http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/magazine/8530405.stm
While it is about movies, I think it spreads to writing as well. I definately like his new rule: only one major suspension of disbelief per movie. I recently watched a HORRIBLE scifi movie, which I would rank even worse than this author's worst movie pick, and after reading this article I finally realized why it is so bad. There was simply too many stretches the movie made.
Now that I know the disease, hopefully I can avoid it...
[This message has been edited by Teraen (edited March 09, 2010).]
But I understand where their coming from - I like to imagine what would go wrong if a Martian made a movie with Terran characters - what basic stuff would it get wrong that would bother me? I'd get squirmy if someone who grew up in the American South was speaking in a British accent. Or outran an explosion. Or walked on Mars without a spacesuit. Or if a woman suddenly spoken with a man's voice. It's details like that which are impossible to ignore. And if you're a Human - you'll be sensitive to errors like that. Likewise for the scientist who are familiar thus sensitive to scientific details - like sparking shark brain neurons seen under the microscope - sigh, that was pretty bad...even for nonscientists. Like a human with three arms or something...
quote:
I recently watched a HORRIBLE scifi movie, which I would rank even worse than this author's worst movie pick, and after reading this article I finally realized why it is so bad.
I would keep in mind that the author's list generally consists of stuff that takes place in the very near future. Stuff that takes place further off gets to use Arthur C. Clarke's maxim that any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. So, FTL, transporters, etc, are fine, as long as you are consistent in following your own pseudo-scientific rules and the characters are aware of the implications of that magical technology. That's where Star Trek gets in trouble.
Now, Star Wars, that is straight up science-fantasy, but it's not due to bad science as it is to "The Force." In fact, just about every Star Wars fan was infuriated by Lucas's attempt to give the Force a scientific basis in Episode I.
What's important is whether or not a story (a) identifies how its reality differs from our reality, if at all, and (b) remains consistent within its reality.
I'll argue that any story that establishes an impossible reality--one we cannot get to and could not have reached had our history twisted in a different direction--isn't sci-fi; instead, it's fantasy.
*Edited to insert a word.
[This message has been edited by aspirit (edited March 06, 2010).]
quote:
...remember that science is a compromise...
Science is not a compromise so much as a constant reevaluation of what's going on.
As far as the article, I'm kinda in agreement with the comments section in that article, but if there are too many goofy moments or flaws, I'm not so willing to suspend my disbelief.
I like the X-men and Heroes(at least in the first season), but that is not how evolution works. If the story and the characters are interesting enough, all science flaws can be over looked.
That is not the case in the Deep Blue Sea where not only is science ravished but all logic as well. I want my two hours back.
I do think it would be cool to see a movie where Hollywood actually respects science and scientists and makes a sincere attempt to make it believable.
I once had a physics teacher who walked out of Star Wars two minutes in because of some flaw he saw in it. (I can't remember what it was now.)
About the only dealbreaker for me is when people assume black holes = worm holes.
Also I'm reading up on Harlan Ellison - apparently he wrote a review where he described Star Wars as "shallow" and "a film without soul, without a core."
Cold.
[This message has been edited by billawaboy (edited March 07, 2010).]
Red Planet with Val Kilmer and that girl from the Matrix. Had the potential to be good, but frankly, it wasn't.
"I believe in code. A, G, T, P"
quote:
...Also I'm reading up on Harlan Ellison...
Beware! Beware! Beware! Read him, and he'll be there haunting you when you close your eyes and try to sleep...he'll haunt your dreams, too. You'll carry him with you for the rest of your life. (I've never gotten over a story of his called "Croatoan.")
quote:
I once had a physics teacher who walked out of Star Wars two minutes in because of some flaw he saw in it. (I can't remember what it was now.)