Hatrack River
Home   |   About Orson Scott Card   |   News & Reviews   |   OSC Library   |   Forums   |   Contact   |   Links
Research Area   |   Writing Lessons   |   Writers Workshops   |   OSC at SVU   |   Calendar   |   Store
E-mail this page
  Hatrack River Writers Workshop
  Fragments and Feedback for Short Stories
  WIP SF

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   WIP SF
Bent Tree
Member
posted November 06, 2009 01:49 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Bent Tree   Click Here to Email Bent Tree     Edit/Delete Message
I am looking for comments on this, two potential intro paragraghs for a SF story I am working on. I would like to hear what you think, which you like best and what needs to be done to improve either. Thanks a million

quote:
“Moloki feel heavy” the digital voice came from the transvocalizer implanted within the bonobo’s throat. Unaccustomed to the gravity of Earth, Moloki now seemed more at ease walking on all fours.
“Yes, Moloki, I too feel heavy.” The boy prince, Samouri, wished that he could do more to ease his nervous childhood companion. But, he too felt axious, having never before set foot on Earth. Awestruck by the beauty, and coping with gravity 72% stronger than that on Mars, he was experiencing something teetering between nausea and euphoria.
“Welcome to Earth, your majesty. Although the air quality of Earth has improved exponentially over the past few decades, I would still like to offer you a respirator. Would

or

quote:
The view of Earth was wondrous. Prince Samouri had spent most of the three days since they had arrived on the moon watching from a window, wondering what it would be like to finally step foot on the planet where the humans his race had evolved from evolved.Yet, he also spent considerable time longing into the darkness of space through a telescope for his home. Though it was not so much Mars that he longed after but his twin. For the first time since their birth they had been separated to a degree in which there telekinetic bond would not reach. For this reason he was even more thankful that Moloki was with him.
“Moloki hungry,” the synthesized voice came from the transvocalizer implanted in the Bonobo’s throat. “Moloki want figs. Moloki want celery”. Still accustomed to sign language,

[This message has been edited by a crazy voodoo witch doctor(edited November 06, 2009).]

[This message has been edited by Bent Tree (edited November 06, 2009).]

IP: Logged

Dark Warrior
Member
posted November 06, 2009 01:53 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Dark Warrior   Click Here to Email Dark Warrior     Edit/Delete Message
crazy voodoo witch doctor

lol

IP: Logged

Dark Warrior
Member
posted November 06, 2009 01:56 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Dark Warrior   Click Here to Email Dark Warrior     Edit/Delete Message
I like the second if you rework...

quote:
humans his race had evolved from evolved

[This message has been edited by Dark Warrior (edited November 06, 2009).]

IP: Logged

arriki
Member
posted November 06, 2009 08:12 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for arriki   Click Here to Email arriki     Edit/Delete Message

First, nits –
“Moloki feel heavy” – needs a comma or even better, a period
axious -- anxious
gravity 72% stronger than that on Mars – that seems wrong. Are you certain?

evolved.Yet – needs a space or two

had evolved from evolved – ummm, I believe you either need a comma setting off the second “evolved” or an awkward second had as in -- had evolved from had evolved. Better yet, find a better way to say this.

longing into the darkness of space through a telescope for his home – yeah, a bit awkward. Would be better rephrased.

there telekinetic – wrong word. Use their telepathic.

Moloki hungry,” the – Nope. It’s really this: Moloki hungry.” The

IP: Logged

arriki
Member
posted November 06, 2009 08:41 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for arriki   Click Here to Email arriki     Edit/Delete Message
I think Samouri’s comment should be its own paragraph and the info/setting explanation a separate paragraph. Why? Because the dialogue is a response and loading it with all the narrative takes away from that. I would say “diminishes the energy of that response” but most people don’t seem to “feel” that. Still, give it a try.

Hmmm, you know, you could move that second sentence of M’s into the whole explanation paragraph after S’s reply. That would make the exchange read cleaner.

gravity 72% stronger -- still bothers me. I’m trying to figure out what that feels like. If you just said Earth’s heavier gravity, it might be better. That and the euphoria and nausea and the reader will accept that without trying to break off and contemplate 72%.

