quote:Because reforming the foster care system is one of the most important things that can be done in this country, telling people what they can and can't read isn't!
Could you please explain why you keep talking about people telling other people what they can and can't read? No one has been doing that. The Catholic League hasn't been doing that. I didn't mention it in the post to which you responded.
Moreover, the larger point is this: You seem to think it's OK for someone who thinks something is important to tell other people how they should act with respect to that something. You've done it repeatedly in this thread.
Perhaps you should be focusing on reforming the foster care system rather than focusing on telling other people they shouldn't be give recommendations about books.
Posts: 26071 | Registered: Oct 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:Originally posted by Rakeesh: But let me ask you a question. Let's suppose that there was some media out there that was doing serious, notable harm to your ideas of what improvements should be made to the foster care system in the United States.
This media isn't saying something overtly horrible like 'punish recalcitrant children with cigarette burns', but it's just persuasively proposing a series of ideas that you are quite convinced are harmful. This media is having a great deal of popular success and is in fact doing what you perceive is real harm to an important thing in you're life.
That might be a good point because the media ALREADY does a lot of damage when it comes to the foster care system, portraying every single foster parent as being in it for the money or damaging children, heaping the blame on foster parents instead of on their abusive biological parents. They are spreading misconceptions about the system and not offering useful solutions. Boycotting the media won't stop them, but putting the truth about the subject will.
quote:The Catholic League wants Christians to stay away from this movie precisely because it knows that the film is bait for the books: unsuspecting parents who take their children to see the movie may be impelled to buy the three books as a Christmas present. And no parent who wants to bring their children up in the faith will want any part of these books.
But it seems like that's what they are doing to me, telling folks to stay away from the movie, avoid reading these books... I don't see the use because I still see them as being against the sort of people who state they are religious and then turn around and do cruel things in the name of religion, but they don't think it's cruel because it's in the name of God. It's deeply annoying because they don't seem to get that aspect of the book and focus on the anti-Church aspects...
Now to take a series of unpleasant tests. 2 more to go.
Posts: 9942 | Registered: Mar 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:That might be a good point because the media ALREADY does a lot of damage when it comes to the foster care system, portraying every single foster parent as being in it for the money or damaging children, heaping the blame on foster parents instead of on their abusive biological parents. They are spreading misconceptions about the system and not offering useful solutions. Boycotting the media won't stop them, but putting the truth about the subject will.
I reject your claims about what 'the media' says about the foster care system. I'm not the apparently serious follower of foster-care news that you are, but I'm not completely cut off from the media either and your assessment seems unduly negative and hostile to me.
But that aside, just to be clear, you would tell people to go and view such harmful media without telling them anything, warning them about its flaws and such?
Posts: 17164 | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
http://forums.adoption.com/foster-parent-support/314375-criminal-minds.html It really isn't unduly negative and hostile. This is what happens. Read the accounts of adoptive parents of older children and see what they have to say when they adopt older childrne and try to get help or support only to get none. It does happen. Also, it's the MEDIA. How much of what the media says can we really trust? Hardly any of it. But I would correct their assumptions. There is Guatemala to consider. The media only has tiny little grains of the truth in it about it, but it's not enough to condemn the whole system of adoption without knowing the whole picture.
Posts: 9942 | Registered: Mar 2003
| IP: Logged |
I'm asking if you would correct their assumptions before or after they get the chance to make them, even if you know or at least can safely assume that the media they view will persuasively lead them to make bad assumptions?
Posts: 17164 | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
Beforehand, but I don't think these things are the same. One is the foster care system. Misunderstandings on that can have a negative effect on thousands of children and their families, foster or otherwise. Some might say reading a book like His Dark Materials could have a negative effect on children (it could if they are too young to read it, the idea of cutting away a child's soul is horrible, but you can't deny that historically things like that have happened in the past numerous times, with numerous faiths, how else can you get rid of that by challenging that corruption directly and by pointing out how the system needs to be fixed?) But I think I have had enough...
Posts: 9942 | Registered: Mar 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
Boycotting is about protecting others from what you believe to be harmful effects of certain media.
'Warning' others to avoid specific assumptions due to harmful media is about protecting them from those assumptions. The difference is purely one of degree.
quote:One is the foster care system. Misunderstandings on that can have a negative effect on thousands of children and their families, foster or otherwise.
