This is topic The Medalion Legacy in forum Fragments and Feedback for Short Works at Hatrack River Writers Workshop.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.hatrack.com/ubb/writers/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=11;t=000975

Posted by Marina (Member # 2546) on :
 
Thanks for the feedback - I have been struggling with the beginning. I'm haven't been happy with it and have been changing it constantly. If anyone would read this and tell me if they think its better, I'd appreciate it. Otherwise, I'll scrap the whole two first paragraphs and go right to the dialogue.

Spring came late to Rosewood, Wisconsin, but the ice was finally off the lake. Old Jeb Johnson’s fishing shack had plunged into Lake Shisquebem a few weeks ago. It would take another week before he pulled it out. The first week in May, a few fisherman still risked thin ice for what they claimed was the best fishing of the year. Now, just three weeks later, the lake was clear of even a glimmer of ice. Boats had not yet replaced shanties that had been scattered about the lake all winter.
Normally, Annique loved the spring. The sky was clear and the aspen were finally budding. She loved the open water, the whisper of the aspen leaves when they fully sprouted and most especially the return of her beloved birds. However, this Spring was different.
First of all, she had been sick as a dying dog all month. She had spent almost a week in bed. Pain speared from her temples to her eyes and back again like out of control lightning bolts. Being fried and exhausted by the pain had been the least of her worries. She could have handled the massive headaches, it was the clothes and books flying around the room that really freaked her out.

[This message has been edited by Marina (edited May 06, 2005).]
 


Posted by Beth (Member # 2192) on :
 
congratulations on finishing!
 
Posted by Isaiah13 (Member # 2283) on :
 
If you're planning on going YA with this, I would suggest opening with the second paragraph. Get your character out there right off the bat.
 
Posted by wbriggs (Member # 2267) on :
 
spring should be lower case I think

the hidden menace thing: I don't see a reason for Annique to know this. It's something I make fun of in gothic novels or horror: "I have a sense that unspeakable evil is fast approaching!" or "Somewhere, someone is killing kittens. I can feel it." If you need a sense of menace -- and I think you do! -- let Annique know why she's afraid. (Or if she MUST be kept ignorant of why, let even her wonder about this herself. But I wouldn't.)

Congrats on the novel!

[This message has been edited by wbriggs (edited May 05, 2005).]
 


Posted by Survivor (Member # 213) on :
 
Or you could integrate any necessary information from the first paragraph into the part of the second where you talk about why, "Normally, Annique loved the spring." Then you can work in the unusual incidents like spring coming late and Jeb losing his fishing shack through the ice as being part of that "normal" spring that she loves.

Then, have the second paragraph be about how she's been really sick...oh yeah, and she's got a poltergeist.

That's what I think you're aiming for anyway. Overall, I like your prose, and the sense of incident and scale seems really good from what I can see. Of course, I'm also generally against opening with dialogue. But I really don't think that there's anything unsalvagable about this opening.
 


Posted by wbriggs (Member # 2267) on :
 
Suggested [deletions] in brackets, and ADDITIONS in all caps.

And yes, I'm hooked. The stuff flying around the room did it!

--
[Spring came late to Rosewood, Wisconsin, but] the ice was finally off the lake. Old Jeb Johnson’s fishing shack had plunged into Lake Shisquebem a few weeks ago. [It would take another week before he pulled it out. The first week in May, a few fisherman still risked thin ice for what they claimed was the best fishing of the year. Now, just three weeks later, the lake was clear of even a glimmer of ice. Boats had not yet replaced shanties that had been scattered about the lake all winter.] [OR MAYBE START WITH THE NEXT PARAGRAPH -- BUT PUT THE FISHING SHACK PLUNGE FOR LATER? IT'S FUNNY!]

Normally, Annique loved [the] spring*:*[. The sky was clear and the aspen were finally budding. She loved] the open water [IF YOU REMOVE THE FISHING SHACK STUFF YOU'LL NEED TO EXPLAIN THIS I'M SURE], the whisper of [the] aspen leaves [when they fully sprouted] and most especially the return of [her beloved] SONGbirds. However, this Spring [was different.
First of all,] she had been sick as a dying dog all month*,* SPENDING [She had spent] almost a week in bed WITH PAIN SPEARING HER TEMPLES [SHE MIGHT ALSO HAVE SOME OTHER SYMPTOM]. [Pain speared from her temples to her eyes and back again like out of control lightning bolts. Being fried and exhausted by the pain had been the least of her worries. She could have handled the massive headaches,]

But it was the clothes and books flying around the room that really freaked her out. [MIGHT CHANGE "FREAK OUT" TO SOME OTHER PHRASE UNLESS YOU'RE TRYING FOR HUMOR]
 


Posted by djvdakota (Member # 2002) on :
 
I'm for starting with the second paragraph, too. The first leads me to completely different expectations for the story.

Otherwise, a good start here. That last line hooked me, too.
 




Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2