a recessive gene, usually inherited from the maternal side much like male pattern baldness.
 
Posted by Shanna (Member # 7900) on :
 
Has anyone heard theory going around that Zuko had a daughter who married Aang's son Bumi and they are Iroh's parents? Apparently, on the official Legend of Korra family tree, Bumi is wearing a fire nation collar. There also is a strong family resemblance in terms of jawline when you compare Iroh to Bumi or Aang.

LoK Family Tree
 
Posted by Xavier (Member # 405) on :
 
Am I the only one that thinks its odd that Bumi and Kya both ended up a few shades darker than even Katara?

Here's a comparison I just did in Gimp:

Aang, Katara, Bumi, Kya

Usually (in our world), offspring of a dark skinned and a light skinned person will meet somewhere in the middle. Even if sometimes that comes down much closer to one parent than the other, its still along the spectrum.

Not something I'm upset about or anything, just think its somewhat strange.
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
Does anyone else want to see more of Sokka? He was my favorite character in TLA. I'd like to know what happened to him (aside from his being on the original council) and whether he had kids or not.
 
Posted by C3PO the Dragon Slayer (Member # 10416) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by AchillesHeel:
Brave choice, bringing back the Zuko voice actor. I don't know if I like it yet, it may prove to be a hurdle in separating my opinion of the two characters. Unless they are supposed to essentially be the same anyway.

My question is, son? or grand-son?

If Zuko had kids around the same time as the rest of team Avatar Iroh II would be old enough to have grey hair, so I'm thinking grand-son.

My brother and I freaked out at the reveal. And my brother hasn't even finished watching the first season of TLA yet.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Tomorrow is the big finale! Little more than 12 hours until we have another year and a half to wait!
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
SPOILER:


So much for the Bumi theory.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
MAJOR SPOILERS

Great ending. What I like about it is that it could have stopped here and I would have been satisfied. I'd still like to know more, especially since they sort of tacked on the solution at the very end, but I guess they didn't have the time they did with Aang.

Was any one else pretty sad when Taarlock blew up the boat? I thought one of them would reveal that the bending could be restored and they'd come back next season, but that was surprisingly touching.

Nice to see Korra finally hit the Avatar state and have bending return, also nice that she can finally airbend. It'll be interesting to see what they throw at her next season now that she's a fully realized Avatar. But I'm glad they tied things up so I'm not antsy for the next year and a half.
 
Posted by Xavier (Member # 405) on :
 
quote:
Was any one else pretty sad when Taarlock blew up the boat? I thought one of them would reveal that the bending could be restored and they'd come back next season, but that was surprisingly touching.
I almost never tear up in movies and shows, but that got me somehow. I'm not entirely sure why.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
For me, I think it might have been the thwarted expectations. When I saw Tarlock glancing at the gauntlets and then at his brother's back and back again, I felt pretty sure we would see the cycle of hatred and revenge continue with him attacking and killing his brother. He might then be a recurring villain of sorts, however sincere his words in the cell in the attic.

Instead, we see that he HAS moved beyond all of that hatred and vengeance...but he wasn't able to be hopeful for the future, either. For himself or his brother. The animation played a part, too, his expression was particularly bereft.
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
I think the part that really got me was the look on Amon/Noah Tuk's face. He knew what his brother was going to do and accepted it.

Tarlok could have left with his brother in their youth and saved him, he didn't then but he would now.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Why? Because he shed some tears? He was specifically speaking of the future they would have together, and how nothing would stand in their way. That's not at all what someone who knew his brother was about to kill them both would say.

As for saving Noahtuk, well, maybe. Doesn't seem likely, though, present or past. He was still an extraordinarily powerful water and blood bender, and his ambition didn't seem curbed.

[ June 23, 2012, 04:59 PM: Message edited by: Rakeesh ]
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
He doesn't shed any tears until his brother opens the gas tank and readies the glove. I assumed being an extremely powerful bloodbender might give him better sense of people around him. (In the Promise comic Toph mentions she can feel metal moving even without being in contact with it)

We see that Noahtuk is not a fan of their father, neither of them are, and they have both realized they have become their father, defeated by the avatar and all.

I meant saved in a more spiritual sense, by killing them he ended the cruelty and violence of both of them.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I was quite literally wowed by the season finale.

I'm happy Bolin got his chance to step up in the end battle, it looked like he finally could fight a Sato-bot one on one.

In the end I only have two negative thoughts.
1. Iroh II seems to be an extremely archetypal medium of Mako and Zuko. This allowed him to just be thrown into the mix without sticking out, but makes for a poor character and shows a willingness to pull rabbits out of hats for no reason to advance an otherwise very well written story.
2. Now I really really really can't wait for the next season. Bumi seems awesome, I can't wait.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by T:man:
He doesn't shed any tears until his brother opens the gas tank and readies the glove. I assumed being an extremely powerful bloodbender might give him better sense of people around him. (In the Promise comic Toph mentions she can feel metal moving even without being in contact with it)

We see that Noahtuk is not a fan of their father, neither of them are, and they have both realized they have become their father, defeated by the avatar and all.

I meant saved in a more spiritual sense, by killing them he ended the cruelty and violence of both of them.

It makes me think of Cain and Abel, and the whole "I am not my brothers keeper" idea. I think Tarlok was taking responsibility for his own actions and those of his brother rather than looking out for himself as usual. With how powerful Noatuk was, that moment on the boat with his defenses down was the only real chance to end his bloody path, Tarlok knowing all too well how easy it is to follow in their fathers ways made sure that everything that poisoned them would end. No more of that particular blood bending, the blood-line of Yakon has run dry and the world of Avatar is better for it. I find Tarlok's sacrifice very heroic indeed.
 
Posted by Belle (Member # 2314) on :
 
Major Spoilers
-
-
-
-
-
-
-

That finale was an emotional roller coaster! I loved every second of it. I want to see more Uncle Bumi!

I knew it was Aang walking up to her, but still teared up when I he said "But you called me here" [Cry]
 
Posted by Shanna (Member # 7900) on :
 
I hadn't really been too impressed by the finale with the exception of the boat scene and Aang's appearance. I still can't believe they even did that boat scene on a Nick show!

I'm starting to think that my expectations for the show are just too high, in general. I think my primary complaint is that I just don't care about any of the main characters. I really like Tenzin and Lin but that's it. The love triangle has made it nearly impossible for me to even like Mako much less cheer for him. They've done absolutely nothing to develop Bolin which I find extremely depressing because its obvious that he's kind of the Sokka of the group, and I love me some Sokka! Asami's storyline with her father had some potential and, like with Sokka, I love having a non-bender amongst benders.

As for Korra, I don't feel like she learned anything or has really developed as a character at all. With Aang, I felt like he was growing and maturing as a person with each challenge. Early in the season there was all this stuff about how being an Avatar, especially in regards to airbending, means embracing the spiritual side. I really kept expecting some sort of scene where Korra realizes that running into danger and throwing punches isn't always the best way to take control of a conflict. I'm excited that Korra is a fully realized Avatar now but I don't feel like she's earned it, so emotionally it means very little to me.

The fight scenes are INCREDIBLE but the story and characters have been very disappointing. I really just expected more from this show.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I will say I was a little disappointed with how Korra got to her spiritual side. Aang was there from the beginning because of his Air Temple training, but he worked at it for years whereas Korra seems to have just stumbled into it. I feel that by not working for it, it's not really worth as much.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
I agree. It was moving, but not especially good storytelling, I thought. I don't think they quite sold the connection, for Korra, between airbending and the Avatar's spiritual connection. Had they done so, the ending would've made more sense.

For awhile, though, I thought it would be a reformulation of the first show-she has Air nailed, and has to travel about connecting with the other three elements!
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
Rakeesh, that would have been a cool direction. I agree with you.

I'm curious about where they will take it now. I know originally they just had this first season mapped out and that would be it, but now that they've promised another 14 episodes, I have to wonder what else they can do. I think the first season could have been longer, possibly another 10 episodes to develop the characters and make their resolutions mean more, like Korra's spiritual journey. I personally would have enjoyed more scenes with her talking to Aang, just like when he talked to Roku. Maybe there will be more room for that later.

