This is topic Rescue Mission in forum Fragments and Feedback for Short Works at Hatrack River Writers Workshop.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.hatrack.com/ubb/writers/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=11;t=001605

Posted by arriki (Member # 3079) on :
 
Just looking for feedback on these opening (13) lines. It's the opening of a novella.

Rescue Mission

Disease. It was a new word. A new concept. A demeaning, alien way to die. It had recently come inside the deme's fanatically guarded borders. Now it seemed to have sifted into the deepest levels belowground. What it was, how it spread, was unknown.
The healers shaved Deit's head, looking for more signs of this sickness. Deit's long single braid -- her pride, symbol of her warrior caste status -- dropped onto the floor. As Rocise watched, a healer kicked the braid under the table, out of his way. Just another piece of trash.
"Have we seen enough?" one of the healers asked.
Had they?
Rocise looked down. Deit, Rescue Team 3's kommes expert, lay
 


Posted by pantros (Member # 3237) on :
 
you cannot use "it" without first explicitly defining "it". Just saying disease is too vague.

Teasing isn't nice. Just tell us, really. Its more interesting if we know

 


Posted by The Fae-Ray (Member # 3084) on :
 
"What it was, how it spread, was unknown.
The healers shaved Deit's head, looking for more signs of this sickness. Deit's long single braid -- her pride, symbol of her warrior caste status -- dropped onto the floor."

I don't know how well this works. For me, when I first read it, it seemed as though it were in past tense, so when it became clear it was in present tense I was a little confused. And I agree with pantros. The whole disease thing seems a little too vague. We need to know what it is, what it does. Is it contagious (is that why they're cutting off her hair?)

Other than those, it wasn't bad.
 


Posted by wbriggs (Member # 2267) on :
 
I don't understand what's going on.
 
Posted by Corky (Member # 2714) on :
 
Instead of "looking for more signs of the sickness," would if work if you said something like "looking for ---, xxx, and yyy, signs of the sickness?"
 
Posted by yanos (Member # 1831) on :
 
I think you're trying to cram too much into too few words. This needs a more solid POV and a smoother introduction of information and character. The reader cannot appreciate every little detail unless given time to do so.
These paragraphs should give us an idea of:
1) Who the main character is
2) Where the main character is
3) Why they are there.
 
Posted by arriki (Member # 3079) on :
 
Hmmm... the "it"s in that first paragraph all refer back to the term "disease." Would it help to change the It in -- It had recently come inside..." to -- This strange new type of sickness had recently appeared inside..." -- ????

And, no. the disease is not influenza, polio, leukemia or any other human disease. They have no name for the particular -- which they don't even recognize as a class of illnesses -- so they use the one generic term from outside for the thing itself.

Remember, disease is a new concept. They have broken arms, kidney failures, animal bites, poisons, worms etc. but not infectious disease. That's real alien, to them.

How to make that clearer without ruining the flow of the text?
 


Posted by KatFeete (Member # 2161) on :
 
I'm pretty much going to disagree with everyone here. I like this as an opening. What I'm getting from it:

1) We're talking about a closed, highly protected society, which has not had anything like disease for a long time.

2) However, they've still got warriors, so we're not talking utopia either.

3) I liked the casual loss of dignity as Deit looses her braid; instant sympathy for the character there, and by extension the culture.

I would certainly keep reading this. I didn't think it was too little information or consider it confusing.

Minor nitpick: avoid the use of weasel phrases like "seemed to". "Now it seemed to have sifted..." is a much weaker construction than "Now it had sifted...." but they're saying the same thing.
 


Posted by pantros (Member # 3237) on :
 
How do they have the word for Disease without having Disease?

You will need to find a way to make it clear that infectious illness was a new concept for them. If they just use one term for it, use a word other than Disease, since we already have a meaning for that and you do want us to discover the reality as the PoV character does. Using a word with a definiton for something they cannot define will break the story immersion.

Don't worry about the flow of the text. That is something you, the author, are emotionally attached to. You need to break that attachment if you want to improve. No one else sees the same flow you do. Your goal is to immerse us in the paragraph so that we are thinking about the story, not the words.

It is definitly a tough job to describe something familiar to the reader but new to the character. Good luck with that.

Call the disease what they call it. If it looks like an illness, its an illness. If your people would see it as a curse, call it a curse.

if they have the word disease but only the one disease, use "The Disease" capitalized both at the T and the D.

Remember we are seeing the story through the PoV character's perceptions, not from a Movie camera hovering nearby.
 


Posted by Corky (Member # 2714) on :
 
Perhaps something about "the idea that beings too small to see could attack the body like an army had made them laugh until they saw the results of such battles."

(Thus combining the warrior metaphor in the way the POV character might think with the infectious disease information?)
 


Posted by wbriggs (Member # 2267) on :
 
I would say the purpose of the first 13 is not necessarily to introduce MC (although it's common). It may be to tell us what we need to know to understand the introduction of the MC. I just didn't follow.
 


Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2