This is topic Treasure of Avan rewrite in forum Fragments and Feedback for Short Works at Hatrack River Writers Workshop.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.hatrack.com/ubb/writers/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=11;t=001413

Posted by LMermaid (Member # 2778) on :
 
Several people were kind enough to critique this 2000-word fantasy story, "Treasure of Avan," when I posted it a few weeks ago. I've finished rewriting it and was hoping that I could get some volunteers to read the rewrite before I submit it.

Here's the opening again:

The bodies on the Ramshead battlefield were still warm when Old Alice came. Healers made furtive warding signs as she passed. Even the scavengers looting the dead scurried out of her way, not willing to risk her attention no matter what the reward. “You’ll find plenty to satisfy you later, you vultures,” Alice cackled. “I’m not here for rings and trinkets.”

She picked her way through the bodies, peering into the stunned and disbelieving faces of the dead. The defending Lymen and invading Uskars lay side by side now, their limbs intertwined like lovers. Most of the Lymen were from the Avan Gathering, she noted with satisfaction, with only a few from her own Lyon clan. “That’s what happens when you cross the Lyon Gathering,” she remarked to the corpse of young Dharmid of Avan.
 


Posted by Dude (Member # 1957) on :
 
I'd be willing to read it again, if you are looking for repeat readers. wolf_dude64@yahoo.com
 
Posted by Swimming Bird (Member # 2760) on :
 
You have a pacing problem.

Alice is walking through corpses for two paragraphs. She's talking to herself too much. There really is nothing going on here.

Your first line is passive.

Your tags are awkward. "Cackled" really, really stuck out. So did 'remarked.'

This is only 13 lines, yet we are already introduced to the following:

Ramshead field

Old Alice

Healers

Uskars

Lymen

Lyon Gathering

Dharmid of Avan

Lyon Clan

Warding Signs

Avan Gathering

I understand this is only 2000 words and that you feel the need to get this info out there. But it serves no purpose. It's just a lot of exposition that has nothing to do with anything. These names may sound cool, but they're just empty shells. Either drop all these references or make them work for you. This is a shallow attempt at world building, as it stands.

Does it matter where these people are from? Does any of this expostion, other than the fact that two factions are at war, serve any sort of purpose?

What exactly are Healers? I hate that term because it just sounds so RPG, D&D. Are they magical? They are noted making warding signs; what is that?

If you bring something up, you're going to need to explain it. Better to not bring these things up in the first place if you don't have the room to explain.

In 2000 words, I don't see how you can address any of this.


[This message has been edited by Swimming Bird (edited October 12, 2005).]
 


Posted by lehollis (Member # 2883) on :
 
I do feel like it would be nice to know a little about where she's going by the end of the second paragraph.

You've done a lot in that introduction, really. I have a strong opening sense of Old Alice as a character, which is good.

What I think I'd like to see by this point is where she's going, what the story is likely going to be about, and so forth. Everything we see here is in the past, so it doesn't build much of a sense of conflict or introduce (for me) a powerful question.

Both paragraphs seem to work, though. I don't think anything needs to be removed. However, if you can introduce more of a hook before that second paragraph, I would do it.

Others seem to like it, so it might be just myself that wasn't as hooked by those lines.
 


Posted by yanos (Member # 1831) on :
 
I'll read if you can wait until Monday for my crit.
 
Posted by Survivor (Member # 213) on :
 
I'll try the new version.
 
Posted by LMermaid (Member # 2778) on :
 
Thanks to everyone who made suggestions or offered to read! I appreciate it.
 


Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2