I'd like to see them explore the characters and have their abilities grow. The original show was so great because each character evolved, not just on a spiritual and maturity level, but also in terms of their skills. Each bender achieved another level that was beyond anything they had ever imagined (bloodbending, dragon fire, metal bending). Even Sokka had a chance to develop into a master swordsman. So far all of the characters in Korra have essentially stayed at the same level and we haven't seen much development, which really feels like a waste. The characters have always made this universe so much fun, so I'm sad that we haven't seen as much with them. Hopefully next season we can get some deeper resolutions.

Otherwise, I really enjoyed the finale. I thought the battles were solid, obviously, but I also liked seeing Amon's resolution. I thought it was handled decently, albeit abruptly. In that regard, I think it should have been longer with more of a build up. That's the problem you get when you only do 12 episodes for a season and you have so many characters. It's just not enough time. Maybe if they had focused less on the tournament and more on the characters then maybe it would have been better. Who knows.
 
Posted by Shanna (Member # 7900) on :
 
Lyr, I feel like Korra's journey is supposed to be the opposite of Aang's. He started with all the spiritual understanding but he lacked the desire to act. We got to see reluctance when it came to accepting his responsibilities as the Avatar. We saw how his evasive style and tendency towards avoidance made it difficult for him to learn earth-bending. We saw how fear held him back when it came to fire-bending.

And yet, Korra just magically gets air-bending. I liked where they were going with the dreams and flashbacks. But they often felt more like info-dumps rather than emphasizing that Korra was willing to embrace her spiritual side and resist action in favor of inaction.

Yep, they should have cut a tournament episode in favor of more airbending training. Think of all the awesome Tenzin moments! Because what I love most about him is that he's not like Iroh (the original), he's not the perfect voice of wisdom, he's just a guy who has to learn to be a teacher as much as Korra needs to learn to be a student.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
So the airbending chakra is for Love Grief and Heart.

Korra loves Nagga more than anyone else, but did she really have the opportunity to learn how to open her heart to others while being raised by a bunch of serious old men who were training her all the time?

Did she have anything to regret before she reached the city? any pain or tragedy? No.

And heart, she had plenty of vigor but is that really the same? She was happy to plunge into most anything with no fear but was always disheartened when there was no instant gratification. Even when Asami showed up, Korra immediately was depressed even though she had yet to admit her feelings for Mako. She was ready to give up "being" the Avatar just because she couldn't automatically air-bend.

Think about the power Aang unleashed immediately after receiving what should have been a death blow in the fight against the Fire-Lord, and plus Aang said it himself "when we are at our lowest, we are open to the greatest change." Amon may have severed her physical neural connections to her other bending, but the energy of The Avatar was still inside her and had to go somewhere. I'm not surprised that between her physical training in air-bending technique and that violent flood gate introduction to air-bending chakra, she could easily disarm Amon so readily with nothing but air when Tenzin and family were powerless against him.
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
This season wrap-up was so painfully abrupt and forced and tie-everything-up-with-a-bow-on-top that I think I shall call it Korra's Moving Castle.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Shanna:
Lyr, I feel like Korra's journey is supposed to be the opposite of Aang's. He started with all the spiritual understanding but he lacked the desire to act. We got to see reluctance when it came to accepting his responsibilities as the Avatar. We saw how his evasive style and tendency towards avoidance made it difficult for him to learn earth-bending. We saw how fear held him back when it came to fire-bending.

And yet, Korra just magically gets air-bending. I liked where they were going with the dreams and flashbacks. But they often felt more like info-dumps rather than emphasizing that Korra was willing to embrace her spiritual side and resist action in favor of inaction.

Yep, they should have cut a tournament episode in favor of more airbending training. Think of all the awesome Tenzin moments! Because what I love most about him is that he's not like Iroh (the original), he's not the perfect voice of wisdom, he's just a guy who has to learn to be a teacher as much as Korra needs to learn to be a student.

I agree it was supposed to basically be the opposite, they just didn't do it as well as Aang because of time constraints. They actually showed Aang over the course of three seasons struggling with the question of how to act decisively, how to take things head on, how to deal with having to possibly kill, etc. And they also dealt with his spiritual journey as well, which came easier to him, but was still a challenge.

Korra starts off having the physical side mastered and they tell us she struggles with the spiritual side. Then with no work at all, she just GETS it at the end. No work, no learning moments, nothing like what Aang had to go through, it just happens.

They really should have cut all that Mako-Korra-Asami stuff and focused more on the characters. There simply wasn't time for a love triangle in this season.
 
Posted by Rakeesh (Member # 2001) on :
 
Ugh, yes, I could've done without that love triangle-or at least not such a cliched one. It also would've been nice had Korra said, at the end, "Wait, wait, I love you, but you're with Asami right now, so we can't do this." Don't get me wrong, it doesn't damn her as a coward or traitor or anything like that-people get caught up all the time, after all-but it still would've been nice.

The way they wrapped up some of the elements was very, very rushed, though I did enjoy it. Being stripped of 75% of her bending for...what, about eight minutes of screen time?...was a bit silly. Would've been nice to see more of a resolution between the Sato family.

I agree with whoever said some of the tournament stuff and some of the love triangle stuff could've been cut, but really, I think the season just needed more episodes. Quite a few! [Smile]
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
I agree with the complaints about the love triangle; especially since it's one of those love triangles where the person in the center (Mako) really, really doesn't deserve it. That triangle ought to have been resolved by both Korra and Asami realizing they are way too awesome for him.

I didn't really mind the rushed quality. This isn't the first episode this season that's felt rushed. Honestly, that's Avatar for you. Season 3, especially the second half, of TLA was also incredibly rushed. It's a great show, and I'm happy to roll with it, but in general the pacing of their climaxes tends to be pretty fast.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I thought S3 was pretty solid. At that point they'd completed all the set up and they spent four episodes on the finale.
 
Posted by Foust (Member # 3043) on :
 
quote:
Korra starts off having the physical side mastered and they tell us she struggles with the spiritual side. Then with no work at all, she just GETS it at the end. No work, no learning moments, nothing like what Aang had to go through, it just happens.
There's a theory over on the AV Club that Korra intended to jump off the cliff. Her entire identity had just been stripped from her, and she was finished.

Pulling back from the edge was her moment of enlightenment.

I'd say overcoming a moment of suicidal despair qualifies as a learning moment. Yeah, rushed, but not quite as easy as everyone seems to be making it out to be.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Eh...

That's an interesting theory.

Frankly I think it would have been interesting to see her dealing with not being the full Avatar. Otherwise it feels like the message from the end is you're not special unless you're special. You can't deal with being normal, so either their needs to be a magical solution to bring your specialness back, or you kill yourself.

One of the reasons why Zuko was so compelling is he had to go through that journey. He lived as a pauper, he lived without firebending for a long time. He grew, and he became a different, better person. Instead they took her powers away for half a day and then gave them back. Meh.
 
Posted by Belle (Member # 2314) on :
 
Well, I have spent probably way too much time thinking and analyzing this and I've come to look at it this way.

I think she was not the Avatar for longer than half a day, to start. They traveled to Katara, to the southern water tribe. Bumi and Iroh were not with them, presumably, the military stayed in Republic City a bit (Tenzin had to "entertain" his brother, based on his comment.) They had to get Lin back,and then travel to Katara. They didn't all ride on Oogi (Naga was with them). She was not the avatar long enough to keenly feel the loss, and to contemplate it - but all her hope was wrapped up in Katara. No one truly believed Katara couldn't fix Korra - look at Lin's insistence that she keep trying, for example.

Korra's identity is very much an individualist bent...she does not like to depend on others. Witness her desire to go confront Amon. She didn't turn Mako away, but she didn't ask him to come with her either. She is not used to depending on people, why should she? She has been able to bend three elements from a very young age. (And you gotta deal with it!)

I look at Air bending and its spiritual nature as one of selflessness and humility. Look at how Tenzin embodies that by providing all to his family, and by his service to Republic City. Aang always knew he needed others, and was not at all shy about accepting their teaching, and their help. For Korra, who got the first three elements pretty much on her own, she's never truly learned to rely on others. Sure, she had masters that helped her refine her control of the elements, but she already could bend them. Airbending was so difficult for her because she never released her self-reliance and really allowed Tenzin to teach her.

