Edited for punctuation because I forgot how to use a question mark
[This message has been edited by MDBHarlan (edited July 15, 2011).]
[This message has been edited by MDBHarlan (edited July 15, 2011).]
[This message has been edited by MDBHarlan (edited July 15, 2011).]
There are few hard and fast rules.
For YA, I would usually shoot for around 70,000 to 75,000 words. (My SEVEN STARS is actually under at 67,000. How did that happen?) Middle grade, around 50,000 to 55,000. (My MAGE STORM is 56,000.)
But there are exceptions.
Another thing you can do is think of maybe 2-3 books that your work is most like (modern titles). Then you can do a web search on the title and "word count." There are variations in word counts depending on genre and sub-age groups (e.g. middle grade vs upper middle grade).
The book Aquamarine is 105 pages. (My daughter likes this one, leave me alone.)
Here's what one Amazon reviewer had to say: "Though a bit too short and a bit too shallow, it's sweet."
However, it sold, and then was made into a movie, so are there "rules" as far as page count?
Nope.
Axe
Backlist works from traditionally published authors strike me as a good guide to acceptable lengths. A lot of these modern indie-published works seem much shorter than similar works from traditional publishers.
Hours of fun await the inquisitive.
My YA/MG novels clock in around 60k each time. It's a nice length, around 250 pages. I write at the young end of YA, borderline middle grade, so this length feels perfectly appropriate to me. I have decided to independently publish my books and nobody cares the length there (other than they'd feel cheated paying $5 for a short story of 8k words. I charge 99c for those.) In submitting through normal channels, though, I received no negative feedback reacting to length (for the 65k word YA sci fi novel I was submitting.)
I write at the young end of YA too, KayTi. I worry about it not being publishable because of that. My fairy tale characters get married at the end (older reader) but I think plot wise it is more simple (younger reader).
I have decided to twist a few more things into my plot to take it from the 49k that I have to the recommended lengths. Maybe this will help with the above mentioned problem.
As to the subject at hand... the rule of thumb for word <==> page conversion is 250 words/page on average (and indeed that's what Scrivener uses). YA will be shorter, on average, than adult fiction. If it helps with a reference point, the "target" for adult fiction is 400 pages, or 100,000 words. No length limit is ever hard and fast, but it's one of those things that is nice to hit somewhere in the ballpark of. Write till it's done, then cut it in half, then cut it again. It should be just about tight enough then.
[This message has been edited by micmcd (edited July 16, 2011).]