Either way, the idea is haunting me. So I thought I'd throw it up here for your ideas and thoughts.
*****
Candidate the First:
The Producers, 1968.
Not the movie-of-the-musical-of-the-movie---that had its moments but didn't hold a candle to the original. Zero Mostel as Max Bialystok and Gene Wilder as Leo Bloom, who get together and contrive to scam the Broadway crowd and put on the worst Broadway musical ever and then skip town with the money they didn't spend on it.
Screamingly funny---once you've seen the "Springtime for Hitler" number you'll never forget it. Also a commentary on the miserable state of Broadway circa 1968---running the gamut from "wildly inappropriate subject matter" to "rock-and-roll doesn't belong there," with a lot in between.
And manages to tell a human story within---how Max Bialystok teaches Leo Bloom how to be a human being.
The mix of action and humor just did it for me, as well as the characters being just right. When someone hands 'Mrs. Smith' a baby and she clearly doesn't know what to do with it, it just hit home.
My classic nomination would be 'The Blues Brothers'. That's got three things working for it: comedy, action and good music. Working on all those levels, it hits every time I watch it.
Pulp Fiction. Yeah, it's pretty grim, but the dialogue gets me every time.
quote:
My classic nomination would be 'The Blues Brothers'
I second that nomination. I love that movie so much that every time I get Chicken I think of "Two fried chickens and a coke." Of course there are many classic lines from that one.
More recently 'Hot Fuzz' had me cracking up.
Also, I loved the 'Bad Boys' and 'Bad Boys 2' they were great comedies with action.
'Stripes' was great too.
Of course you got the great Mel Brooks ones like 'Blazing Saddles' and 'Spaceballs' and 'History of the World Part I'
That's all I can think of so far... I know there are more....
If you liked that movie, genevive42, I'd recommend RED. I find that I really like thrillers/adventure movies with a sense of humor. I liked the humor in KNIGHT AND DAY, too.
I think it's one of those movies that you have to see a few times before you appreciate it--and I decided once was enough for me. At least now I know the "context" for the quotes.
Humor is extremely subjective, so what one person finds funny is not going to work for someone else.
I also love the humor-in-action-movies stated previously: RED, Knight and Day, Mr. and Mrs. Smith, Bad Boys (1&2), and I would submit the Lethal Weapon movies as well. I would also add a shameless plug for one of my all-time favorite TV shows, Burn Notice, that routinely cracks me up.
It's almost pure slapstick, and I found myself thinking, especially at the end, with the fire engine ladder, that if this had been really happening, it wouldn't have been at all funny.
But then, that's my sense of humor. Just not into slapstick.
quote:
I'm curious to know if anyone here who's seen IT'S A MAD MAD WORLD thought it was funny.
It's almost pure slapstick, and I found myself thinking, especially at the end, with the fire engine ladder, that if this had been really happening, it wouldn't have been at all funny.But then, that's my sense of humor. Just not into slapstick.
I found parts of it funny. Not the ending particularly, where just about everyone gets badly hurt. That's not funny to me.
I have a strange sense of humor. I enjoy the "in" jokes in animated movies like "Ice Age" (all three of them) and "Shrek".
For a funny movie, I checked my DVD drawer--the movies I liked well enough to invest in them and watch them over again. They're not the classic choices.
"Little Shop of Horrors" (I watch that every Halloween without fail, along with "Young Frankenstein". Keep your scary movies)
"Halleluiah Trail" -- Bet you never heard of it. Go look it up. Rent it. It does for westerns what "Murder by Death" did for mysteries, with a very funny three-way battle during a sandstorm.
"Cat Ballou" -- It's the characters. And the drunk horse, of course.
"First Wives Club"
And almost anything with Danny Kaye, but especially, "The Inspector General" and "The Court Jester".
quote:
...anyone here who's seen IT'S A MAD MAD WORLD thought it was funny.
When I was ten...and yeah, I did, then. For some reason, Spencer Tracy's role stands out in my memory...