When everything else was gone, and she couldn't fall back on what she herself knew and could do - that was when the airbending came. She had no choice, and at that moment she was helpless and seeing someone she cared for about to be destroyed, as she thought she had just been. She forgot about herself in that moment and only cared about protecting Mako - that selflessness allowed the airbending to come through. Notice, however, she still hasn't mastered it - she slung air around like a firebender, so she hasn't truly mastered it.

Now, flash forward to the last couple scenes. When Mako declares his love, she can't reciprocate - she hates herself in that moment, doesn't feel worthy. The fleeing on Naga was her running from the life she doesn't believe she deserves to have anymore - one with friends, and people who love and accept her.

The tears, including the one that called Aang - this was Korra giving up - not suicidal, I don't believe that. It was her releasing all the strength, all the individualism, everything that made her that bold little toddler that announced herself to the White Lotus. It was Korra humbling herself, and realizing she could not fix things on her own - she could not do it all. She became, finally, selfless and dependent. She needed help, and when she admitted that, Aang was able to come through and help her.

I too wish there had been at least one more episode, that we could have seen Korra struggle more with not being the Avatar, but given the time constraints, I think it was pretty well done. It rang true to me, and I liked it.

Of course, I am an unemployed English teacher with nothing to do since there are no new job postings, so I could be totally off base. [Smile]
 
Posted by TheTick (Member # 2883) on :
 
Belle, you've basically nailed my thoughts here. I loved it, and while there are things that I would change and that were a bit silly, for a Nickelodeon kids show, this adult was pretty emotionally invested in the ending.
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
that finale was, looking back at it, the worst of all worlds in terms of an artificially constrained cessation of a buildup period. You work all the way up to this and .. chop. done. meh.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
Up until the last few minutes, I was really looking forward to a season 2 that explored Korra sans Avatar-powers, that culminated in her getting them back but not before she had gone through a lot of introspection, with the show continuing to exmaine the interplay between benders and non-benders and the modern world.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
Up until the last few minutes, I was really looking forward to a season 2 that explored Korra sans Avatar-powers, that culminated in her getting them back but not before she had gone through a lot of introspection, with the show continuing to exmaine the interplay between benders and non-benders and the modern world.

That sounds a lot like the ground they already tread with A:TLA, though. I'm excited for the possibility that we're going (once again) into unknown territory here, with a story about an Avatar in (more or less) full control of her powers. We never got that with Aang.

Edited to add: I'm with Bella here. The finale had some pacing issues, to be sure, but I'm quite satisfied with the resolution of the story overall. The "Amon a boat" scene was simply incredible - I got the same "HOLY CRAP DID THEY REALLY JUST GO THERE" chills that I got from some of the darkest moments of A:TLA (*ahem* end of Season 2). And Korra's meeting with Aang and her long-awaited entry into the Avatar State, coupled with the most powerful rendition of the main Avatar theme we've ever heard, was spectacular.

And I *do* think Korra was contemplating suicide. The key moment is the tear falling into the abyss. I also think Amon knew what Tarrlok was about to do - again, the tear gives it away.
 
Posted by Belle (Member # 2314) on :
 
The only way I see Korra contemplating suicide is the idea that if she killed herself, the world would get a new Avatar - a real avatar, that could properly bend all the elements.

Still, that fits my theory - if so, then she was no longer thinking of herself, but as doing something selfless (though I personally have big problems with considering suicide a noble act or one that is truly selfless, so I hope the story writers weren't really going there). Again, that selflessness allows her connection to Aang to be fulfilled. For whatever reason the tear was shed, it symbolized something profound that changed within her, allowing her to truly connect with the avatars.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
That's definitely a reasonable interpretation.

My own thoughts were closer to those described in the AV Club review - she is definitely thinking about jumping, but ultimately chooses not to. And her decision to live is what allows her to connect with her spiritual side. Hooray for protagonist agency!

To quote another great female television protagonist: "The hardest thing in this world is to live in it." Korra's realization of that painful truth (and her decision to pursue living in the world anyway) was the "something profound that changed within her" in my interpretation of the events.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
Finally saw the finale, then went back and reread everyone's thoughts posted here.

I thought it all seemed too tidy and quick. I hated the love triangle with Mako, because it was just sad, and I never saw what either of them saw in him. I didn't really believe in the feelings there, or in several other story arcs. I'm not happy Korra and Mako ended up together.

The Sato father and daughter story didn't ring true to me either. So I always expected something else was really going on, that she was secretly still on his side or something.

I liked Lin. I'm glad she got her bending back in the end, but will Korra restore all the bending that was taken away from all the other benders since Amon came? How did Amon use blood bending to take people's bending away, anyway? That never made good sense to me. The only thing that keeps fantasy from being utter mismash is there are rules about how things work. I felt like the rules were all broken and we're back to total mishmash with this one.

The way Aang came to Korra in the end isn't even anything like the way it would happen in the last series, that Aang would seek out the spiritual world and come there. This was like the spirit world just broke into Korra's real world or something. Sparkling into being like Spock in a transporter beam, and then disappearing just as quickly. Oh hey, maybe they invented spirit-world-transporters. Why not? It makes about as much sense as the rest of this stuff.

I guess they did succeed in making me care, or else I wouldn't feel disappointed, huh? None of these people seem as real to me as Aang, Katara, Sokka, and Toph did in the last series, though.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
I get the people that hated the Mako/Asami/Korra triangle. It was pretty terrible. Mako wasn't nearly good enough for either of them.

But I'm a little surprised at how surprised people are that it ended up that way. It was telegraphed from very early on. I guess people expected it to be subverted? But that's not really Avatar's style. Look at the romantic relationships in TLA. Aang and Katara were telegraphed from episode one and, frankly, never really impressed me either. Zuko and Mae came sort of out of left field, and also never felt particularly real or poignant.

About the only couple in TLA that seemed remotely cool and actually well matched was Sokka and Suki, and it took a long time for the show to make that happen.

I don't know. I think TLA was great, and I think Korra is great, but to me, their portrayals of romance have never been a big draw. In either case.

Like the complaints of hasty pacing, this feels a little bit like looking at TLA through rose-colored glasses.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I think some people are reading an awful lot into the moment where she's standing on the cliff. I'd really like to hear what the creators have to say about it.

Dan - I don't think anyone is really surprised by the how the romance ended. We're mostly just annoyed they wasted so much time with it.

ak - I liked the door they opened with the Sato Family story line, but I don't really think they did it any justice. They needed to spend more time showing just how unhinged Sato was, and more time with Asami as well. There was a ton of potential there for a great story. I feel like most of the heavy hitting stories in this were from peripheral characters. Taarlock/Noatuck. Lin/Tenzin. Pabu/Naga. Hiroshi/Asami. They just needed to spend more time on them and less on the love story.

And I agree on how Aang came to Korra at the end...though, they were a little wishy washy with Aang and Roku. In some episodes Roku told Aang he had to get to a certain place on the solstice to chat, but in other situations Roku just showed up and grabbed Aang for a ride-along. So I don't necessarily have a big problem with Aang just showing up, but their explanation for how Korra broke through wasn't really fulfilling for me.
 
Posted by Marek (Member # 5404) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by ak:
How did Amon use blood bending to take people's bending away, anyway?

It also made me wonder why Katara who was not just a master waterbender, and the greatest healer in the world, but also a master blood-bender herself, could not heal damage done by bloodbending. Why not wait till the full moon and try her healing then, when she can use her own bloodbending to fix it?
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
Answer: because bloodbending is not how he was taking powers away. That's spiritbending. The question remains where he got spiritbending from.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
Really, Sam?

I mean I've been of the opinion since the beginning that Amon wasn't really spiritbending, but I thought this was explicitly confirmed in the finale.

He was doing it wrong, for one thing. And then there's the Guru's explanation of the forehead chakra, for another.

Just seemed to me that what Amon was doing was some sort of advanced chi-blocking move. One that somehow required the use of bloodbending (didn't they say exactly this in the finale?)

It's true they never satisfactorily explained what that maneuver was. But then, chi-blocking in general was never thoroughly explained.

