posted
Faramir 27 Aragorn 23 Eomer 23 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Balrog 19 Sam 17 King Theoden 17 The One Ring 13 Galadriel 13 Frodo 11 Shadowfax 9 Prince Imrahil 9 Merry 9 Pippin 7 Nazgul 5 Bilbo 1
++ Merry - I wanted to vote for Merry and Pippin, how could they be on the same score as the nazgul, but I'm sticking to two down, one up. -- Nazgul - see above -- The One Ring - My pressioussss
Posts: 169 | Registered: Aug 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Faramir 25 Aragorn 23 Eomer 21 Gandalf 19 Balrog 19 Eowyn 17 Sam 17 King Theoden 17 The One Ring 13 Galadriel 13 Frodo 11 Shadowfax 9 Prince Imrahil 9 Merry 7 Pippin 7 Nazgul 5 Bilbo 1
++ Pippin - desperately trying to save Merry and Pippin, whilst only viting one up at a time. -- Nazgul -- Eomer
Posts: 169 | Registered: Aug 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 23 Faramir 23 Eomer 21 Gandalf 17 Balrog 17 Eowyn 17 Sam 17 King Theoden 17 Galadriel 13 Frodo 11 The One Ring 11 Shadowfax 9 Prince Imrahil 9 Merry 7 Pippin 7 Nazgul 5 Bilbo 1
++ Eomer -- Gandalf -- Balrog
I also fixed Eomer, TOR, and Faramir. Someone, ahem, Steve, rounded them down to even numbers for some reason, I put them back.
Posts: 21898 | Registered: Nov 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 23 Faramir 23 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Sam 17 King Theoden 17 Balrog 15 Galadriel 13 Frodo 11 The One Ring 9 Prince Imrahil 9 Shadowfax 9 Pippin 7 Nazgul 7 Merry 5 Bilbo (dead)
-- Balrog (Not really a character; more a means of plot development) -- TOR (Shouldn't this have been linked to Sauron somehow? Is there a personality to TOR without Sauron?) ++ Eowyn (Mainly for Miranda Otto's performance in TTT)
<edit> I believe Steve didn't update the list after he voted, so I added points to Shadowfax and Gandalf and took from Bilbo in his behalf. This means Bilbo's dead and Steve owes the story </edit>
Posts: 2926 | Registered: Sep 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 23 Faramir 23 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Sam 17 Balrog 17 King Theoden 15 Galadriel 13 Frodo 9 The One Ring 9 Prince Imrahil 9 Shadowfax 7 Pippin 7 Merry 7 Nazgul 7 Bilbo (dead)
-- Frodo (sissy) -- King Theoden (Pretty cool guy, but I believe he is now the only one on the list who dies. Not counting TOR and the Nazgul ... and the people who sail to the undying lands ...) ++ Balrog (Because he is cool! Who cares how minor of a character! He's cool!)
Posts: 2827 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 23 Faramir 23 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Sam 17 Balrog 17 King Theoden 15 Galadriel 13 Prince Imrahil 9 Shadowfax 9 Frodo 7 The One Ring 7 Pippin 7 Merry 7 Nazgul 7 Bilbo (dead)
-- The One Ring: Honestly, it's just a ring. ++ Shadowfax: I'm still rooting for him -- Frodo: I like villains better
Posts: 973 | Registered: Apr 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 23 Faramir 23 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Sam 17 Balrog 15 King Theoden 15 Galadriel 13 Prince Imrahil 9 Shadowfax 9 Frodo 9 Pippin 7 Merry 7 Nazgul 7 The One Ring 5 Bilbo (dead)
-- Balrog -- TOR ++ Frodo (Elijah Wood may be a sissy, Dr. Merkwürdigeliebe, but Frodo never was. He faced down challenges and trials greater than any other character (except maybe Gandalf)).
Posts: 2926 | Registered: Sep 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Faramir 25 Aragorn 21 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Sam 19 Balrog 15 King Theoden 13 Galadriel 11 Prince Imrahil 9 Frodo 9 Merry 7 Pippin 7 Shadowfax 5 Nazgul 5 The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
++ Frodo (ok, ok, so Frodo is ok ... the last -- was for Elijah Wood, these ++ are for Frodo) -- Shadowfax ++ Sam
Posts: 2827 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 21 Faramir 21 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Sam 19 Balrog 13 King Theoden 11 Galadriel 11 Prince Imrahil 9 Pippin 7 Shadowfax 7 Merry 7 Frodo 3 Nazgul 1 The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
++ Merry - I'm on the "save the hobbits" campaign -- King Theoden - He was scary before he transformed -- Balrog - yeah, I don't see what everyone loves about him (it?)