For better or worse, religion is surely one of those things which leads to human beings benefiting or hurting other.
quote:...how else can you get rid of that by challenging that corruption directly and by pointing out how the system needs to be fixed?)
Well let's be clear here, you're not talking about 'challenging corruption' here. You love the books after all. One method of avoiding corruption is quite simple: avoid being corrupted in the first place!
Posts: 17164 | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged |
quote:Originally posted by Synesthesia: I wouldn't tell other people not to read them, it's up to them to form their own judgement, but sometimes folks you don't agree with have interesting things to say about certain aspects of things that would be overlooked if one is told not to examine them.
This is not how you behave when it's something you feel strongly about, such as Ezzo. Your condemnation of his books and ideas are much more forceful than the relatively mild tactics of the CL that you're condemning.
Posts: 16551 | Registered: Feb 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:Originally posted by Synesthesia: I wouldn't tell other people not to read them, it's up to them to form their own judgement, but sometimes folks you don't agree with have interesting things to say about certain aspects of things that would be overlooked if one is told not to examine them.
This is not how you behave when it's something you feel strongly about, such as Ezzo. Your condemnation of his books and ideas are much more forceful than the relatively mild tactics of the CL that you're condemning.
\\Dude, that's because Ezzo's books have actually caused failure to thrive in infants or have caused women to lose their breast milk! They are dangerous books. His Dark Materials is a thought provoking series, but it's not causing attachment disorders in babies or causing parents to be indifferent towards their children. Ezzo's books are really dangerous, and Pearl worse so. I can't help but be angry over a book that tells people to hit their children repeatedly over normal child behaviour. It's entirely different.
Posts: 9942 | Registered: Mar 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:\\Dude, that's because Ezzo's books have actually caused failure to thrive in infants or have caused women to lose their breast milk! They are dangerous books. His Dark Materials is a thought provoking series, but it's not causing attachment disorders in babies or causing parents to be indifferent towards their children. Ezzo's books are really dangerous, and Pearl worse so. I can't help but be angry over a book that tells people to hit their children repeatedly over normal child behaviour. It's entirely different.
For parents who believe their children will experience eternal suffering if they reject their religion, it is NOT entirely different. Whether or not you agree the dangers they perceive are real, they are trying to prevent children from experiencing what they see, rightly or wrongly, as real harm - the same as you are.
Although I do think the best thing is for parents to discuss potentially disagreeable books with their children (if the kids want to read them in the first place), rather than just disallowing them, I think it's a good thing to be aware of the worldview behind writings - which seems to be the guidance the CL is providing.
Posts: 57 | Registered: Jul 2007
| IP: Logged |
quote:\\Dude, that's because Ezzo's books have actually caused failure to thrive in infants or have caused women to lose their breast milk! ... Ezzo's books are really dangerous, and Pearl worse so. I can't help but be angry over a book that tells people to hit their children repeatedly over normal child behaviour. It's entirely different.
So, we're agreed -- when you care about something, boycotts are fine and good, but when you don't, they're not.
Posts: 16551 | Registered: Feb 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:His Dark Materials is a thought provoking series, but it's not causing attachment disorders in babies or causing parents to be indifferent towards their children.
I'm beginning to believe this is simply willful ignorance on your part, Synethesia. Clearly you do not believe that saying hateful things about a religion and potentially dissuading others from that religion is an awful thing. I'm not busting your chops for that.
But just imagine for a moment, if you can, that you did belong to a religion which did in fact believe that media which say hateful and potentially persuasive bad things about their religion are spiritually harmful (because naturally you believe your religion is true), and thus should be avoided-and far from being unhealty to suggest others avoid it, is unhealthy not to.
It's really quite simple: so far you are unwilling to accept the gigantic blurry gray area contained in the concept of importance.
Posts: 17164 | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
If a person is actually convinced by a book to abandon his religion, then this says one of two things:
1.) He is justified in doing so either because his religion really is flawed or because he does not yet understand the religion well enough to dedicate his life to its practice - whether it is based in truth or not.
or
2.) He is unable to think for himself and make his own decisions on the matter. If this is the case, then his former belief in that religion amounted to crap anyway.