What elements of chi-blocking are physical and what aren't? Why does chi-blocking work? There's obviously a physical injury associated with it. Can a waterbender heal it and make it wear off sooner, or not?

Answers to those questions might explain why Katara couldn't help. She's a healer, but she wasn't a terribly good bloodbender (nowhere near as good as Yakone and his kids, certainly), and she knows nothing of chi-blocking as far as we know.

If Amon can use bloodbending to cause permanent injuries, he could have, say, permanently damaged their forehead chakra. That could account for permanent loss of bending, if I understand the Guru right.

But it's definitely still pretty unclear and undefined.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
Edit: Dang, beaten by four minutes. This was originally in reply to Sam.

I don't think so. My read was that Amon used bloodbending to permanently chi-block his targets - basically, what Ty Lee did using physical force, he did by pushing tissues around internally.

Katara is unable to heal Korra because she was using traditional waterbending healing techniques, not bloodbending herself. I suspect that even if she knew how to reverse Amon's chi-blocking effect, she wouldn't have the bloodbending skill to execute it - after all, she only really used bloodbending twice, whereas Amon has been practicing it nonstop for decades. And that completely leaves aside the question of whether Katara (who considers bloodbending an abomination) would be willing to use it at all, even for such a noble purpose.
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
worth discussing, i'm sure, but anyway let me crosspost my post about why the ending sucked:

______________

Here is what I come up with when I go back and really try to make sense of why I am disappointed with the ending: it comes down to the resolution of character and plot arcs hitting a brick wall of what appears to be a very artificial constraint.

Mako is stuck in a love triangle which has to be hammered out in a fraction of the time, so his character development abruptly stops and he becomes terrible. Asami is thrust off likewise and becomes little more than a spurned, disappointed point in a love triangle.

Bolin is even further hurled off to the wayside, all of his character development halts as well, and he becomes nothing but a series of comic-relief quotes abruptly injected into the story. His interaction on the ridge is a quintessential example of this; he appears, says something overly wacky to remind us all he is the wacky person, then, he literally removes himself off back into the background so as not to waste more time in the precious minutes that the show needs to take pretty much every issue and wrap it all up completely.

It is an overly and fittingly literal and direct version of what we realize we've been witnessing throughout the plot crunch at the end of the season: characters being distilled into an absolute barest and flattest minimum of their concept and personality in order to crunch them into a giant "and it all worked out" — character arcs are abruptly ceased, taking pretty much the entirety of the season's buildup and having to dispose of most of the payoff just in order to desperately fit as much complete resolution into the finale as possible.

It's an abrupt and dissatisfying disposal. Korra's buddies get chumped. Amon and the equalists, the overarching threat and conflict driving the entire season, melt off as quickly as Noahtok's makeup and leave people wondering 'so that's it then? just, boom, done like that?'

The end result of these abrupt end woes shows this off in interesting ways; the characters which benefit the most from the structure of the finale are the ones which HAVE to have their essential introductions fit into the finale, and so they come off the best (see: iroh), and the characters most central to the story and Korra's life so far come off the worst. Mako is the ultimate loser, because in order to wrap HIS part up as fast as everything else, he has to devolve into a pretty unlikable character that people were bound to complain about.

As I understand it, this is not the way the show's makers would have wanted it; it's a network constraint due to waffling on how much they were willing to commit to for this new series. I can see how it ended up this way; it's a little bit sad to watch the central conflicts of the entire season just sort of be burned up in a fire sale, with a number of twists and turns that really honestly should have had entire episodes devoted to them. Korra's conflict with Amon in which she loses her bending but awakens her airbending should have been about three episodes from the end; entire episodes should have been devoted to her struggling with her loss of identity as the avatar but clinging desperately to the hope that she can be healed. The episode immediately afterwards should have been her with Tenzin in the shantytown under the city, going through a role-reversal, where Korra rightfully demands a lesson in airbending which has no room for patience or indirectness, and where Tenzin has to oblige and gain an insight into the way her brashness can be developed as an asset. There should have been an episode in which bei fong and her have to work together while communally dealing with the reality of being Amon's victims. Perhaps the Lieutenant could have been pivotal to Korra's central conquest and revelation of Amon as a foe. Korra's spiritual awakening could have at barest minimum been turned into something which does not require very clever specific reading to figure out in order to figure out why Aang is there to all but say "Congratulations! You have advanced your Spirit level! Press OK to continue." There are literally so many ways to have turned this into an extremely satisfying ending that still fits the requirements of "and it all turned out amazing enough that this works if we don't have a following season!"

Most importantly, Mako, Bolin, & co needed plenty of time to branch and arc their character development satisfactorily.

Perhaps overexplained? I really do feel that these are legitimate complaints and that I did not have unrealistic expectations. The season ending was just a complete abandonment and disservice to the very sorts of character and plot niceties which make the Avatar series worth caring about in the first place.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
Not overexplained at all. I can definitely see where you're coming from, especially after rewatching the series over the past week.

I agree that Korra's story was weakened by the rushed schedule, and that she should have lost her bending earlier so we'd have time to absorb the implications both for her character and for the world around her. Plus, as you point out, it would've given us an opportunity to focus on Korra's airbending training, which was woefully underutilized in this season. But I thought her descent into despair and humility, and subsequent healing, were well done.

As for the other leads, I agree that Mako's character arc was severely shortchanged - what we're given over the course of Book 1 defines Mako as, basically, a gender-swapped Ginny Weasley, with all the irritating qualities that entails. However, I actually quite liked where they took the character of Asami. She was always more intriguing to me for her backstory with her father and her position as the non-bender of the group than for her role as the "other woman" in the main romance. As annoying as the Makorra stuff often was, that had nothing to do with how Asami herself was written, and everything to do with the writers' failure to give Mako any compelling attributes whatsoever. Honestly, I was glad they just skimmed over the ending of the Mako/Asami relationship and focused on her daddy issues. She has interesting daddy issues.

As for Bolin... ehh, I was OK with him being glorified comic relief for the latter half of Book 1 (and to be fair, he does get some great action beats in the last several episodes). He just doesn't have the personal investment in the plot that most of the other characters do, besides a generalized fear of losing his bending. I suspect/hope he'll get more to do in Book 2.

On a broader level, it's unfortunate that the interesting power dynamics between benders and non-benders were subsumed by the more direct Korra vs Tarrlok vs Amon conflict, but as I said before, I was still quite happy with how that was resolved, at least from a character standpoint. It's sort of like how the battle between the original Team Avatar and the Fire Nation ultimately boiled down to direct personal conflict between Aang and Zuko/ Azula/ Ozai, rather than necessarily focusing on the grander themes of elemental unity vs fragmentation. Though I'll grant that A:TLA did a better job of merging the human drama with the big picture themes than LoK has to date. I'm curious if the showrunners will be returning to the now-leaderless Equalists at all in Book 2. If they don't, then I'd agree with you that tossing the bender vs non-bender thematic elements to the side was something of a missed opportunity.

So yeah, I guess my opinion of the finale (and the season as a whole) has cooled a bit with distance, as there are some deep structural problems in the storytelling. But I still think it was a pretty strong season overall. It established an intriguing new version of the Avatarverse and featured some great characters in Lin, Tenzin, Amon, Tarrlok, Asami, and Korra herself, and did those characters justice in how the story resolved, even if it did so somewhat clumsily. I'm looking forward to see where the writers take the show in Book 2.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Dan_Frank:

About the only couple in TLA that seemed remotely cool and actually well matched was Sokka and Suki, and it took a long time for the show to make that happen.

You're forgetting Zuko and Katara. [Razz]
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
Hah!

Well, they had interesting chemistry the few times they interacted, I'll give you that.

I found Katara to be painfully obnoxious most of the time, so I don't much care who she ends up with.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
Oy, Zutara. I'm so glad they didn't go there.
 
Posted by Xavier (Member # 405) on :
 
I would have liked it better than Kataang. That for me fell quite flat. Maybe I just couldn't get past Aang seeming so much younger (prepubescent even). For that reason, I think Aang/Toph would have been a better pairing.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
Aang/ Toph might make sense in terms of age, but I don't see it from the standpoint of chemistry. They're too diametrically opposite in personality, and not in the "opposites attract" sort of way.

