| |||||||||||||||||||||
|
Hatrack River Writers Workshop
![]() Fragments and Feedback for Novels
![]() Query: YA Post-Apocalyptic
|
| next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: Query: YA Post-Apocalyptic |
|
wrenbird Member |
Dear Agent McAgentson: ***New Attempt a few replies down. Please critique that one.**** The abandoned ruins of Denver spread for miles, but to seventeen-year-old Jetta, they’re a prison. Enslaved by the ganglord Dagan for her rare gift, she’s spent her entire life seeking merk: the mysterious, liquid fallout that draws life from the charred soil, heals the sick, and gives inhuman powers to those who consume it. Jetta dreams of a free life in the mountains on the Western horizon, but in the face of a merk shortage, Dagan keeps her under tight watch. Then, a dying woman broadcasts a mass radio message describing a huge reserve of merk, hidden in the dangerous and forbidden East Half. It’s clear that obtaining it would bring incredible wealth and power, but seeking it would likely bring death. Jetta, however, sees a chance at freedom and is willing to face anything to gain it. After killing her guard, she becomes a desperate fugitive and must delve deep into the shadows of the East Half. Feral dogs, mutated by merk, hunt her. Radiation storms bring lightning and flash floods. And all the while, Dagan’s men close in around her. If Jetta doesn’t find the reserve soon, she’ll not only lose her one chance to be free, she’ll lose her life as well. SEARCHER is YA post-apocalyptic novel, complete at 79,000 words. Thank you for your time and consideration. ------------ Thoughts? Is it clear? Does it catch your interest? Thanks! [This message has been edited by wrenbird (edited October 02, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
thayeller Member |
The premise is interesting. But I think if this is your query you want to refine it. From what I have learned agents (if that is who you are sending it to) aren't interested in bogged down in details at first. They want a glimpse. I am not an expert and perhaps, people here have had some experience in what works for them. I think you will find this helpful. How to Write a Great Query Letter by Noah Lukeman, who is an expert. You can find it for free download at amazon.com. I only suggest this, because it was very helpful to me when I wanted to write a query and it was free. Good luck. [This message has been edited by thayeller (edited October 02, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
Devnal Member |
hey wrenbird, I know nothing about what agents look for in queries, but just as an overall read I find it very intriguing and well written. I get a solid understanding of the story (enviroment, how it will unfold, understanding of the MC and the conflict(s)). If this was something written on the back of a book it would get me to start reading the first page. "After killing her guard" - would it be better to just say "after escaping" and leave this detail of her escape to the story? (I don't know myself, maybe this is something the agent would want?)
IP: Logged |
|
MAP Member |
I think the website query shark is an awesome tool for writing good queries if you haven't already checked her out. This is her advice: quote: I think you are almost there, but you give a little too much plot info and not enough hint of character.
quote:
Here is my suggestion. Keep the first paragraph and elaborate on her and her ability. In the second paragraph, cut out how she learns about the hidden merk just say that she does and specifically explain how finding it will win her her freedom. In the final paragraph, say something like "But to win her freedom, she must first do the impossible and escape from Dagen, and then the hard part begins." Then explain the hardships she will face and the consequences of her failure like you did in the end of the last paragraph. All of this is just my oppinion, but I hope it helps. Good luck, this sounds like a good story. [This message has been edited by MAP (edited October 02, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
wrenbird Member |
Thanks guys! thayeller-thanks, I'll definitely try to slim down the the details if I can. Devnal-aww, your comment made my day! Thank you. And I'd always be game for more readers. I'll send you an email. MAP-Sound advice. I can see that I need to infuse more of Jetta in there. Thanks! [This message has been edited by wrenbird (edited October 02, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
wrenbird Member |
TAKE 2 --------------- The abandoned ruins of Denver spread for miles, but to seventeen-year-old Jetta, they’re a prison. Her dreams lie in mountains on the Western horizon, in a place of trees and rivers and life—birds never sing in the Ruins. But enslaved by the ganglord Dagan for her rare gift, she instead spends her days in the hovering deadness of the city, seeking merk: the mysterious, liquid fallout that draws life from the charred soil, heals the sick, and gives inhuman powers to those who consume it. When Jetta overhears word of a huge reserve of merk, possibly the last reserve left, she sees the means to survive, should she finally make her escape to the mountains. The plan has one problem, however. The merk reserve is said to be hidden in the dangerous and forbidden East Half. Determined to pursue her one chance, Jetta kills her guard, and becomes a desperate fugitive. She must delve deep into the shadows of the East Half. Feral dogs, mutated by merk, hunt her. Radiation storms bring lightning and flash floods. And all the while, Dagan’s men close in around her. If Jetta doesn’t find the reserve soon, she’ll not only lose her one chance to be free, she’ll lose her life as well. SEARCHER is YA post-apocalyptic novel, complete at 79,000 words. Thank you for your time and consideration. ------------- Better? IP: Logged |
|
MrsBrown Member |
Yes, better. I will echo the comments that I want to know what this rare gift of hers is, and I want a little more insight into Jetta's personality or internal life. The phrase "draws life from the charred soil" seems backward--how can charred soil act as a source of life? Perhaps restore life to the soil instead. [This message has been edited by MrsBrown (edited October 03, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
MAP Member |
Yes, much better. I like it alot. A few nits in your second paragraph.