Posts: 1945 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
mph: Not to be confrontational, but the way I read it, Synesthesia seemed to be saying in the first sentence that the difference is not so much the level of care involved but that Ozzo's books "have actually caused" in the sense that whether or not Ozzo's methods have real-world consequences can actually be seen.
rollainm: Well, to be fair, the Catholic League seems to be primarily concerned about the books effect on kids, kids that would not be so much abandoning a religion but would never have really understood or made an informed choice to join/stay in a religion in the first place.
Posts: 7593 | Registered: Sep 2006
| IP: Logged |
quote:1.) He is justified in doing so either because his religion really is flawed or because he does not yet understand the religion well enough to dedicate his life to its practice - whether it is based in truth or not.
A person is always justified in abandoning his religion of his own free will.
That has nothing to do with this, though.
Posts: 17164 | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
Well, no, he's not. If he is reasonably convinced that his religion is truth then he'd be completely unjustified in abandoning it. It would be just plain stupid of him really. The whole "willfully turning your back on God" bit just doesn't hold water with any reasonably thinking person.
But anyway, please note Mucus' point and my concession above. I'd already backed off (although technically I could press further that my initial point still stands regardless of the person's age or experience - in fact, experience is part of the point).
Posts: 1945 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
quote:If he is reasonably convinced that his religion is truth then he'd be completely unjustified in abandoning it.
Sure he is, at least as far as you or I are concerned. Those particular issues are (imo, obviously) exclusively between him and God. It's not for me to say that he's justified or not.
Incidentally, I can easily imagine many situations where turning one's back on God 'holds water'.
Posts: 17164 | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
Aggravating. The don't get it right at all. it wasn't the Catholic church, it was a protestant church. Calvinist. It also wasn't God, but Enoch (I think it branches from an extremely old legend) who took over heaven from God somehow. (God was the old angel) Why are they griping about this book NOW when it's been out since 1997?
Posts: 9942 | Registered: Mar 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:The Church in Lyra’s world exerts a major influence on the lives of all the characters. It has a college of cardinals, a college of bishops, priests, nuns, and a magisterium. It even boasts converts from Protestantism. In Lyra’s world, Protestant reformers remained within the Church, elected John Calvin as Pope, moved the Church’s headquarters to Geneva, and then did away with the papacy altogether.
Seems to me they're acknowledging it was Calvinist.
quote:Why are they griping about this book NOW when it's been out since 1997?
Because there's what will most likely be a promising movie coming out about it soon.
Posts: 26071 | Registered: Oct 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:Originally posted by Rakeesh: I'm beginning to believe this is simply willful ignorance on your part, Synethesia. Clearly you do not believe that saying hateful things about a religion and potentially dissuading others from that religion is an awful thing.
I don't want to start anything, but...don't religions do this to other religions all the time?
Posts: 3852 | Registered: Feb 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
Frankly, I think calling for a boycott is a little silly. I appreciate that they perceive this film to be spiritually harmful, but honestly, adults are supposed to be capable of taking what they see and thinking about it and deciding which bits they agree with and which bits not. Faith shouldn't be so shaky that one film/book can take it apart.
John Milton said some really excellent things in Areopagitica about banning books; I wish I had the whole thing in front of me so I could quote it. Basically he was saying that people can't go through their whole lives without encountering ideas that run contrary to their faith, and it was better that it should happen in a book, where the temptation to stray from faith would not be so great. He thought that evil in books was like a spiritual rehearsal for evil in life, and you shouldn't shelter yourself from it, because then you would be more unprepared for real tests of your faith.
He said (I wrote this bit down in my commonplace book), "We should be wary therefore what persecution we raise against the living labours of publick men, how we spill that season'd life of man preserv'd and stor'd up in Books, since we see a kind of homicide may be thus committed....whereof the execution ends not in the slaying of an elemental life, but strikes at that ethereall and fixt essence, the breath of reason it selfe, slaies an immortality rather than a life."
I don't, incidentally, think that Philip Pullman's books are evil, and if I have money and it gets good reviews, I will probably go see The Golden Compass when it comes out.