As for Kataang... well, Katara and Aang were two years apart, just like Katara and Zuko. Although in terms of perception, Zuko always felt to me significantly older than anyone in Team Avatar - he's even drawn like a guy in his early twenties, especially in the latter two seasons. Heck, Sokka is supposedly less than a year younger than Zuko, but he looks five years younger. So the age argument regarding Kataang never really held water for me. If a romance between a 12 year old and a 14 year old is weird, then so is a romance between a 14 year old and a 16 year old who looks and acts like he's 20.

And that doesn't even get into the inherent creepiness of the "oh! You pursued me/ tried to kill me for so long and that drew me to you like a moth to flame!!" stuff. The show itself made fun of that idea in "Ember Island Players."

*shrug* I guess Kataang never bothered me much, since it seemed obvious to me from the first episode that that was where they were going. And I'll take the slow burn romance built on mutual respect and affection over the BURNING HATE-TURNED-LURRRRVE OF MUTUAL A(a)NGST anyday.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Zutara would have left me totally unsatisfied for a lot of reasons, if not only because the "good girl/bad boy" trope is overplayed...especially when the bad boy in this case BURNED HER VILLAGE DOWN, and at several points not only tried to capture or kill them, but assisted Azula in actually killing Aang after betraying Katara's trust.

If she got past all that because he broods and makes a pouty face, I'd forever boycott the show. And I say that as someone who loves Zuko. He's my favorite character (tied with Iroh maybe) on the show, but that would have been stupid.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
Strongly disagree. After the scene where she almost healed his scar in the S1 finale, I knew they were meant for each other. That was one of the best scenes in the show, because of the chemistry between those two characters. You're right that by the season 2 finale, Zutara was ruined. They'd have had to play some of those events out differently to make a relationship credible. But it would have improved the show if they'd taken those steps and had the two end up together.

The age issue isn't that relevant to me, it's just that Aang isn't an interesting romantic male lead. I might feel that way partly because he's visually pre-pubescent, but it's also for the same reasons that Luke Skywalker wouldn't have worked very well in a romance: the character is spiritually occupied in a way that comes off as androgynous.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
Actually, the scene in which Katara almost heals Zuko's scar is in the second season finale, literally minutes before Zuko chooses to side with Azula against Aang and Katara. So the idea that Zutara was "birthed" in that scene and subsequently "ruined" by the Season 2 finale makes no sense, unless your romantic entanglements operate on a ridiculously short timescale.

In addition, the cave scene was one of the best scenes in the show because it showed Zuko at a moral crossroads, and Katara in a position where she, for the first time, understood that her enemies in the Fire Nation weren't all unmitigated evil. Any romantic chemistry between the characters was subtext, at best - the boldface textual interpretation is not that these two people are falling in love, but that they're both coming to an epiphany about the nature of their conflict.

And again, I think you're misremembering the show if you think there were events that could have played out differently to "make a relationship" credible, because that brief cave scene is literally the only moment in the entire series wherein we observe the slightest hint of romantic chemistry between Zuko and Katara. Seriously, I dare you to name another.

In contrast, the Katara and Aang romance is built up starting from their very first scene together. Aang's crush on Katara is obvious, but we see many scenes over the course of the series showing Katara's feelings growing for Aang in return. To name just one from each season, there's her realization that he is a "powerful bender" at the end of "The Fortuneteller," the did-they-or-didn't-they kiss in "The Cave" (which, might I remind you, Katara initiated), and of course, the dance scene in "The Headband" (prior to which we see some pretty obvious jealousy from Katara directed at On Ji, Aang's new Fire Nation friend).

So no, the text doesn't indicate at all that Katara and Zuko "were meant for each other." That was pure fanfic-ified speculation from the fans.

Edited to add: Also, I disagree that Aang isn't a "credible romantic lead." We've already discussed the age thing, which I agree is mildly problematic - but again, just as much so for ANY of the pairings on the show other than Sokka/ Suki. But with regards to the monk thing, nah. Aang's characterization is as much "impulsive teenager" as it is "quiet, spiritual monk." The idea that he's crushin' after Katara from the get go matches my experiences as an impulsive teenager who could also be shy and reflective quite well. And it doesn't seem at all weird to me that a smart, strong, empathetic girl might be drawn to a smart, strong, empathetic guy - it's actually sort of regressive, I think, to assume that girls can't be attracted to "effeminate" males like Aang, especially ones who can summon friggin' tornadoes with their minds.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
Wow, weird. I totally remembered that scene as happening in the S1 finale, but you're right, she only got the healing water at the end of that episode. You're right that they would've had to change things way more in order to make Zutara happen. My only claim is that it would've improved the show if they'd done this.

Anyway, I agree that the writers never intentionally set up Katara and Zuko to get together. But they're such a natural pairing. When I first started watching the show, I missed the first couple episodes and I was certain they were going to get Zuko and Katara together, just because they (unlike Katara and Aang) are the kind of couple that works on the screen. (I've never read any fanfic, for Avatar or anything else, except as a joke, so that wasn't my source for the idea.)

There are so many reasons "Zutara" would work better as a source of romantic drama. In a show like this, you want to go with archetypal character arcs that work. Here's one that works: once-bitter enemies are nonetheless attracted to each other and get together. There's a built-in source of tension that the couple's natural chemistry has to overcome.

Here's one that doesn't work: girl doesn't know if guy is "like a brother" to her or not. The attraction has to be lukewarm in order for there to be tension, or else the girl would not have mixed feelings, so the couple is forced to be portrayed as having bad chemistry. But that was the only way to introduce any tension into the Aang-Katara pairing. So of course, the couple comes across as uninspired.

Also, the age difference thing (although again, it's not the biggest deal-breaker for me) is more about Aang's youth in absolute terms than it is about the difference between their ages. I could believe a romance story between a 14-year-old and a 17-year-old, because those are two people who are both old enough to have hormone-driven crushes on the opposite sex. At 12, and a young-looking 12, Aang just doesn't come across as old enough to even like girls that way.

quote:
Aang's characterization is as much "impulsive teenager" as it is "quiet, spiritual monk." The idea that he's crushin' after Katara from the get go matches my experiences as an impulsive teenager who could also be shy and reflective quite well.
You don't think the same goes for Luke? Aang and Luke are very similar characters in a lot of ways. I really think this analogy holds up in a big way, and illustrates why Aang is not a good romantic lead. He's on a spiritual journey. That's the way he's maturing, not the going-after-girls way. His thing for Katara just doesn't fit with that.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
Heh. If your argument is going to hinge purely on "this thing feels better to me than the other thing," then I suspect we'll have to just agree to disagree. To me, a Zuko/Katara pairing feels unimaginative and cliche, not "natural" at all.

"Oh, I've hated you for so long! But I just can't resist you now that I understand that you aren't entirely a jerk!!!"

"Oh, I've pursued you for so long! But only now do I realize that the real pursuit was for your heart!!!"

Ugh. It's like the Twilight version of Avatar.

I've seen the "bad dude gets the good girl" thing done too often already, usually with the emotive success of a paper bag (Korra/ Mako falls squarely into this category). About the only time it "worked" at all, in my estimation, was with Buffy and Spike - and that was mostly because Spuffy was explicitly written as an exploration of how completely screwed up such a relationship would be.

In contrast, the canon relationship Aang and Katara feels more natural to me because it more accurately reflects how stable romantic love works in real life. Two people drawn together by circumstance, who develop mutual admiration and a deep friendship and whose feelings for each other derive from that.

It's not just about the "tension" between them - it's about each of them realizing, at varying times, that their friendship has bloomed into something even bigger and stronger. The tension in the story comes from the fact that Aang realizes this sooner and has fewer hangups about expressing it. Katara's more reserved by nature, and more focused on her responsibilities to the group, so she doesn't feel comfortable acting on her feelings until after the conclusion of the war - hence the conversation during "Ember Island Players." Once Ozai is defeated and Zuko is crowned, those roadblocks are removed and she seeks out Aang on her own.

