Hatrack River
Home   |   About Orson Scott Card   |   News & Reviews   |   OSC Library   |   Forums   |   Contact   |   Links
Research Area   |   Writing Lessons   |   Writers Workshops   |   OSC at SVU   |   Calendar   |   Store
E-mail this page
  Hatrack River Writers Workshop
  Fragments and Feedback for Novels
  Seven Stars--Fantasy

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Seven Stars--Fantasy
Meredith
Member
posted November 15, 2009 05:53 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Meredith   Click Here to Email Meredith     Edit/Delete Message
I'm still really not sure I'm starting this in the right place. Here's the current first 13:

Tia forced herself to sit quietly beside her sister. She would rather walk. Walking or even pacing helped her think. Activity swirled around them. Men were preparing the palace and the city for the coming war. Women and servants were busy packing up large parts of the furnishings to be taken to the mountain fortress along with the women. In the midst of all of this, their father had sent for them to his private audience chamber. It had to be something important.

“What do you think it’s about?” Janessa asked, smoothing the folds of her skirt for the third time.

“I suspect Father has chosen husbands for us,” Erytia answered, tapping her feet. “To solidify the succession and gain him allies for this war. And he doesn’t think we’ll like his choices.”

Second Attempt:
Erytia paced across the room. She reached the corner and turned around to pace back. She had been pacing since she had picked up the news from one of the servants. Artria was preparing for war.

“Will you settle down?” Janessa said. “You should be doing your needlework. And you’ve made me miss a stitch. What’s made you so restless today, anyway?”

“Father is going to war.”

“So? We won’t be expected to fight in it.”

Tia sighed. Janessa could be almost willfully dense at times. “This changes everything, Jana.”

“I don’t see how. Father has gone to war before.”

“When we were children. We’re grown now. Marriageable.

Third attempt: The second rambled a little because I was in a hurry this morning, but I just had to write what was in my head.

Erytia paced across the room. She reached the corner and turned around to pace back. She had been pacing since she had picked up the news from one of the servants. Artria was preparing for war.

“Will you settle down?” Janessa said. “What’s made you so restless today, anyway?”

“I’m not restless. I’m thinking. This changes everything, Jana.”

“I don’t see how, Tia. It’s not like we’ll be expected to fight.”

“Not directly, perhaps. But the balance of power in the court changes with a war. Until now, it’s suited Father to keep us unmarried. Now, he may have to use us to cement alliances

Fourth Try:
Tia forced herself to sit quietly beside her sister. She would rather walk. Walking or even pacing helped her think. She had to compose her arguments in her head so she wouldn’t hesitate or miss an important point.

Activity swirled around them. Men were preparing the palace and the city for the coming war. Women and servants were busy packing valuables to be taken to the mountain fortress along with the women. In the midst of all of this, their father had sent for them to his private audience chamber. There was only one possible reason for that. Tia had actually been expecting this since word of the advancing army came.

“What do you think it’s about?” Janessa asked, smoothing the folds of her skirt for the third time.


[This message has been edited by Meredith (edited November 17, 2009).]

[This message has been edited by Meredith (edited November 17, 2009).]

IP: Logged

Dark Warrior
Member
posted November 15, 2009 06:12 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Dark Warrior   Click Here to Email Dark Warrior     Edit/Delete Message
I am not a master of punctuation, and such but I am thinking...

quote:
Walking or even pacing helped her think.
should have a comma or two ",or even pacing,"

quote:
“To solidify the succession and gain him allies for this war. And he doesn’t think we’ll like his choices.”

Feels to me like this would be known to them and they probably have already discussed it many times, so would not be additional conversation, but would be a thought of the MC after she says he is probably choosing husbands.

Nicely written, had a good flow to it. You set the scene for me well, but the only real hook that I read into it was of a father picking husbands for daughters and them not happy...which, to me, has been done often enough and needs something more to keep me reading.

IP: Logged

Meredith
Member
posted November 15, 2009 07:24 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Meredith   Click Here to Email Meredith     Edit/Delete Message
quote:
but the only real hook that I read into it was of a father picking husbands for daughters and them not happy...which, to me, has been done often enough and needs something more to keep me reading.

Yeah. That's why I'm not sure this is the beginning. It does go off in an unexpected direction (I think). On the other hand, I kind of need this set up.

FWIW, one of the girls has given this a lot of thought and made some shrewd guesses. The other has done more daydreaming than thinking and isn't being realistic in her expectations.

