OSC at SVU Home Page    |    Hatrack.com    |    Southern Virginia University    

Elizabeth Brady



Pratchett on Popularity


            Terry Pratchett, being an Englishman, had the chance to experience the growing popularity of The Lord of the Rings firsthand in its native country, as well as the reactions of the literature elite to the fact.  In his essay “Cult Classic” he uses his particular wit and charm to illustrate both his own original experiences with The Lord of the Rings trilogy and its effects on others. 

            First Pratchett defines “cult” as “‘inexplicably popular but unworthy.’ It’s a word used by the guardians of the true flame to dismiss anything that is liked by the wrong kind of people.”  Pratchett makes the point that there is such a negative connotation to “cult classic” that it is a wonder that it still applies to The Lord of the Rings.  He makes it clear through a distinction between “favorite” and “best.”   When people in England were asked what their favorite books were and The Lord of the Rings was at the top of the list, and Tolkien was top for favorite author, but Pratchett says that “favorite” is such a personal word that people choose what they like rather than what they think they should like.  He then shows that a poll was taken of the top 50 masterworks, including artwork, and The Lord of the Rings showed up again, right along with the Mona Lisa. 

            Pratchett says that the vote for The Lord of the Rings was probably a vote from the heart, where the Mona Lisa is a “sheer cultural knee-jerk reaction.”  He states that if you ask anyone to name great works of art that the Mona Lisa will be named not particularly from a personal experience with the work, but because that is what we as a culture have been told over and over.  Which is not necessarily a bad thing, it is agreeing with so many people who have seen the art and appreciated it.  He also mentions that not everyone can appreciate art, while most people can read a book.

            Pratchett then goes on to describe his own personal first experience with The Lord of the Rings.  He compares the memory of his first reading of The Lord of the Rings to the memories that people have when they find out about a world-shaking news, for example when JFK was shot, or, for this generation, 9/11.  But his memory of reading the book is combined with his memories of the book itself.  Pratchett says that he remembers walking through the Shire and that the light was “green, coming through trees” as well as a chilly room with a bare, sixties-style couch.  Later in the essay, he says that he used to read The Lord of the Rings every year in the spring, but no longer has to because he can see Middle-Earth in his mind more clearly than most places he has actually physically traveled to. 

            Pratchett tells of his venture to the library after reading The Lord of the Rings looking for more books with the richness he had found, especially the maps and runes.  He came away with Beowulf and a book of Norse myths which led to a full journey into history and mythology that Pratchett said served him better than any history class ever did. 

            Pratchett also says that what is most important to him in The Lord of the Rings is not the characters or the plot, but the landscape.  Seeing the maps and reading the book created a landscape that was, to Pratchett, the hero of the book more than any of the characters. 

“I can still remember the luminous green of the beechwoods, the freezing air of the mountains, the terrifying darkness of the dwarf mines, the greenery on the slopes of Ithilien, west of Mordor, still holding out against the encroaching shadow.”

            Pratchett’s essay makes the reader think about the meaning of “cult” and who is making the judgments about what makes the best literature.  He makes an argument that a book that could create so much magic and impact on so many people does not deserve to be looked down upon. 




Copyright © 2024 Orson Scott Card All Rights Reserved. Web Site Hosted and Designed by WebBoulevard.com