I also think that the Church may be just the teeniest bit self-serving here, in that they may not want Catholics to start paying a lot of attention to the things that are and have historically been corrupt within the Catholic Church.
Posts: 910 | Registered: May 2000
| IP: Logged |
posted
Banning a book means making it unavailable for the public to read, presumably by government intervention. No one is suggesting that this be done. No one is saying "Pullman should not be allowed to publish his books and Hollywood should not be allowed to produce this movie."
The Catholic League is encouraging Catholics not read this book or financially support its promotion or that of the movie and especially not to have their children read it. I don't see any strong-arming here; they're saying "let's put our money where our mouth is and boycott this enterprise."
I'm a Christian and I've read the books and I'll probably go see the movie. But I take no issue whatsoever with any organization recommending that I not do so. I totally see their point.
If I had kids, I'd probably handle it as Belle described. But I also had no idea what I was getting into when I first started reading The Golden Compass. If I had children, I think I'd have appreciated at least the head's up about Pullman's agenda, whether I supported the boycott or not.
Posts: 3149 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
quote:Originally posted by Fyfe: I also think that the Church may be just the teeniest bit self-serving here, in that they may not want Catholics to start paying a lot of attention to the things that are and have historically been corrupt within the Catholic Church.
Is it even the Church that we're talking about? Remember, this is the Catholic League, not the Catholic Church. I'm sure the League has some support from them, but if the Church really wanted to boycott the movie and books, wouldn't the Pope do it?
Posts: 3852 | Registered: Feb 2002
| IP: Logged |
quote:Frankly, I think calling for a boycott is a little silly.
Could you please point to where they've called for a boycott? That was a third-hand characterization of the CL statement. If by "calling for a boycott" you simply mean any recommendation not to buy a product, then this is a boycott. That's not how the word is typically used, however.
If that is how you're using the word, then you think that recommending someone not buy a book is a little silly.
quote:John Milton said some really excellent things in Areopagitica about banning books
People keep jumping from talking about recommendations to not read a book to banning books. Why?
Posts: 26071 | Registered: Oct 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
Although Fyfe used the words "banning books" I don't think that the Milton he paraphrased necessarily applies only to the widespread banning of books, since he's clearly recommending that people should read books they don't agree with- and for that reason they shouldn't be banned.
Posts: 8473 | Registered: Apr 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
But the portion of Milton's statement that was actually quoted did use the word "persecution," which suggests something more than what the CL is proposing.
Posts: 26071 | Registered: Oct 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:If he is reasonably convinced that his religion is truth then he'd be completely unjustified in abandoning it.
Sure he is, at least as far as you or I are concerned. Those particular issues are (imo, obviously) exclusively between him and God. It's not for me to say that he's justified or not.
Incidentally, I can easily imagine many situations where turning one's back on God 'holds water'.
I think you misunderstand. I think rollaim is just pointing out that the question of whether the Christian God exists is something that is either true or not, regardless of who is asking the question.
If you're convinced that God exists, it would be pretty unjustified to be an atheist or vice versa.
Perhaps you're thinking about someone that is convinced that God exists but then turns his back on God in terms of the thinking whether God is a good guy. However, whatever that is, it is not quite atheism since an atheist does not believe that there is in fact a God to turn one's back towards in the first place.
quote:Originally posted by Dagonee: Because there's what will most likely be a promising movie coming out about it soon.
Is it promising? Still hoping for an answer from someone that has no pre-existing biases about religion.
Posts: 7593 | Registered: Sep 2006
| IP: Logged |
posted
I meant promising in the interesting or enjoyable sense, not the financial.
Edit to add: Sorry, it was a bit of subtle play with the meaning of words and pretty easy to misunderstand.
Posts: 7593 | Registered: Sep 2006
| IP: Logged |
quote:People keep jumping from talking about recommendations to not read a book to banning books. Why?
Perhaps because previous "recommendations" from the CL turned to outright protests. Remember "The Last Temptation of Christ" and "Priest?"
Why do you keep jumping from the point being made to a perceived technicality about the insigificant difference between a recommendation and a ban?
Posts: 3735 | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
Also, folks please remember that Milton was no paragon for the free press as we know it. He had no problem with books being censored if they promoted ideas he didn't agree with. Were he alive today, I think he would specifically have argued FOR banning His Dark Materials.