It's a more subtle love story than the bodice-ripping passion of a hypothetical Zutara pairing, but one that rings far truer to me, personally.

quote:
You don't think the same goes for Luke? Aang and Luke are very similar characters in a lot of ways. I really think this analogy holds up in a big way, and illustrates why Aang is not a good romantic lead. He's on a spiritual journey. That's the way he's maturing, not the going-after-girls way. His thing for Katara just doesn't fit with that.
I don't see Aang and Luke as being particularly similar. They're both impetuous youths, but Aang has a clarity of spirit from the start that Luke is missing entirely in the first film. Luke doesn't achieve the spiritual monk aspect until the latter two films (and really, not until "Jedi"). He's an impetuous youth who TRANFORMS INTO a spiritual monk, whereas Aang is an impetuous youth who already IS a spiritual monk (and maintains both aspects of that personality throughout his story). Aang's arc is not a spiritual journey - that's Korra's thing. Aang's arc is about growing up and finding the courage within himself to stand strong, like an Avatar, rather than try to dodge around it, like an Airbender. And in that sense, coming to grips with his feelings about this awesome girl and learning to express them effectively is a natural side branch of his main arc.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
I'm definitely not saying the Aang-Katara thing is unrealistic (except for the part about his age). Probably the contrary. All I'm saying is, it doesn't work as drama. Zuko and Katara would work. (Zuko and Mai as drama isn't too bad either, in terms of the set-up, but they kind of put it on the back burner when it needed to be developed further in S3.)

quote:

I've seen the "bad dude gets the good girl" thing done too often already, usually with the emotive success of a paper bag (Korra/ Mako falls squarely into this category).

Cliches like this are archetypal for a reason, and good dramatists can pull them off in a way that feels fresh and fun. There are many successful examples. Good guy/bad girl is perhaps more common these days (Batman/Catwoman, Willow, Helo/Athena from BSG, the recent Miami Vice movie, Knights of the Old Republic). But the arrangement is the same however the genders break down.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
I should add, Korra/Mako doesn't qualify the way I'm understanding the archetype. Mako isn't a "bad guy," not in the sense that he's working for evil the way Zuko is in Last Airbender.
 
Posted by Xavier (Member # 405) on :
 
quote:

So the age argument regarding Kataang never really held water for me. If a romance between a 12 year old and a 14 year old is weird, then so is a romance between a 14 year old and a 16 year old..

Nope. Puberty is a HUGE milestone in development. A romance between a post-pubescent person and a pre-pubescent person is inherently creepy. Katara is a "young woman" and Aang is a "kid". Zuko and Katara would have been "young woman" and "young man", which is way less weird.

IMHO, anyway. That said I was never into Zutara, I just have never liked Kataang either.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Destineer:
I'm definitely not saying the Aang-Katara thing is unrealistic (except for the part about his age). Probably the contrary. All I'm saying is, it doesn't work as drama. Zuko and Katara would work. (Zuko and Mai as drama isn't too bad either, in terms of the set-up, but they kind of put it on the back burner when it needed to be developed further in S3.)

I think where we differ is on the necessity of "drama" in this particular love story. Katara's love life is not the main arc of A:TLA (even for the character of Katara herself). At best, it's a minor side quest. Given that there's plenty of heart-stopping drama elsewhere in the series, I liked that the love story was comparatively low-key. Girl meets Boy, Boy is entranced by Girl, Girl gradually discovers that she likes Boy as well.

Plenty of tension arises from how Katara has to balance her feelings with her naturally "big picture"-oriented mentality, and how this conflicts with Aang's more touchy-feeling, "let's just admit how we feel about each other" approach. Just because it's understated and largely internal doesn't make that tension any less compelling from a storytelling perspective. It doesn't need soaring drama to be interesting or believable.

To me, anyway. Your mileage obviously varies. [Smile]


quote:
Cliches like this are archetypal for a reason, and good dramatists can pull them off in a way that feels fresh and fun. There are many successful examples. Good guy/bad girl is perhaps more common these days (Batman/Catwoman, Willow, Helo/Athena from BSG, the recent Miami Vice movie, Knights of the Old Republic). But the arrangement is the same however the genders break down.
Archetypes can be great! Many a storyteller has mined an existing trope to tell a compelling new tale. But there can also be great value in trying to do something a bit less conventional. Not every romance needs to be Princess Leia and Han Solo. And hell, good guy/ good girl is pretty damn archetypal in and of itself.

quote:
I should add, Korra/Mako doesn't qualify the way I'm understanding the archetype. Mako isn't a "bad guy," not in the sense that he's working for evil the way Zuko is in Last Airbender.
Sorry, I mistyped there - I meant "bad boy," as in the smoldering dangerous type. Going back to the Buffy example, Angel qualifies for this archetype as much as Spike did. Mako and Korra were rote "good girl falls for bad boy," and were thoroughly boring for it.

quote:
Nope. Puberty is a HUGE milestone in development. A romance between a post-pubescent person and a pre-pubescent person is inherently creepy. Katara is a "young woman" and Aang is a "kid". Zuko and Katara would have been "young woman" and "young man", which is way less weird.
Maybe by stated age, but again, Zuko's depiction in the show is far more similar to a 20-year old than a 16-year old. The dude has shoulders and abs that Sokka could only dream of, and he's struggling with existential questions that feel very "college years," rather than "high school years." To me, Zuko/ Katara doesn't feel like "young woman" and "young man" - it feels like "early teenage girl" and "20-year old man." Which is way, way creepier than "early teenage girl" and "pubescent boy" (although that, as I said earlier, is hardly without its own issues).

Again, if you're going to insist that the show adhere purely to age-appropriate romances, Sokka/ Suki is really your only option.

....Well, okay, maybe Ty Lee/ Azula. [Razz]

Edit: Wait, how could I forget? The one other age-plausible pairing is one we got in the show, and a pretty great one, too: Zuko/ Mai. And hey, it's another case of two characters who have a strong personal connection based on mutual respect and eventually take their friendship to the next level. Sokka/ Suki, too! It's like the writers are consistent with how they write romances or something.

[ July 10, 2012, 05:45 PM: Message edited by: Tarrsk ]
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
quote:
Sorry, I mistyped there - I meant "bad boy," as in the smoldering dangerous type. Going back to the Buffy example, Angel qualifies for this archetype as much as Spike did. Mako and Korra were rote "good girl falls for bad boy," and were thoroughly boring for it.
OK, I think part of what's going on is that we're talking about different archetypes. The one I have in mind is: a couple where the guy and the girl are on opposite sides in a conflict, the resolution being that the one on the bad side ends up defecting to the good side.

In general, I think romance in fiction works best when it's "star-crossed" in some sense. There has to be something external that stands in the way of the couple, or else there will be no surprises or tension in store for the viewer. This is why Zuko/Mai worked (and worked better, IMO, than Sokka/Suki). Because Mai was Azula's creature, she was on the wrong side of the Zuko/Azula feud, and this threatened to come between her and Zuko. Made things pretty interesting for a while.
 
Posted by Marek (Member # 5404) on :
 
Korra never seemed to me anymore of a "good girl" then Mako was a "good boy". She is the avatar, and the hero of the piece, but she is also every bit as reactionary and explosive as Mako himself is, even more so really. Mako never seems to be crazy enough to take on the council, the police chief, or other established authority figures. Korra never really listens to anyone's directions, not even Iroh II.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Destineer:
In general, I think romance in fiction works best when it's "star-crossed" in some sense. There has to be something external that stands in the way of the couple, or else there will be no surprises or tension in store for the viewer. This is why Zuko/Mai worked (and worked better, IMO, than Sokka/Suki). Because Mai was Azula's creature, she was on the wrong side of the Zuko/Azula feud, and this threatened to come between her and Zuko. Made things pretty interesting for a while.

Yeah, we're just going to have to agree to disagree on this. The idea that a love story requires some external force separating the couple is just bizarre to me. There are certainly great star-crossed lover stories out there, but to say that a love story need to be star-crossed to be interesting? I dunno, man.

Also, Zuko/Mai were plenty of fun even before Zuko switched sides. [Razz]

quote:
Originally posted by Marek:
Korra never seemed to me anymore of a "good girl" then Mako was a "good boy". She is the avatar, and the hero of the piece, but she is also every bit as reactionary and explosive as Mako himself is, even more so really. Mako never seems to be crazy enough to take on the council, the police chief, or other established authority figures. Korra never really listens to anyone's directions, not even Iroh II.

