quote: The series is based on the real-life Epidemic Intelligence Service, the elite corps of moon-suited heroes who chase ebola outbreaks, anthrax attacks and other emergencies for the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta, which has been consulting with the show's producers for months.
It is publicity no amount of money could buy for the CDC, an agency historically overshadowed by its richer sister, the National Institutes of Health. Except that in NBC's version, these hotshots are not part of the CDC at all, but rather . . . the NIH.
This story is funny as hell, everyone getting mad.
quote: Anthony S. Fauci, chief of the NIH institute that deals with infectious diseases, expressed surprise Thursday when a reporter told him of the show's theme. When told about one scene in which an NIH sleuth carefully swabs the sewer line in a victim's home in search of clues, he burst into laughter.
"We don't get near that stuff," Fauci said. "We do research. CDC must be going bonkers."
posted
I'm torn. The agencies are soooo mad. And TV is soooo stupid not to just use the right agency. It shouldn't be a big deal to the agencies, but the remedy is so easy I can't help thinking the TV show is being stupid.
The whole situation is amusing to me, making no judgment on who's in the right or wrong.
posted
It's saying the password is incorrect. Maybe only one person can use it at a time or something. But yeah, I can totally see that. It's like not sorting out the CIA and the FBI. Or the City Police and the County Sherriff. Or the German Shepherds and the Labrador Retrievers.
Posts: 11017 | Registered: Apr 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
The strange thing is that I know exactly what the CDC is. The NIH, I would have to think about for a sec to recall what they are.
Posts: 4625 | Registered: Jul 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
I find the emphasis on disease from other countries as violent threats to our way of life to be horrifying and inaccurate. (This isn't a comment on you, Dags, by any means. This is a long-standing but rarely-published controversy from within the infectious disease community.)
For all the underlying message that we must be alert and aware of disease patterns throughout the world, the real threats for Americans are things like basic pneumonias (not SARS), diabetes, heart disease, food-borne illnesses. The real threats for the world are things like cholera, malnutrition, HIV, malaria.
About 1200 deaths internationally have been documented from Ebola since it was identified in 1976. Cholera, although easily treated with simple hydration supportive measures, kills 50% of those infected in areas where there is not access to clean water.
The big bogeyman isn't Ebola or Anthrax. It's the lack of basic human needs such as a clean water supply and sufficient nutrition. But you can't dress that up in fancy spacesuit gear and stick a flashing neon "danger" sign on it -- not sexy enough.
[ September 08, 2004, 10:21 AM: Message edited by: Sara Sasse ]
Posts: 2919 | Registered: Aug 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
CDC = coordinating and interacting agency under the Department of Health and Human Services (part of the Presidential Cabinet, just like the Department of Defense)
NIH = National Institutes of Health, a part of the research arm of the DHHS
Posts: 2919 | Registered: Aug 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
The show will crash and burn - there isn't enough fear about viruses and plagues and whatnot to carry the show.
It's a little tacky the network is trying to ride today's concerns into ratings, but nobody has ever accused a tv network of having good taste.
And tv producers rarely get anything right - I mean c'mon, compare "CSI" to more realistic crime shows like "Forensic Detectives" and so on. Dramatic license in entertainment extends to the absurd.
How many cops or even lawyers for that matter can watch a legal drama without snickering because they can't help but compare it to their own, real-life experiences?
posted
The Amazing Race is quite possibly the best show on network television.
Although the teams are most certainly chosen by Exec's for their camera-bility, we at least have a convincing illusion that there's a real competition.
So, yeah, CBS got ONE thing right.
Posts: 14554 | Registered: Dec 1999
| IP: Logged |
posted
That drama NBC ran about civil engineers was pretty accurate. Ohh wait... that was actually about a mass murder who left clues in his victim's blood for the cop who was on the edge of retirment but had a checkered and mysterious past and a bad marriage.
posted
The only one most lawyers I know can watch is Law and Order, and that's because it makes a minor attempt to look accurate, not because it gets it right. (*mutters about the difference between 5th and 6th amendment right to counsel*)
And CSI has led to acquittals because juries have a terribly misguded idea of what forensics can actually do.
posted
They've been bantering back and forth on CourtTV regarding the popularity of shows like "CSI" influencing the demand of juries for definitive forensic proof regarding crimes.
Which is going to seriously complicate any and all future trials if it's a definite trend.
posted
So this is what Sara really does in her job... I will now picture Sara swabbing down mysterious death scenes while wearing a red minidress, high heels, and pointing out the blindness of those in authority above her. This doesn't match what she's said, but TV says that's how it is, so it must be true. Posts: 26077 | Registered: Mar 2000
| IP: Logged |
posted
There. Sara can now have perfect anonymity. Everyone will be looking for the big-haired, eye-lined, mumu-wearing, Mimi-lookalike swabbing at arm chairs.
Posts: 26077 | Registered: Mar 2000
| IP: Logged |
posted
I totally know the difference between NIH and CDC. NIH is in the Washington Beltway and CDC is in Atlanta.
Yeah, it is sad that no one wants to watch a show about something that they are much more likely to die from. Like obesity or artheroschlerosis. But I guess the point of TV is to escape reality.