IP: Logged

Dark Warrior
Member
posted November 15, 2009 07:47 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Dark Warrior   Click Here to Email Dark Warrior     Edit/Delete Message
If you need it, keep it, but what about adding some conflict to broaden the hook, or keep us wondering about it, something like...

“What do you think it’s about?” Janessa asked, smoothing the folds of her skirt for the third time.

“I suspect Father has chosen husbands for us,” Erytia answered, tapping her feet.

"I think it is more dire than that. One of the nightguards that fancies me seems to think ...

- that assassins may have infiltrated the guard
- father is sending us to neverneverland to be safe
- he has found out about you and your nightly meetings with Shrek.

whatever you could add, that fits into your tale.

Just a suggestion, looking forward to more.

IP: Logged

Meredith
Member
posted November 16, 2009 12:01 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Meredith   Click Here to Email Meredith     Edit/Delete Message
quote:
"I think it is more dire than that. One of the nightguards that fancies me seems to think ...

- that assassins may have infiltrated the guard
- father is sending us to neverneverland to be safe
- he has found out about you and your nightly meetings with Shrek.


LOL. Have you been peeking at my fourteenth line?

No. It's not any of those.

Up the conflict? Well, at this point, the conflict is mostly in Tia's thoughts. She knows the answer and she has reason to really be unhappy about it. Maybe I can move the dialog down a bit and get into the thoughts sooner. I'll take a look at that.

Course, it's still basically girls unhappy with the husbands their father has chosen in the first chapter. The train doesn't come off the rails until chapter two.

Edited to add:

Hmm. Maybe I could push the beginning back. Start with the first indications of coming war. The status quo has changed. Tia would do the mental calculations to figure out what that means for her and her sister and then seek out more information. Then I can make it clear exactly why she's so unhappy about this. She does have a very valid reason. That could work.

[This message has been edited by Meredith (edited November 16, 2009).]

IP: Logged

Meredith
Member
posted November 16, 2009 11:32 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Meredith   Click Here to Email Meredith     Edit/Delete Message
bump for new version.

IP: Logged

insectica411
Member
posted November 16, 2009 12:28 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for insectica411   Click Here to Email insectica411     Edit/Delete Message
I think the first is the better of the two. I would work with that one a bit more. If you only have thirteen lines to get someone’s interest I would try to milk as much out of them as you can. Make sure there are no wasted words.

IP: Logged

Meredith
Member
posted November 16, 2009 05:25 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Meredith   Click Here to Email Meredith     Edit/Delete Message
Bump for third try.

IP: Logged

Kitti
Member
posted November 16, 2009 10:10 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Kitti   Click Here to Email Kitti     Edit/Delete Message
Just to be ornery, I think I like the second one better than the third. I get more of a sense of the girls' personalities and their relationship with one another.

IP: Logged

MAP
Member
posted November 16, 2009 11:27 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for MAP     Edit/Delete Message
I like the first one the best. If you want me to give you nits about it I will, but it seems like you are not sure where to start, so I can wait until you decided.

I think the dynamic between the girls is clearly shown in the first, and it feels like something is going to happen soon where the other two feel more drawn out. I like the marriages already arranged better then just hinting at.

The girls being forced into marriages is a good hook for me. I know it has been done before, but I have no idea where you are going with it. It certainly provides the tension that would make me turn the page.

Besides, what hasn't been done before.

I like it. I would keep reading.

IP: Logged

Meredith
Member
posted November 17, 2009 12:16 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Meredith   Click Here to Email Meredith     Edit/Delete Message
Okay, two votes for the first. On reflection, I think I can rework it to get what I want. Maybe. Too tired tonight, though. I'll see what I can do with it tomorrow.

Thanks everybody.

IP: Logged

Meredith
Member
posted November 17, 2009 01:11 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Meredith   Click Here to Email Meredith     Edit/Delete Message
Bump for new version.

IP: Logged

Raider
Member
posted November 17, 2009 05:07 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Raider   Click Here to Email Raider     Edit/Delete Message
I like the first version the best. However, I do agree with Dark Warrior's suggestion to add a little more conflict to provide more of a hook for the reader.

“I suspect Father has chosen husbands for us,” Erytia answered, tapping her feet.

"I think it is more dire than that. One of the nightguards that fancies me seems to think ...

IP: Logged

All times are ET (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47d