Korra's a "good girl" in the sense that she's a nice person who is presented as friendly and earnest. She's impetuous as all hell, but so was Katara. Mako, as a character archetype, is a classic "bad boy," down to his physical design - except that he's the coooooool bad boy (versus Zuko, who was more the brooding, smoldering type).

That being said, there are more problems with the Korra/Mako love story than just the archetypes they fill, so I'll grant that it may not have been the best counterexample. [Smile]
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Tarrsk:
quote:
Originally posted by Destineer:
In general, I think romance in fiction works best when it's "star-crossed" in some sense. There has to be something external that stands in the way of the couple, or else there will be no surprises or tension in store for the viewer. This is why Zuko/Mai worked (and worked better, IMO, than Sokka/Suki). Because Mai was Azula's creature, she was on the wrong side of the Zuko/Azula feud, and this threatened to come between her and Zuko. Made things pretty interesting for a while.

Yeah, we're just going to have to agree to disagree on this. The idea that a love story requires some external force separating the couple is just bizarre to me. There are certainly great star-crossed lover stories out there, but to say that a love story need to be star-crossed to be interesting? I dunno, man.

Also, Zuko/Mai were plenty of fun even before Zuko switched sides. [Razz]

Fair enough. But on the last point, Zuko and Azula were always enemies in some form. Their opposition just spent a few episodes simmering beneath the surface of a superficial alliance, but it was always there.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
As a side note, you really think that Helo and Athen were the good guy/bad girl pairing of note to pull from BSG? They were the MOST stable family pairing in the ENTIRE show.

There was nothing particular bad about Athena other than what Boomer did that she had to live with as a legacy. She spent the entire show proving that she wasn't a bad girl, and she was right.

I think the example you're looking for is Lee and Kara, and that was the most dysfunctional relationship on the entire show.

Sometimes drama is entertaining. Sometimes it's stupid.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Lyrhawn:
Sometimes drama is entertaining. Sometimes it's stupid.

Often.
 
Posted by Destineer (Member # 821) on :
 
quote:
As a side note, you really think that Helo and Athen were the good guy/bad girl pairing of note to pull from BSG? They were the MOST stable family pairing in the ENTIRE show.
quote:
Originally posted by Destineer:
OK, I think part of what's going on is that we're talking about different archetypes. The one I have in mind is: a couple where the guy and the girl are on opposite sides in a conflict, the resolution being that the one on the bad side ends up defecting to the good side.


 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Ah, fair distinction.

But I'm not sure how many people would agree with that definition of a "bad boy." By itself it has a totally different meaning for me anyway, a totally different character archetype than the star-crossed lovers archetype.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
Zuko I loathed from the very start. He was so whiny and so angry all the time. Why would he never listen to Iroh who was obviously very wise? I found him completely obnoxious. That time when Azula imitated him and then said "go ahead and laugh, it's funny" made me laugh out loud.

Maybe that's why I love Azula so much, because she was so much more awesome than that whiny spoiled sissy Zuko.
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
In what way was Zuko *spoiled*? (As compared to Azula, anyway). Zuko had his face burned off and then banished from his home forever. That is basically the opposite of getting spoiled.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Nick ordered 26 more episodes.
 
Posted by C3PO the Dragon Slayer (Member # 10416) on :
 
Is that 26 more than Season 1, or 26 more than Season 1 and the already-announced Season 2? Are we getting two more 13-episode seasons, or three?
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
26 more in addition to the 26 already ordered for a total of 52, making Korra almost as long as TLA.

No word yet on how the seasons will be split up...but I'm betting they'll do two more half seasons instead of one big one.
 
Posted by C3PO the Dragon Slayer (Member # 10416) on :
 
Wow... makes me wonder what they can do with Korra's story with that many episodes. Having mastered all the elements and the Avatar state, there can't be any of that mastering-of-the-elements stuff that padded TLA, and Amon is almost certainly gone for good. What conflict will there be now? It would feel like beating a dead horse to keep the same anti-bending revolutionaries as the main antagonists now that Amon's gone, but it would feel like any new conflict not involving the anti-bending faction would come out of left field.

I hope they don't pad it with more probending. As fun as that was to watch, I've had my fill of the quaint sports drama. Having triumphed over Amon's revolution, it would feel regressive for the new Team Avatar to go back to that. Yet at the same time, it would feel cheap to up the stakes out of nowhere.

I think that's what I really hated about the ending of Season 1. It really left the show nowhere to go. I can't get hyped to learn what happens next because they've wrapped up every plot thread in a neat bow. I understand they didn't realize they'd get to make more than one season when they drafted these episodes, but this rushed resolution is coming back to bite them in the rear.

Maybe Cabbage Corp's CEO will be the new bad guy, taking over Future Industries. I'd like to see that.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
I actually think there's a lot they can do with Legend of Korra - there's a ton of untapped potential just within Republic City, and don't forget there's a whole new world outside the city that we've barely seen. Future Industries and Cabbage Corp offer the possibility of corporate intrigue, and the bender vs non-bender conflict still has yet to be genuinely resolved. And personally, I'd welcome some more pro-bending - sure, it's a "smaller" story than Amon's revolution, but I think there's a lot of interesting material to be mined (celebrity culture, sports as a cultural replacement for violent conflict, etc), all of which are in line with the more mature thematic bent of LoK in general. As long as the writers don't just endlessly reiterate on the "bad guys coming to conquer Republic City" plotline, I think there's plenty of potential for interesting stories.

Unlike A:TLA, which was conceived around a single long-running plot (Aang vs Ozai) and thus didn't naturally lend itself to story expansion, LoK is constructed in a more open-ended fashion. I think Bryke voluntarily choosing to shut down A:TLA after the completion of Season 3, despite the fact that the show's ratings were strong, indicates that they wouldn't be agreeing to further seasons of LoK unless they had some solid ideas regarding where to take the show.

With regards to the characters, as I mentioned upthread, the "Avatar learning to master the four elements" arc has been done with Aang already, and Bryke don't seem terribly interested in repeating themselves. Korra having completed this part of her journey opens her up to new and different aspects of character development.

For example, just because she can use all four elements doesn't mean her spiritual journey is complete. I can see the writers doing a further inversion of Aang's arc, which started with "spiritual monk" and moved towards "powerful bender." Korra has always been powerful - she started Season 1 with full mastery of three of the four elements, don't forget. But one encounter with her past lives doesn't mean that she's a spiritual guru. She still has a ways to go there.

Furthermore, we've never really explored what a fully realized Avatar does, beyond the occasional flashback. And even those hint at significant differences between how individual Avatars chose to carry out their duties. Kyoshi clearly sought out conflicts to resolve, while Roku seemed more passive and let the conflicts come to him - ironic, given their respective "home" elements. Aang, surprisingly, seemed to embrace more of a Kyoshi style (albeit in a less confrontational manner), actively working to shape the world around him, acting as a diplomat between nations and founding Republic City. I could see Korra being even more confrontational an Avatar than Kyoshi and learning to temper her arrogance over time, as she learns the hard way that geopolitical conflicts can't be solved via her usual brute force approach.

Anyway, that's all obviously just speculation on my part. But it illustrates some cool directions I think they could take the series - and hopefully, the added time will allow future seasons to "breathe" more than Season 1, which sometimes lacked the small moments of character interaction that made A:TLA so enjoyable. Heck, as someone who loves many of the episodes that A:TLA fans often characterize as "filler," I'd welcome a return of pure character stories that have little or no external stakes whatsoever.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I find it interesting to think about how Kyoshi eventually retreated to her own Kyoshi Island and Roku created an entire island to serve as his home and after his death, a temple of the Avatar. Aang created a city for the world to meet and co-habitate in without heritage and historical claims causing problems, which is something no Avatar seems to have done in the past. So what will Korra do? with the mission statement of "restore and preserve balance in the world" an individual could meet the criteria any number of ways.

