| |||||||||||||||||||||
|
Hatrack River Writers Workshop
![]() Fragments and Feedback for Novels
![]() Adventures of Mark Henderson - The Lost Library
|
| next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: Adventures of Mark Henderson - The Lost Library |
|
Raider Member |
Hello everyone. I'm posting the first few lines from my story. I haven't written much so far and I'd like to hear your thoughts. I'm hoping to write a series of novels about this Mark Henderson character. I have several other ideas for other adventures and this is just one of the ideas in the pile. So I figured I'd try to evolve this one. First let me give you all a quick introduction to the character himself. Mark Henderson is a legendary explorer and self-taugh adventurer, who travels the world exploring ancient ruins, searching for lost treasures, and chasing some of the most unbelievable conspiracy theories there are. His journeys take him to places that ordinary, extraordinary, and beyond the imagination. Ok folks, here's the first few lines. I don't have alot of experience yet so bear with me.
[This message has been edited by Raider (edited November 12, 2009).] [This message has been edited by Kathleen Dalton Woodbury (edited November 12, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
tchernabyelo Member |
If this is a novel-length work, then you're in the wrong thread. Novel openings work very different from short stories (IMHO) as novel hooks are often the cover and back page blurb, or for an agent/editor the symopsis, so I tend to think they are less "important" than a short story first 13. This reads to me as competent enough, but it lacks a spark, and the setting is faintly confusing - new millennium makes me think it's current, butler generally does not (I know there are people with butlers still around these days, but it feels out of place without knowing anything about the MC). Additionally, you are trying to cram a lot of backstory/background in, which arguably you do not need in a novel opening - your back cover copy/synopsis will do that so the first 13 doesn't have to (the cover copy might be "Determined to find the fabled lost hall of records in the Egyptian sands, Mark Henderson uncovers ancient clues that lead him into an adventure where..." etc etc). IP: Logged |
|
Raider Member |
Thank you for your input, I suppose I should try to elaborate on the MC a little more first. I wasn't sure if I was trying to cram too much info in my first few lines. And yes, I realize this topic is in the wrong category, that was my mistake. I need to contact the administrator and have it moved. [This message has been edited by Raider (edited November 12, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
Meredith Member |
Reminds me of Indiana Jones and Lara Croft. Which is fine if you do it well and differentiate your character.I'm not great on first thirteens. That said, I think I would start off with just his first name. If we're in his POV he probably doesn't think of himself by his full name. Let the Butler call him Mr. Henderson. And I second the previous opinion. I want to know a little more about the character before I care about what he's doing. Also, this is a very passive beginning. I don't believe everything has to start in media res, especially in novels. But sitting at a desk isn't very exciting. We've all done that. Most of us read novels to enter the worlds of people who do things we can't or haven't done. Maybe he paces while he's trying to think? Or maybe your story starts with his excitement when he gets a new piece of information to fit into the puzzle. IP: Logged |
|
Raider Member |
Ok, I've re-written the entire beginning so hopefully this one won't seem so passive. Let me know what you all think. Mark made his way down the dark, dusty corridor with his flashlight illuminating the way. Dust and cobwebs were everywhere; it looked as if nobody had been down these halls in centuries. With the light in one hand, and a gun in the other, he proceeded cautiously, not knowing what could be lurking around the next corner. [This message has been edited by Raider (edited November 12, 2009).] [This message has been edited by Kathleen Dalton Woodbury (edited November 13, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
ScardeyDog Member |
Hi Raider. I'm fairly new to writing myself, so take my comments with a grain of salt. "Mark made his way down the dark, dusty corridor with his flashlight illuminating the way. Dust and cobwebs were everywhere; it looked as if nobody had been down these halls in centuries. " You mention dust in both these sentences, which you don't need to do. Maybe cut it from the first one. "With the light in one hand, and a gun in the other, he proceeded cautiously, not knowing what could be lurking around the next corner." Here you tell us he is holding things, but you don't really describe them, or how he feels about them. Maybe you could have something creak and he could spin and point the light and gun in that direction (or something, just off the top of my head). That would let us know he is holding both and that he is nervous. "Mark reached the end of the hall and found himself in a large room." Again, I would like more description of what he sees. "He thought to himself, “That’s strange;..." This part is tricky for me to define, as I don't have the vocab. Dialogue tags like "he tought to himself" seem old fashioned to me. Some writers put thoughts in italics to differentiate them from narration. Some writers use "Free indirect discourse" which someone else here will have to explain, since I can't remember. Hope that helps! IP: Logged |
|
Meredith Member |
Okay, I was hoping someone else would pitch in so I wouldn't have to be the one, again. Waking up from a dream is a pretty cliched opening. I got told the same thing when I tried it with Dreamer's Rose. Can you show him a little earlier or a little later in the story getting a key piece of information? Or the moment when the pieces come together and he has an idea where his goal is located? I don't subscribe to the idea that you have to have something really exciting right off. But you do have to show the character involved in something interesting enough to draw the reader in. And, because it's a novel, not a short story, your original opening might have been just fine if that moment of interest was coming right up. IP: Logged |
|
shimiqua Member |
I have a character named Mark Henderson. How funny. Don't worry, I'll change his name. I was going to anyway. As for the story, I like your second try better. I agree with everything what Scardey Dog said. I.E. Ditto. IP: Logged |
|
Raider Member |
Ok guys, I've come up with a third attempt at my first 13. Hopefully the third time's the charm. This place is important because the MC returns to this place later in the story. My only concern is that I may be trying to put too much information into this intro. What do you think?
[This message has been edited by Raider (edited December 01, 2009).] IP: Logged |
|
Raider Member |
thread bump IP: Logged |
|
Jesse D Member |
Far, far better than the first two. I'm not sure I love your character's name, though: Mark Henderson? Way too bland for an adventurous archeologist. Just my two cents. IP: Logged |
All times are ET (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
|
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47d