quote: But I really like it. Good luck with this. It sounds like an awesome book. [This message has been edited by MAP (edited October 08, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
wrenbird Member |
Thanks so much, MAP and Mrs. Brown! I appreciate the comments.
IP: Logged |
|
KayTi Member |
Wren, congrats on being ready to query! A few nitpicks/suggestions on your letter. I think it's really good and compelling, makes me want to read the book, but here's a few things: - her dreams lie in THE mountains (the lack of "the" in the sentence was disruptive to me.) I think it's fabulous, good luck with this! - IP: Logged |
|
SavantIdiot Member |
The abandoned**Do we need abandoned? ruins sort of says it for me but maybe there's dangerous fallout?** ruins of Denver spread for miles, but **is but better than 'and' here?** to seventeen-year-old Jetta, they’re a prison. Her dreams lie in mountains on the Western horizon, in a place of trees and rivers and life—birds never sing in the Ruins. **are there birds in the ruins or do they just not sing there? I think I would prefer either no birds at all or more discussion as to why they don't sing but are there** But enslaved by the ganglord Dagan for her rare gift **I agree with the others, a little more specificity about the gift**, she instead spends her days in the hovering deadness of the city, seeking merk: the mysterious, liquid fallout that draws life from the charred soil, heals the sick, and gives inhuman powers to those who consume it. When Jetta overhears word of a huge reserve of merk, possibly the last reserve left, she sees the means to survive, should she finally make her escape to the mountains. The plan has one problem, however. The merk reserve is said to be hidden in the dangerous and forbidden East Half. Determined to pursue her one chance, Jetta kills her guard, and becomes a desperate fugitive. She must delve deep into the shadows of the East Half. Feral dogs, mutated by merk, hunt her. Radiation storms bring lightning and flash floods. And all the while, Dagan’s men close in around her. If Jetta doesn’t find the reserve soon, she’ll not only lose her one chance to be free, she’ll lose her life as well. I would keep reading, I think. I hope her gift is resistance to radioactive fallout, though! Or is that why she'll lose her life soon, for being exposed for so long? IP: Logged |
|
wrenbird Member |
Thanks so much KayTi and Savant. I definitely appreciate the feedback. In regards to her "rare gift," it is the ability to sense and find merk. So I don't know how I could explain that before explaining what merk is. And the way I have the who intro structured, I feel like I first and foremost have to say that she is enslaved for her gift. So you can see, it's a bit of a sticky spot. I'll play around with it and see what I can do. Thanks again! IP: Logged |
|
KayTi Member |
Throw an extra sentence at the end of that first para: "Her gift lets her sense and find merk, a trait the underlord is eager to exploit..." (or something about how he's unwilling to un-enslave her because he needs her so bad. I'm sure part of what you play with here is her feelings of helplessness about having to help find merk for this bad dude.) Good luck! IP: Logged |
All times are ET (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
|
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47d