Posts: 11017 | Registered: Apr 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
pooka, it isn't that I don't understand the role of television as an escape from reality. That would be silly. It's that I object to further spurring on of irrational fears and the fallout that will continue to ensue.
Posts: 2919 | Registered: Aug 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
I can understand not making a television show based on atherosclerosis or Type II diabetes. That doesn't mean it's a good idea to present fighting the shocking! deadly! outrageous! attacking-my-goodness-at-least-we-have-the-infection-warriors-to-protect-us! looming spectre of the dreaded (kills ~400/yr out of ~6.3 billion) Ebola virus as the zippiest little job on the planet.
Of course, I haven't seen the show. But it's kind of like seeing the words "Morman" and "babies" and "eating" in a partially-hidden headline of the Weekly World News -- it's a pretty sure bet.
Posts: 2919 | Registered: Aug 2004
| IP: Logged |
But "CSI" is as much about the pretty people and the vicarious thrill of watching a crime scene and the perverse curiosity about the drama of the people involved as it is about the science.
However, when people start exploring the field of forensics and realizing exactly what they won't be playing with, the fixation of being a CSI will fade pretty quickly.
It's not unlike the sudden influx of enlistees following "Top Gun".
quote:But "CSI" is as much about the pretty people and the vicarious thrill of watching a crime scene and the perverse curiosity about the drama of the people involved as it is about the science.
Yeah. But the same could be done for this show, and you sure get to show a lot of skin in medical dramas.
quote:However, when people start exploring the field of forensics and realizing exactly what they won't be playing with, the fixation of being a CSI will fade pretty quickly.
It's not unlike the sudden influx of enlistees following "Top Gun"
This cheers my crabby little self.
[ September 08, 2004, 12:44 PM: Message edited by: Sara Sasse ]
Posts: 2919 | Registered: Aug 2004
| IP: Logged |
quote:The scene: a busy Manhattan street. A well-dressed man, suddenly short of breath, looks in horror at his hands and then collapses on the sidewalk. His skin is an eerie blue.
Cut to Bethesda, where a man's cell phone rings. Soon he is sprinting to a nearby field, where a black helicopter swoops in to pick him up.
"We've got an incident!" he barks. "Get everyone. We're going to New York."
Betcha five bucks we see that blue guy's thigh (or some blue guy's thigh) in some examination by the investigators, either pre- or post-mortem.
quote: Later, the "NIH" media officer tries to seduce a reporter to keep him off the story.
Ewww. Smarmy.
[ September 08, 2004, 01:15 PM: Message edited by: Sara Sasse ]
Posts: 2919 | Registered: Aug 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
I saw an episode yesterday where the CSI dudes could have been exposed to Risin (sp?), but the danger was just poo-pooed away.
Posts: 16551 | Registered: Feb 2003
| IP: Logged |
On the other hand, when I dissected my very first preserved brain, my lab partner and I were puzzled by the baby-swiss cheese appearance of the parenchyma, which seemed quite at odds with the labbook pictures. This was back in 1994 when mad-cow issues were still mostly on the horizon. We were told to burn our clothes and shower in the contamination unit.
*grin
Sean and I still occasionally send each other an update on tics, tremors, and personality changes.
Actually, it's only funny in a grim, horrible way, as we were exposed to prions that, if infecting us, would take decades for the symptoms to surface. And there's no telling for sure, other than by brain biopsy.
*shudder
[ September 08, 2004, 01:23 PM: Message edited by: Sara Sasse ]
Posts: 2919 | Registered: Aug 2004
| IP: Logged |
Sadly, these disillusioned people only make it a week before they're pulling their hair out from boredom. Its really cool to feel like you're solving something, but the reality is that it takes a lifetime of research to get anything near "solved" in science and that the work is really very mundane. Its hard to keep track of that greater purpose.
That said, I haven't heard about the show. The only things I watch on tv any more are the Daily Show and Monk and even Monk is beginning to grate on me.
I wonder, was there an influx of people wanting to be in the CIA after 24 made it big? Or have the recent political screw-ups made that impossible. *ducks and runs*
Posts: 1777 | Registered: Jan 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
I'd like to suggest one very simple reason why they are insisting on NIH as opposed to CDC. The National Institutes of Health has the word National in it. CDC doesnt'. If was the ACDC, there'd be no problem with them getting the agency right.
Posts: 10177 | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
Sure, give me a ring. Or, I'll try you if I don't hear from you in a few minutes. Sophie's not sure if she's sleeping or not, but that's okay.
Posts: 1777 | Registered: Jan 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
We discussed this show in our weekly staff meeting this week. I work as a "Disease Investigator" for the State of Hawaii, and we work very closely with CDC. We all thought it was hilarious that the TV dudes would think that our jobs could ever be interesting enough for a television show. Posts: 2069 | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged |
Printer-friendly view of this topic
![[Frown]](frown.gif)
![[Embarrassed]](redface.gif)
![[Grumble]](graemlins/grumble.gif)
![[Smile]](smile.gif)
![[Big Grin]](biggrin.gif)
![[Laugh]](graemlins/laugh.gif)