Areopagitica shows up in debates all the time, yet people conveniently only quote bits and pieces of it and forget to quote where he is praising people who burn books. It's fine to burn books, says Milton, provided the people who burn them do so after determining on their own that they are not fit. He just didn't want book licensers to tell him what was fit or not - he wanted to determine it on his own. Plus, he wasn't so much against book licensing in principle as he was afraid the people doing it weren't smart enough to do so. In other words, it would be okay to license books, he just didn't want his works judged by stupid people.
I love Milton, but he was such a snob.
Posts: 14428 | Registered: Aug 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
I imagine that the Catholic League's main concern is not people who would be reading the books themselves, it's grandparents who see the trailers for the film, think it looks just like Narnia, which they've heard is a Good Christian Book (TM) and buy the books for their grandkids for Christmas. It's perfectly appropriate, IMO, to inform people who are not already familar with the series that the books are anti- organized religion.
In the same way that some groups made a point of informing people when the Narnia movie came out that the books are Christian allegory.
Posts: 9866 | Registered: Apr 2002
| IP: Logged |
quote:Perhaps because previous "recommendations" from the CL turned to outright protests. Remember "The Last Temptation of Christ" and "Priest?"
Why would protests - that is, the exercise of free speech - justify speaking of a ban?
quote:Why do you keep jumping from the point being made to a perceived technicality about the insigificant difference between a recommendation and a ban?
Because the difference between a recommendation and a ban is neither insignificant nor a "technicality." In fact, I think it's the heart of the issue - at least the part of the issue I give a damn about.
I don't particularly care whether Pullman's books are anti-Christian or whether other people will or should read them. I do care about the tendency of people responding to complaints about the media to leap to cries of censorship and to equate persuasion with compulsion. It's ugly and dishonest.
Posts: 26071 | Registered: Oct 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:I don't want to start anything, but...don't religions do this to other religions all the time?
Sure they do! And do you imagine that most religious cultures, when they become aware of such a challenge to their faith in their area, do nothing to at the least try to reinforce the faith of their congregations?
-----------
quote:Faith shouldn't be so shaky that one film/book can take it apart.
Another common mistake: a boycott does not necessarily equal, "We've gotta stop this! It'll successfully challenge the faith of our people!" ------------------
quote:Perhaps you're thinking about someone that is convinced that God exists but then turns his back on God in terms of the thinking whether God is a good guy. However, whatever that is, it is not quite atheism since an atheist does not believe that there is in fact a God to turn one's back towards in the first place.
Well, sure now that we're defining things in terms of atheist or not. But when I was answering the question, that wasn't the issue.
Posts: 17164 | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged |
quote:Why do you keep jumping from the point being made to a perceived technicality about the insigificant difference between a recommendation and a ban?
Calling this action a ban is making a point, and that point is being addressed.
If the difference is really that insignificant, then we can all stop calling it a ban and move on.
Posts: 16551 | Registered: Feb 2003
| IP: Logged |
quote:Originally posted by dkw: In the same way that some groups made a point of informing people when the Narnia movie came out that the books are Christian allegory.
Was there any similar recommendation (issued, for example, by an atheist network) when Narnia came out? The closest I can find is this, but the internet has a short memory for current events, and two years is nearly an eternity.
Posts: 2926 | Registered: Sep 2005
| IP: Logged |
Perhaps you could elaborate. The way I read it, the discussion was about what constituted valid justification for leaving a religion. You seemed to allude to various counter-examples where one can leave a religion or as you put it "turning one's back on God" and still be justified.
The issue I had with that is that a person that goes through "turning one's back on God" is not really abandoning the religion. I mean, they might be leaving the organised aspects of the religion but they are not *really* abandoning the religion so much as reinterpreting it.