No time for a lengthy post on some other candidate, though I've got plenty...maybe sometime tomorrow.
Dudley Doright, the one Brenden Frasier did. (Also in connection with this his George of the Jungle.)
Corky Remano
I think the one that had me laughing the most was The Wrong Guy starring Dave Foley.
The funniest bits in the Holy Grail were the opening credits and the communist rant by the serfs. There were some slow bits, and I thought that The Life of Brian was a more consistently funny movie.
Speaking of hysterics...
Candidate the Second:
"Porky's." Sometime in the early 1980s, I forget. (My reference books are in my other room.)
Now, this is pretty sophomoric, and pretty sexist to boot. And it's a crude production. But on first viewing it reduced me to rolling around on the floor laughing, and thinking about some of the scenes in it makes me chuckle. I guess it's the granddaddy of all the gross-out comedies of today.
"We're No Angels," not the dreadful remake-in-name-only, but the original, from sometime in the early 1950s. Humphrey Bogart, Aldo Rey, and Peter Ustinov as escapees from Devil's Island who, without particularly intending to, help out a family. Particularly the scene where Basil Rathbone takes a container containing a poisonous snake into his bedroom and Bogart and Rey and Ustinov discuss whether they should tell him.
Probably too bleak for the era it was released in, but seems funnier every time I catch it...
quote:
I'm curious to know if anyone here who's seen IT'S A MAD MAD WORLD thought it was funny.
I agree with you though I like Jack Benny's cameo.
Goldie oldie
The Music Box
Laurel & Hardey's only academy award winning effort. The men move a piano, slapstick at its best. My Dad loved these guys and although I'm a 3 stooges guy first, this one tops anything they did.
Parody
Top Secret
This is the airplane catagory. Val Klimer spoofs every war/spy movie made from the 40's thru 70's. The ridiculous premise had the movie set in communist East Germany (why would East Germany have a french resistance?). The crowning moment was the cow. Two agents were supposed to be inside a cow suit to infiltrate the enemy compound but the director used a real cow wearing army boots throughout the scene (makes me laugh just thinking about it). Favorite line of the movie was when the two agents argued who would be in the rear of the costume. After a bitter arguement Latrine acquiesces with the line "Fine. Go ahead and be an a**hole."
Stage comic hitting the big time
Easy Money
I don't care who you are, if you ever saw Rodney Dangerfield on the Tonight Show and didn't laugh, you probably should have seen a shrink a long time ago. "Easy Money" was his type of movie, fitting so well with his style of humor. This movie had Joe Pesci as his best friend. So many funny lines hard to pick one but I am going with the final one in the movie.
"My mother-in-law. For years I wouldn't kiss her face and now I'm kissing her a**."
Made for a teenager but still funny today
Cheech and Chongs Up in Smoke
They say it glorified drugs but if you saw it you can't imagine anyone would run out start doing them based on the events of this movie. Stacy Keach made half of this movie. I remember a joke he said about catholic nuns that I couldn't dress up to be okay to post here no matter how hard I tried.
Favorite part of the movie was the opening when Cheech is checking out his pimp mobile with the shag purple interior while the song Low Rider played.
Modern work
My Cousin Vinny
Joe Pesci at his best. Classic culture clash humor. Ralph Machcio unwittly confessing to double murder was great. If you never saw this movie go rent it.
I could go on all day....
[This message has been edited by snapper (edited April 21, 2011).]
[This message has been edited by snapper (edited April 21, 2011).]
Road to Morocco, Bob Hope, Bing Crosby, and Dorothy Lamour, sometime in the 1940s.
This was probably the funniest of the seven "Road" movies Hope and Crosby made...certainly their "ad-libs" around whatever passed for the script were worthwhile all the way through all seven movies...besides, this was the one where a camel "ad-libbed" and spat in Hope's eye.
Interestingly, the scariest movie I've ever seen was Signs, the key movie they parodied.
Overall Fav: Fight Club.
Axe
.