If it has -- “air quality of Earth has improved exponentially over the past few decades” – do you know what exponentially means? I think you’re overstating this especially if it STILL needs a respirator. On the other hand, what’s the air on Mars like? He might need something because of that difference.

On to #2

He spent MOST of three days and yet had also spent considerable time – I guess he could but it just doesn’t add up too well. Also, that second sentence is way too long.

Now this is harder for me to defend but that entire first paragraph is too full of different topics any one of which could be expanded on. You are trying to cram everything in and as a result, making nothing memorable.

Wonderous view of Earth
Arriving on the moon (Mars has two moons itself, wouldn’t he refer to it as Luna?)
Wondering about setting foot on the Earth
Longing for home through a telescope (unless he’s got a big, big one, there is not going to be all that much to see)
His telepathic twin
And, finally, his bonobo


[This message has been edited by arriki (edited November 06, 2009).]

Added later. If he is on the side of the moon where he can SEE the Earth, what are the chances Mars is visible, too? Only three days, remember?

[This message has been edited by arriki (edited November 06, 2009).]

IP: Logged

snapper
Member
posted November 06, 2009 09:17 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for snapper   Click Here to Email snapper     Edit/Delete Message
quote:
gravity 72% stronger than that on Mars – that seems wrong. Are you certain?

No it is not. I believe BT may have got that from subtracting the figure of Mars' 38% of Earth's gravity (still a mathematical error). Reversing that means that Earth's gravity is 263% of Mars'. In relation to our planet, that would mean a 150 pound man would weigh 395 pounds in a similiar gravity well.

Sorry, the prince's bones would snap and would likely die shortly after landing.

Other than that, I like V1 best. Puts the reader right into the story.

IP: Logged

NoTimeToThink
Member
posted November 06, 2009 08:21 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for NoTimeToThink   Click Here to Email NoTimeToThink     Edit/Delete Message
I like V1 better - more active and involved.

The main problem I'm having with it is that I have no idea what a bonobo is. An animal I've never heard of? Some genetically engineered critter? A robot? Moloki is the first character to speak, Samouri interacts with it, but there is no clue what it/he/she is. This:
1. Distracts me from the story while trying to figure it out.
2. Results in my brain constructing something to fill the void (in this case, a little silver TOBY robot), and when you finally reveal what a bonobo is, my brain will go through whiplash reconstructing the scene with the proper critter.

You need to either find away to quickly describe Moloki, or don't include it at the very start.

IP: Logged

Kathleen Dalton Woodbury
Administrator
posted November 06, 2009 11:28 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Kathleen Dalton Woodbury   Click Here to Email Kathleen Dalton Woodbury     Edit/Delete Message
Bonobos look like chimpanzees, only smaller. They are actually closer genetically to humans than chimpanzees are, according to some.

IP: Logged

TaoArtGuy
New Member
posted November 07, 2009 11:59 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for TaoArtGuy   Click Here to Email TaoArtGuy     Edit/Delete Message
I prefer the first one. The second just makes for a more awkward read. The "humans his race..." sentence in particular ground my reading to a halt.

The "he too felt anxious" right after the "I too feel heavy" stuck out to me for some reason I can't quite figure out yet.

“Welcome to Earth, your majesty. Although the air quality of Earth has improved..." Do you need that "of Earth" qualifier so soon after saying welcome to Earth? Try phrasing it "Although our air quality has improved..."

"...which there telekinetic bond" should be their telekinetic bond.

IP: Logged

arriki
Member
posted November 08, 2009 06:30 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for arriki   Click Here to Email arriki     Edit/Delete Message
How did I miss that? Telekinetic bond! Don't you mean telepathic bond?

A telekinetic bond would be some sort a ability to move objects.

IP: Logged

Bent Tree
Member
posted November 08, 2009 10:36 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Bent Tree   Click Here to Email Bent Tree     Edit/Delete Message
Thank you all. You have given me what I need to make my revision and decision. Sorry for the annoying typo's

IP: Logged

Architectus
Member
posted November 13, 2009 10:32 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Architectus   Click Here to Email Architectus     Edit/Delete Message
V1 all the way. It rocks. V2 felt bland to me.

quote:
"Moloki feel heavy” the digital voice

End with a period. . . . heavy." The . . .

My only compaint with the first one is they all talk a little nerdy, except the bonobo.

IP: Logged

All times are ET (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47d