Before Aang the power of The Avatar seems to have acted as something akin to a nuclear deterrent, Fire-Lord Sozin waited until Avatar Roku was dead until he started working toward the beginning of his war, then only struck when he had reason to believe he could defeat the Avatar but still spent the rest of his life on the offensive hoping to defend himself from the frightening power of the next Avatar. Aang changed that, yes he did prove himself to be the most powerful man alive but even in the case of Fire-Lord Ozai he was hesitant to take his place as sole judge and jury. His devotion to the preservation of life and justice allowed for people like Tarlok's father to grow powerful, even in the face of all his wrong doing Aang would still let others judge him rather than use his authority via power to rid his city of such an audacious criminal.

I would find it neat if in the end Korra takes the role of lonely wanderer, let the tyrants of the world worry about where she is every moment of every day rather than sit in the ivory tower like Aang.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
In what way was Zuko *spoiled*? (As compared to Azula, anyway). Zuko had his face burned off and then banished from his home forever. That is basically the opposite of getting spoiled.

He treated his uncle, who was going to great lengths to guide and help him, with disdain and disrespect. He insisted that his ship captain take unnecessary risks to satisfy his (Zuko's) pride and vanity on several occasions. He naturally assumed that his honor and his accomplishment of capturing the Avatar took precedence over any other concerns of those around him. He whined constantly. Yes, he was a spoiled brat.

Azula kicked ass and did what needed to be done without fanfare. She was a bending prodigy and developed lightning bending on her own without any apparent instruction. She was by far Zuko's superior.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
So, you got an impression of Zuko during the first season, and decided that you were going to stick to that impression indefinitely, come hell or high water?
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
quote:
Azula kicked ass and did what needed to be done without fanfare. She was a bending prodigy and developed lightning bending on her own without any apparent instruction. She was by far Zuko's superior.
1. She purposely pulled the other two girls into the fight so she could have her own little court to abuse and be praised by, even going as far as threatening to burn down a whole circus just because Mei didn't want to get in the middle of a war.

2. Azula was shown being instructed by the two creepy old ladies at least once, they seemed to be her personal nannies most times but they may as well have been a part of the Fire-Nation religion and thus well trained in fire-bending.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by AchillesHeel:
quote:
Azula kicked ass and did what needed to be done without fanfare. She was a bending prodigy and developed lightning bending on her own without any apparent instruction. She was by far Zuko's superior.
1. She purposely pulled the other two girls into the fight so she could have her own little court to abuse and be praised by, even going as far as threatening to burn down a whole circus just because Mei didn't want to get in the middle of a war.

2. Azula was shown being instructed by the two creepy old ladies at least once, they seemed to be her personal nannies most times but they may as well have been a part of the Fire-Nation religion and thus well trained in fire-bending.

1. I think you mean Ty Lee at the circus, don't you? Azula assessed the job that needed to be done, and picked the right team to accomplish it, giving them the incentive they needed to motivate them properly. Her methods were decisive and effective, if not always endearing. [Wink]

2. The nannies were awesome, too, and of course Azula would have been trained in fire bending from a young age. But the blue lightning type of fire bending stuff was quite uncommon. From what we know, only Iroh and Azula were able to do it. Iroh learned by watching water benders. We don't know how Azula learned it. She was apparently just a prodigy.

Seriously, all she wanted was to kill all her enemies and take over the world. Is that so unseemly in a girl? We admire men like that! She's my hero!
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
Good news everyone!

The Legend of Korra was renewed or an additional 2 seasons, which means it will go for a total of four seasons, 52 episodes!!!!

Everyone get excited!

On a side note, the second season will delve heavily into the Spirit World. In fact, book two is actually called "Spirits". As the show develops, Team Avatar will venture outside of the city and explore the rest of the world, little by little, town by town. We'll start to see familiar places as well as entirely new areas.

It looks like everyone's complaints have been addressed. I don't know about you guys, but I'm very happy about this news.
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Jeff C.:
Good news everyone!

The Legend of Korra was renewed or an additional 2 seasons, which means it will go for a total of four seasons, 52 episodes!!!!

Everyone get excited!

Yep, we know. [Wink]
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I just watched a panel video of a live read from SDCC.

David Faustino (Bud Bundy) is Mako. I don't know if I can separate the two now, I certainly have watched far more Married With Children than I ever will Legend of Korra.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Dan_Frank:
So, you got an impression of Zuko during the first season, and decided that you were going to stick to that impression indefinitely, come hell or high water?

Did he ever quit being a whiny brat? If so, I didn't notice it. I remember Iroh taking great delight in serving wonderful tea in Ba Sing Se and Zuko grumbling and being miserable and hating everything. I seem to remember even after he changed sides he was still a major wet blanket and buzzkill. Wasn't he? His declaration of love for Mai was "I don't hate you". I thought both of them sort of had as the bedrock of their character that they hated life, the world, and everyone, didn't they?

I've only watched the series twice, so I could have missed it, but I would think I would have noticed if Zuko suddenly transformed into a non-whiny non-brat. Did he?
 
Posted by Dan_Frank (Member # 8488) on :
 
Is "broody" the same thing as "whiny brat" in your universe, ak?
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
I thought Zuko did a pretty good turnaround. He still kept his drive, but he lost his anger. He was always so obsessed with getting his father to accept him again that he couldn't see how much of a father his uncle had become or how futile his mission was. By the end of the show, he had thrown off the burdens of his insane family and accepted team Avatar as his new family, along with his uncle.

You might not like the fact that he was only 14 years old, and thus acted like a child at times, but he still had a character arc.
 
Posted by Blayne Bradley (Member # 8565) on :
 
For an anime that has a similar animation style and design aesthetic there's always "Sword of the Stranger" Slightly more violent than Avatar.
 
Posted by ak (Member # 90) on :
 
I was surprised that Zuko's scar still wasn't healed when we saw him as a grownup in something or other (some flashback?). Wouldn't Katara have used her super healing powers on him by then? Or was it only that special water from the one pool that made that possible? Couldn't she have fetched more, given enough time? And wouldn't that have been worthwhile to do?
 
Posted by Mr. Y (Member # 11590) on :
 
I think by now that he probably views the scar as a kind of badge of honor. It is a constant reminder of him disagreeing with his father. The father that he finally decided had to be stopped.

Or maybe because Mai likes it...
 
Posted by Marek (Member # 5404) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Mr. Y:
Or maybe because Mai likes it...

This seems the most likely
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I just finished reading "The Lost Adventures" comic from The Last Airbender and I'd highly recommend it to anyone. It's a series of tiny short stories, some just a few pages long, but it's great! I can't remember the last time I laughed out loud so much at a book. They absolutely nailed the humor.
 
Posted by Tarrsk (Member # 332) on :
 
Seconded - the Lost Adventures comics are fantastic. The tale of "Private Wang Fire" is one of my favorite Avatar stories in any form.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I read that entire story in Sokka's fake Wang Fire voice. [Smile] I think it was my favorite from the graphic novel.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
Book two has a semi-official but vague release date!

http://avatarthelegendofkorraonline.com/2013/03/28/book-2-of-the-legend-of-korra-to-release-in-the-middle-of-april/
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
Supposedly we'll hear something more specific really soon. Lots of people think there will be an announcement at Momocon. That really just snuck in out of nowhere. Usually you hear about these things months in advance, not just a couple weeks.

Very much looking forward to this. I'm also looking forward to it being over way too early and then sulking for 15 months waiting for Book 3. [Wink]
 
Posted by C3PO the Dragon Slayer (Member # 10416) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by AchillesHeel:
Book two has a semi-official but vague release date!

http://avatarthelegendofkorraonline.com/2013/03/28/book-2-of-the-legend-of-korra-to-release-in-the-middle-of-april/

So, um, the middle of April has come and gone, and we're rapidly approaching May. Is this still happening?
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
I blame Zuko, he changed sides again.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
New rumors suggest mid to early May as the new release date, but I've yet to see anything official yet.
 
Posted by Jeff C. (Member # 12496) on :
 
If it was going to be within the next months, we'd probably see some promos or something.
 
Posted by AchillesHeel (Member # 11736) on :
 
You would think so, but Nickelodeon has dropped the ball before. In fact they vehemently underestimated Legend of Korra despite the track record of the creators.

Nickelodeon needs to learn from the example set by Warner Bros. Animation in regards to Bruce Timm and Paul Dini. Just trust them like the fans trust them, and the fans will buy what you allow them to create.
 


Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2