| |||||||||||||||||||||
|
Hatrack River Writers Workshop
![]() Fragments and Feedback for Short Stories
![]() SF WIP
|
| next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: SF WIP |
|
Phobos Member |
Well, here is my first attemptin F&F. I am not yet ready for readers, but I am really interested in how this measures up. I look forward to any comment you may have on this first thirteen. thanks,
Second version quote: [This message has been edited by Phobos (edited November 17, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
BenM Member |
quote: This was interesting, but I wonder if (10) would keep me reading or turn me off. I'm not sure. I'd probably keep reading to find out if I'd keep reading (1) - I assumed this was a newly cloned ancient headset, and that it was then described as an incarnation of the Ryushooka. It was only on the re-read that I understood what this was. (2) - I wonder if these two sentences, which form a little exposition, should be in a paragraph of their own. Or, if you could perhaps show this and simultaneously trim the next sentence (3). (3) - The three actions in this sentence - extending, pressing, activating, I personally found awkward. Others won't. (4) - The impersonal 'The Ryushooka' made the male pronoun seem awkward to me. (5) - Whos? Honzu's or the Ryushooka's? (6) - I'm not sure the Then is necessary? (7) - comma here? (8) - Similar to earlier, the multiple actions and description in this sentence made it feel like a run-on to me. (9) - This could be shown, ie, by him asking "Why?" or similar. I'm not sure that telling works for me here. (10) - I worry that I've lost the character I've been following and trying to identify with. IP: Logged |
|
Phobos Member |
I posted a new intro. Hopefully that adressed at least some of the issues mentioned. I would be glad to hear wether or not they worked to make this better. [This message has been edited by Phobos (edited November 17, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
TaoArtGuy Member |
You have a couple of typos that just knock me out of the moment. laid - not layed wavered - not waivered
quote:The memories are moving forward/surging, not the feeds. Maybe The Ryushooka's eyes danced as memories surged down the feeds and into his brain. Interesting concept, though. IP: Logged |
|
Phobos Member |
Does the revision work? IP: Logged |
|
satate Member |
It works for me. I like it much better than the first one. It's a lot clearer and more engaging. IP: Logged |
|
NoTimeToThink Member |
Interesting, Frankenstein feel. Some suggestions for the start:
quote: IP: Logged |
All times are ET (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
|
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47d