Posts: 7593 | Registered: Sep 2006
| IP: Logged |
posted
Back at the beginning of August, I posted in another forum:
I do have some real reservations about Phillip Pullman's "Golden Compass" (also called "His Dark Materials") trilogy, which I recently read. In interviews, he has expressed antipathy toward C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien, because he is somewhere between being an agnostic and being an atheist, while they based their fiction on Christian values and concepts. This comes out in his books, especially in the last one in the trilogy where he has a poor, pitiable, decrepid, drooling old angel in a protective crystal cage carried around by angels, who is called "the Ancient of Days." God is called "The Authority" that all the good characters oppose and rebel against. Pullman also depicts angels as whisps of ether, weaker than humans who are solid. In all fairness, I should note that some characers in his stories say that the angel who claimed to be the Creator was not really the Creator. Whoever might really be the Creator, if there is one, is left pretty much up in the air.
Just wait until Christian churches tumble onto what Pullman's fantasy is really about--there will be real opposition to it. Especially since it seems to be regarded as fantasy for children (though it is really for adults). If the filmmakers try to market this as a fantasy like "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe," they are going to have a problem when people discover the anti-Christian propagandistic nature of Pullman's fiction.
The really devious thing about the "His Dark Materials" trilogy is that it is viewed as a fairy tale, which are usually assumed to be for children.
I don't believe in book burning, but I do believe in warning parents what this trilogy is really about. I would ban it from elementary school libraries, but allow it in college libraries and perhaps in high school libraries (with restrictions).
I will not pass judgment on the movie version until it is out, and I can see how the anti-Christian elements in the novels have been downplayed or otherwise handled.
As for being a good story, Pullman is a better story-teller than C.S. Lewis, in my opinion, but not quite as good as Tolkien (who after all invented whole new languages and a back history that goes back thousands of years, besides showing mature depth in characterizations). Pullman's stories will (and have) found considerable success because of the narrative quality.
As a fiction writer, I am of the opinion that fiction should tell the truth in the broad sense. Fiction that wrongly portrays (for example) the nature of women and what they really want, as in the John Norman Gor novels, is telling lies about reality in a way that is unacceptable and potentially harmful to the individual and to society. Suspension of disbelief is one thing, but being misled about basic issues of right and wrong, good and evil, is a whole different ball game.
The third novel in the "His Dark Materials" trilogy, The Amber Spyglass, is where Pullman is the boldest and most blatant. Perhaps because by then he was a success, and felt confident he could get away with it. That's where he depicts a being called "The Ancient of Days" as a decripit, drooling, past-senile angel, who has to be protected in a crystal globe. Once the heroes caused the globe to be broken, and exposed the ancient thing to the breeze, his wispyness was shredded and he passed away, saying "Thank you." (This is not a major plot element, so this is not really a spoiler.) The main thing though, is that no one in the trilogy ever says anything good about God. Nor does God ever appear in the trilogy. "The Authority" is viewed as the enemy, and all the angels in the story are said to be fallen angels who rebelled against the Authority. Pullman has a lot of respect for Milton's sympathetic depiction of Lucifer in Paradise Lost, which Pullman even mentions favorably in some interviews.
(Milton may have given a somewhat sympathetic depiction of Lucifer, but there was nothing egregious about it. It was more on the order of Lucifer being an object of pity, and how tragic it was when God had to end His patience and withdraw His offer of mercy and forgiveness. It was like the way God Himself would have written about Lucifer--without hatred or rancor, only sadness and pity, and a disappointed longing for a child whom He loved.)
Posts: 3742 | Registered: Dec 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
I'm honestly confused about what the major problem is, but then I've only read the first book.
If Pullman's description of angels and gods is so markedly different from the Christian one, why is it seen as threatening? Where does this become an anti-Christian thing as opposed to set in a world with different rules/characters?
Posts: 10177 | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged |
quote:I don't believe in book burning, but I do believe in warning parents what this trilogy is really about. I would ban it from elementary school libraries, but allow it in college libraries and perhaps in high school libraries (with restrictions).
I have a feeling this would lead to many more kids reading it than otherwise would have.
Not that I think that's a bad thing.
Posts: 3852 | Registered: Feb 2002
| IP: Logged |
quote:If Pullman's description of angels and gods is so markedly different from the Christian one, why is it seen as threatening? Where does this become an anti-Christian thing as opposed to set in a world with different rules/characters?
I would say it largely depends on the author's intent. If religion in his book is meant to be simply a fictional idea devoid of any commentary aimed at say Christianity, then I don't know why the religious get all up in arms about it. It's not like anyone believes that The Indian in the Cupboard is a metaphor for Native American culture.
