Working on the assumption that this is a speculative fiction story, I've got a few concerns about whether your hook is effective as it could be.

Firstly, the "just woken up" start is normally a very difficult place to enter a story.

Whatever the broad conflict in your story is, my very generic advice is to start the story a bit closer to where the protag's world changes. You can always fill in the backstory of Tom's emotional states through his interactions with others. If he's unusually happy today for some reason, then his nearest and dearest will notice it.

In and of itself, the opening is basically "Tom, normally depressed, is happy today." His depression/elation is probably something cleverer than that, but I can't tell at the moment.

The identification with the protag is well done, but nothing in the hook intrigues me. I can see that it's well written, but I get the feeling that the really interesting bits are later in the story. If so, why not get straight to them?

I'm also not seeing the speculative touch in the opening 13...I don't personally think it's mandatory in short stories, but it's a bonus that can hide other weaknesses in a story.

Regards,

Nick

His feet hit the road with rhythmic accuracy and he took in his surroundings with the eyes of a man willing to live. This didn't really work for me and seemed a bit over-written, especially the "rhythmic accuracy".

He had gained weight during his illness and relished his churning legs This sounded a little strange to me--he had gained weight and so this made him relish his churning legs? I'm not sure how that works, also "churning" conjured a strange image to me of the way this man walks.

Shepherd-mix Storm running at his side I know just a couple of sentences later you say this is a dog, but on the first read I wondered what this was.

Even the light rain and gray skies could not hinder his high spirits by now you have already well established this guy feels a lot happier, I think you could move on by now.

He returned home thirty minutes later color still on his cheeks, POV?

Storm headed straight for her water bowl in the kitchen before happily prancing into the bedroom. Is this important? I would prefer you to be developing your hook by now.

I like the first sentence, I'd just prefer you to move on and tell us what it is that has changed in this guys life before the end of the first page.

Good luck with it

Regarding the wife yes. That's where the story starts because that is what tips his life out of the ordinary. How abou this? This incident is what tips him from depression to happiness. You suddenly have a scene where his reaction to her death subverts our expectations.

Regardless of my suggestions, having him come back to a dead wife raises a question that makes the reader keep reading...how did she die? I think that makes a great hook.

Nick

quote:

---

And if the reader is curious about how she died does that make the story about her more than Tom?

---

It depends on how you playing, but I think not. Finding out how a loved one died is an acute part of the grieving process. He would strive to discover this information. The reader would need to know this for Tom's sake, mostly.

If by speculative you mean I'm trying to get the reader to wonder about something regarding the characters, no but if I'm misunderstanding your question let me know.

By "speculative", Annepin meant whether the story was in the field of science-fiction, horror or fantasy. Given the nature of the board, it's a reasonable question. You might want to give the slush reader a hint that there's a speculative element to the story in the 1st 13; it shows you've targeted the market and helps hook them because they're speculative fiction readers.

By showing us how he reacts to his wife's death, you make the story about your protagonist. I've always thought that one of the best ways to reveal the character of a protagonist to the reader is to show how they react to events. Obviously you don't have to follow my suggestion (and it sounds like it's unsuitable for where you want your story to go), but my scenario shows the reader something unexpected about the protag's character and you don't have to spell it out.

Regards,

I want to thank you for all your help. I've now got three different outlines written and am testing them out to see which one fits best.

And one more rewrite, judiciously cut:

It was a rainy Friday when Tom Richardson returned home to find his wife dead. Unfortunately it was also the day the fog of depression that had enveloped him for the past year had begun to dissipate.

Is the unfortunately too cute or sarcastic? And aren't you supposed to be on your honeymoon?

Last day before the honeymoon :-)

There's nothing wrong with the outline of your story; it could go in a thousand different directions. The trick is to make it fresh and new.

As far as the opening line goes, it's okay. Could you swap the order of the two lines? This way, you start off with something like "It was a rainy Friday when Tom's depression finally lifted after a year of suffering. Unfortunately, he also retuned home to find his wife dead." If you start it off the other way, it's confusing because it's not clear whether his depression lifting is a result of finding his wife dead.

Note also, that it's a very "telling" opening. Nothing wrong with a bit of telling in the right place, but a scene showing him finding his wife and his reactions has the potential to be a lot stronger (depending on where you want the story to focus).

Regards,