Posts: 1789 | Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 21 Faramir 21 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 17 Sam 17 King Theoden 13 Galadriel 13 Balrog 9 Prince Imrahil 7 Pippin 7 Shadowfax 7 Merry 9 Frodo 5 Nazgul 1 The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
++ Galadriel (Long live the lady of the Noldor) -- Prince Imrahil (How important is he? Really?) -- Balrog (Just continuing my vendetta against non-characters)
Posts: 2926 | Registered: Sep 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aragorn 21 Faramir 21 Eomer 21 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 17 Sam 17 King Theoden 13 Galadriel 13 Balrog 9 Merry 9 Pippin 9 Prince Imrahil 7 Frodo 7 Shadowfax 5 Nazgul 1 The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
++ Pippin (Has to be with Merry) ++ Frodo (He's not one of my favorite characters by any means, but he definately does not belong below Shadowfax) -- Shadowfax (See above)
Posts: 2827 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Faramir 23 Aragorn 19 Eomer 19 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 17 Sam 17 King Theoden 13 Galadriel 13 Pippin 11 Merry 9 Balrog 7 Prince Imrahil 7 Frodo 7 Shadowfax 5 Nazgul -1 dead The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
++ Pippin - Paid up member of STH -- Nazgul -- Balrog
A cat leapt out of the bushed and bit a Nazgul to death. It lost a life in the process. Then it scratched another to death and lost a life. The next was licked to death and another life went. Luckily the cat had nine lives, and the Nazgul perished.
When are the other deaths going to be written?
Posts: 169 | Registered: Aug 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Faramir 23 Aragorn 19 Eomer 19 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 17 Sam 17 King Theoden 13 Galadriel 13 Pippin 11 Balrog 9 Merry 7 Prince Imrahil 7 Frodo 7 Shadowfax 3 Nazgul -1 dead The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
++ Balrog -- Merry -- Shadowfax
Should we go back and edit the scores to eliminate SteveRoger's extra votes?
Posts: 109 | Registered: Oct 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
Faramir 21 Sam 19 Eomer 19 Aragorn 19 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 17 Galadriel 13 King Theoden 13 Pippin 11 Balrog 9 Merry 7 Prince Imrahil 7 Frodo 5 Shadowfax (dead) The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
-- Galadriel - just to spite Teleperion ++ Sam - the real hero of the books -- Frodo - just didn't do it for me. I'm not a huge fan of Elijah Wood
Posts: 1789 | Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
Faramir 23 Sam 19 Eomer 19 Aragorn 19 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Galadriel 13 King Theoden 13 Pippin 11 Balrog 9 Merry 7 Prince Imrahil 7 Frodo 3 Shadowfax (dead) The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
++ Gandalf [HARRY POTTER SPOILER WARNING: Without Dumbledore, we need someone wise and semi-omnipotent] -- Frodo [whiny little brat] ++ Faramir [if I mention "unconscious Faramir covered in oil", how many Jatraqueros will get the reference?]
Posts: 1735 | Registered: Oct 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
DISCLAIMER : I am not voting, I am simply adjusting the score to eliminate SteveRoger's two extra votes. Please only vote once a day from now on.
Faramir 27 Sam 19 Eomer 19 Aragorn 19 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 19 Galadriel 13 King Theoden 13 Pippin 11 Balrog 9 Merry 7 Prince Imrahil 7 Frodo 7 Nazgul 3
Shadowfax (dead) The One Ring (dead) Bilbo (dead)
The Nazgul, having been unjustly killed, were brought back to life, much to the delight of everyone here rooting for the bad guys.
EDIT: Evie, "Jatraquero" is simply a fake spanish word for "Hatracker". I prefer the word "Hatracker" myself, if only to go against the trend. Posts: 609 | Registered: Oct 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
I just want to say, that while it may be fake it makes searching for anything hatrack related easy as pie.
Posts: 503 | Registered: May 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Faramir 29 Sam 19 Eomer 19 Aragorn 19 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 17 Galadriel 13 King Theoden 13 Pippin 9 Balrog 9 Merry 9 Prince Imrahil 7 Frodo 7
-- Merry (why was he below pippin?!) ++ Pippin (why was he above merry?!) -- Nazgul
Credit goes to Kettricken:
A cat leapt out of the bushed and bit a Nazgul to death. It lost a life in the process. Then it scratched another to death and lost a life. The next was licked to death and another life went. Luckily the cat had nine lives, and the Nazgul perished.
Posts: 2827 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Faramir 27 Aragorn 21 Sam 19 Eomer 19 Eowyn 19 Gandalf 17 Galadriel 13 King Theoden 13 Pippin 9 Balrog 9 Merry 9 Frodo 7 Prince Imrahil 5
Shadowfax (dead) (death by Telperion) The One Ring (dead) (death by Steve) Bilbo (dead) (death by Steve)
-- Faramir (I like Faramir, but c'mon, 29 pts! Isn't that excessive?) ++ Aragorn (Noble son of Numenor, arise) -- Prince Imrahil (He seems like a good enough guy, but his impact is very low. Besides, I don't like Frodo being tied for last.)
I propose we institute a 48 hr rule on writing deaths. If the deaths aren't written within 48 hours of the killing, it becomes open to anyone. Do I hear a second?
Posts: 2926 | Registered: Sep 2005
| IP: Logged |
Printer-friendly view of this topic
![[Wink]](wink.gif)
![[Big Grin]](biggrin.gif)