But when an author is a very vocal critic of religion, and Christianity specifically, the onus is on the author to help people understand to some extent what he/she hoped to get across by portraying religion as she/he did in the work.
edit: Or in this case the author writing the book and then going on to be very vocal in his criticims of religion causes folks to think he IS providing clarification to those themes in his books. This is not always a reasonable assumption however. Mr. Card for example has been very critical of homosexuality, and yet his books have in a handful of instances, had wonderful, sympathetic to the reader gay characters.
Also I'd like to point out that IMO you can boycott a book, movie, etc without thinking it is a base evil thing. I'm not a big fan of this thread's title.
Posts: 14316 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
I get the authorial intent thing, I guess. But, if you remove this from the authorial context, which is to say, if you didn't know that Pullman was a militant atheist - which I assume would be true for the primary target for the Catholic League announcement - would a person - I don't know what the right way to put this is - (edit: replacement) feel that he was describing Christianity?
Posts: 10177 | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged |
quote:Originally posted by MrSquicky: I get the authorial intent thing, I guess. But, if you remove this from the authorial context, which is to say, if you didn't know that Pullman was a militant atheist - which I assume would be true for the primary target for the Catholic League announcement - would a person - I don't know what the right way to put this is - beliefs be threatened by it?
I think having one's beliefs threatened by a work of fiction in that instance would be ludicrous, as it would often be vague, if not be completely impossible to ascertain what beliefs an author was attempting to state throughout the book.
But I also think it's a mite tacky, (plaintworthy?) to write a book that enters popular culture and be completely silent about what messages you were trying to get across.
Posts: 14316 | Registered: Jul 2005
| IP: Logged |
The cosmology in HDM is very Christian in form. It is easily identifiable as having some connection with Christianity. But the REASON Pullman gives for the cosmology-- God's reasons, and the reasons his Magisterium go about doing what they do-- are so far removed from what most Christians believe, it can seem like an attack.
Posts: 14554 | Registered: Dec 1999
| IP: Logged |
quote:But I also think it's a mite tacky, (plaintworthy?) to write a book that enters popular culture and be completely silent about what messages you were trying to get across.
Well, we're talking about a movie and the Catholic League warning people about things that, if the Catholic League didn't tell them, likely wouldn't be something they'd ever know.
quote:But the REASON Pullman gives for the cosmology-- God's reasons, and the reasons his Magisterium go about doing what they do-- are so far removed from what most Christians believe, it can seem like an attack.
That's the part I don't get. If it is so far removed, how can it be an attack? Is it something that people are going to come to believe is true of Christianity? I mean, in movie form, if these aspects are kept, why would people even connect this with Christianity in a way that is like "This is what Christians believe." or something.
Well, actually, that's one of the parts I don't get. Also, if it isn't a threat, then who the heck cares?
Posts: 10177 | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged |
quote:Why would protests - that is, the exercise of free speech - justify speaking of a ban?
Because those protests cost people their livelihoods. Video stores that rented the films were picketed, threatened, vandalised, and driven out of business. Is this free speech?
The Catholic League's recommendation carries a lot of weight. Librarians will remove books from shelves, which makes them unavailable to people that would like to read them. I was unable to see "The Last Temptation of Christ" for several years after it came out (and then only on video), because theaters that had planned on showing it were bullied out of it. The Catholic League took away my ability to choose to see a movie on my own, because they didn't think it was appropriate. How is that different than a ban?
Posts: 3735 | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
It uses the language and forms of Christianity. So sure, it’s possible to believe that it’s set in a fictional universe where “church,” “cathedral,” “angels,” “pope,” etc. all refer to some evil organization other than Christianity, but no, I don’t think you need to know anything about the author’s views outside the book to “get” the slam. I’d never heard of Phillip Pullman before I read them and it was pretty clear to me. By the end of the series it’s clear that the “world-view” is from a Gnostic/Marcionite perspective, and very hostile toward the institution of a church whose theology mirrors that of Christian orthodoxy. It turns out that the orthodox theology is wrong (actually, lying) about reality and the Marcionite rebels are right, of course.
Posts: 9866 | Registered: Apr 2002
| IP: Logged |