[This message has been edited by axeminister (edited April 22, 2011).]
Candidate the Fifth:
Plan Nine From Outer Space, directed by the legendary Ed Wood. Mid-to-late 1950s. Bela Lugosi, the nominal star and big name, died after shooting a few scenes...when shooting resumed, Wood recast the role with a guy who's taller than Lugosi and had blondish hair as well.
It's a very funny movie...perhaps all the more so because the director and cast did not set out to make a funny movie. In a way, that's sad...but if you feel sad about it, watching the movie should cheer you up.
Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein, 1948.
Picking the funniest Abbott & Costello movie is like figuring out which raindrop fell first---but, out of many options, I'll pick this one. As is often said, this one works because A & C are funny, and the monsters play it straight. It's the granddaddy of all the horror-humor combinations, and one of the best.
Also I found "What's up Doc?" Pretty funny, not many have seen it though.
My wife would second "It's a Mad, Mad, Mad World"
Which reminds me of a couple of movies, ostensibly comedies, that weren't really funny at all.
M*A*S*H and Catch-22. I enjoyed the former, didn't like the latter, but neither made me laugh much.
Numerous Streisand movies.
Caveman, Ringo Starr and others, 1981 or so.
This one usually turns up routinely on "bad movie" lists (Roger Ebert included a review of it in his "This Movie Sucks" collection.) But I liked it---Ringo always did have a lot of appeal for me, the parodies and jokes about other "caveman" movies worked for me, the effects were good, the actors were good---and a lot of it made me laugh my head off. (Saw it recently, on cable sometime in the last year---it holds up for me.)
But honestly the movie I laughed the most at, ever, so much so that everyone in the theater had to be ticked off with me and my friends, was meant to be a serious movie. Dungeons and Dragons. We busted up laughing as soon as Damadar with his blue lips popped onto the screen, and didn't stop until it was over. The combination of bad makeup and props, bad acting, bad dialogue, and ludicrous plot was just too much.
Candidate the Eighth:
The Inspector General, Danny Kaye, 1946 or somewhere in that decade. A loanout of Kaye to Warners. Reputedly based on a Gogol story, I think---I've never seen it. A corrupt town worried about a visit from the Inspector General mistakes a wandering tramp for him.
Secondary, of course, to Danny Kaye and his comedic acting and patter songs. I'm fondest of the song known as "Soliloquy for Three Heads"---how many songs or movies from the 1940s would have its characters exhort one to "give him the fist...give him the wrist...give him the finger!"
*****
Another note: there's a lot of "funny" in the Pixar movies, but, as a whole, they don't come across as "funny movies," and not quite what I had in mind for The Funniest Movie I've Ever Seen.
You can close the thread and voting is now officially over.
Wait. Dumb and Dumber. Now you can close--
Anchorman. No, wait...Kung-Fu Hustle. His Girl Friday. The Thin Man. Some Like It Hot. The Hangover. Animal House. The Big Lebowski...
Nevermind. Just keep going with the list.
quote:
I'm curious to know if anyone here who's seen IT'S A MAD MAD WORLD thought it was funny.
I haven't watched this one since I was a kid. Slapstick, yes...but it did make me laugh. I should add this to my Netflix list.
Another slapstick movie that became one of my favorites of all time is "The Great Race." Even after all the times I've seen it, I still laugh like like an idiot. Jack Lemmon was especially over the top in this one, but he definitely stole the show.
Also on my list: "The Pink Panther Strikes Again." The dentist scene alone is worth the price of admission.
Hey...it just occurred to me...both of these are Blake Edwards movies.
S!
S!
And The Big Lebowski - another winner. I love that film.
-Being John Malkovich;
-Raising Arizona; and:
-Desperado (with Antonio Banderas)
It may be just me....
Casablanca, Bogart and Bergman, 1942. You might not think this is a funny movie, and the main story is serious, but the greats of filmmaking knew (and still know) how to leaven a serious story with humor---and so much of the humor in Casablanca has entered popular culture.