This is topic The Soul Stealer in forum Fragments and Feedback for Short Works at Hatrack River Writers Workshop.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.hatrack.com/ubb/writers/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=11;t=002889

Posted by monstewer (Member # 5883) on :
 
I didn’t know she was a Soul Stealer when I met her. She wasn’t like the others. Everybody knew the Soul Stealers, with their pale faces and far away dark eyes. Everywhere they went they were followed by fearful downcast eyes and sullen silences.
Little Eadric Malkin once dared me to touch the billowing black cloak of the Soul Stealer who strode through the marketplace every morning on his way to the Pits. I won the bet but had nightmares for months afterwards of those cold, cold eyes swinging towards me. Whether the crawling, creeping sensation which scraped across my mind was a figment of my imagination, I’m still unsure to this day.
Laraine was different. She had eyes that sparkled and danced with life. She had a smile that I would guard as jealously as


Hmmm, not sure about this opening, but all comments are much appreciated and if anybody wants to read the whole thing its dark fantasy and 5900. Thanks

 


Posted by NathanClark (Member # 3149) on :
 
I would combine the second and third sentences, to read:
"She wasn’t like the others, with their..." in order to avoid repeating "Soul Stealers;" it sounded kind of awkward when I read it.
I'm not sure about "far away dark eyes," 'distant' would probably work better.

The Soul Stealers themselves don't seem to deviate from common fantasy archetypes (Nazgul, Fades/Eyeless from 'The Wheel of Time,' the Wights in 'Song of Ice and Fire'), especially with the dark eyes and long, black robes. In my opinion, the first two sentences counteract at least most of the negative opinion I get from the 'cliche' characters (since Laraine is obviously not your standard Ringwraith), but this may still put off some readers. If the Stealers do differ significantly from these archetypes, that should probably be made clear from the beginning, to avoid readers assuming your work is largely derivative.

In any case, this beginning did pull me into the story, and I would be happy to read more.
 


Posted by supraturtle (Member # 1518) on :
 
She ain't nothing but a soul stealer,
Think I'll take my chances.
[place gratuitous air guitar here]

Sure, I'll give it a go.

 


Posted by annepin (Member # 5952) on :
 
Heh--I sense an dangerous love a-brewing... I was hooked by the opening lines, but do agree with NathanClark they could be a little leaner. I do like how you slipped in some details about the world.

I'd love to read it, if you like.
 


Posted by LCastle (Member # 7363) on :
 
I'll take a look.
 
Posted by foxjwill (Member # 7723) on :
 
Although a lot of authors seem to use it, I tend not like this kind of summary introduction used at the beginning of a story. If not done extremely well (take The Great Gatsby or various sections of the Alvin Maker novels, for example), it makes it seem as if you're afraid that the rest of the story won't convey some important message to the reader (in this case, that some sort of intimacy will develop between the narrator and the Soul Stealer).

It would be much more effective--and much more fun to write, I'd say--if you just head straight into the action. Have the narrator start with some sort of encounter with a Soul Stealer. (By the way, "Soul Stealer" just seems too much of a mouthful--plus, the common people tend to shorten titles (e.g. "Autobus" became "bus," "Royal Canadian Mounted Police" became "Mounties," etc.). Just have them be called "Stealers.) Then have him encounter the specific "Soul Stealer" (after some transition, of course).
 


Posted by BoredCrow (Member # 5675) on :
 
The idea intrigues me. I'd be happy to give it a look.
 
Posted by Cheyne (Member # 7710) on :
 
I agree with the general timbre of the previous comments but need to see more to have anything deeper to add. send it on.
 
Posted by Krista (Member # 7738) on :
 
I like what you have here. I have to agree with what others have said about questioning the use of "far away" in describing the Soul Stealers' eyes. And while I don't have foxjwill's issue with this kind of introduction, I do like the idea of perhaps starting the story with an encounter with a Soul Stealer, if only because that will tell us more about the narrating character.

I'd be happy to read more if you'd like to send it my way.
 


Posted by smncameron (Member # 7392) on :
 
I like it, although from the way the first paragraph is written I expected the second to detail how the POV character met Laraine.

If you want to send it my way I'd be happy to read over it and give you my thoughts.

[This message has been edited by smncameron (edited January 17, 2008).]
 


Posted by TheOnceandFutureMe on :
 
[quote]Everybody knew the Soul Stealers, with their pale faces and far away dark eyes. Everywhere they went they were followed by fearful downcast eyes and sullen silences.[quote]

Cut this line. All this will become apparent. The lines about touching a soul stealer (don't capitalize it, you wouldn't capitalize doctor or police officer) are quite awesome.

Send it my way, I'll check it out.
 


Posted by smncameron (Member # 7392) on :
 
I disagree. The capitilization emphasizes the terrifying power at the Soul Stealer's disposal.
 


Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2