posted
Due to a significant weight gain over the past two years related to medication, my doctor is strongly recommending that I go on the South Beach diet. His goal for me is 50 lbs over the next year. If I don't lose at least 25 in that timeframe, however, he's going to take me off this med entirely and prescribe something different. But I like the other side effects of this med so I'd prefer to stay on it if I can.
I've not heard anything about this diet yet beyond hearing that it's similar to Atkins but not as restrictive, and am hoping that someone has some kind of feedback for me. I also have the tie-in book on reserve at the library (57 copies in network and not a single one on shelf anywhere) to see what's the deal.
posted
Goody, Many of my friends have been successful with this diet, and really enjoy it. I have glanced at it, and it looks pretty reasonable. Good luck. Somewhere on here is a weight loss encouragement thread, and there might be something mentioned about the South Beach Diet on there.
posted
My husband is getting ready to start this diet. A friend of his at work went on it and was very successful. The first phase is quite restrictive, but that only lasts two weeks. From what I can tell by looking at Mr. Opera's book the diet itself seems very reasonable and easy to maintain. The emphasis is on veggies and meat and avoiding fruit and breads. Good luck, and I'll let you know how Mr. Opera does.
quote:My husband is getting ready to start this diet. A friend of his at work went on it and was very successful. The first phase is quite restrictive, but that only lasts two weeks. From what I can tell by looking at Mr. Opera's book the diet itself seems very reasonable and easy to maintain. The emphasis is on veggies and meat and avoiding fruit and breads. Good luck, and I'll let you know how Mr. Opera does.
posted
My father has had great luck with this diet. I'm not sure exactly how much weight he's lost, but he's gone from being an undeniably fat man to being pretty thin. I know he's wearing jeans with a 32 inch waist, which is something he's neve been able to do during my lifetime.
I couldn't do this particular diet, though. I'm just too enamored of fruit. I like bread, and I'd miss it, but without fruit...no, it's too bleak to contemplate.
Posts: 16059 | Registered: Aug 2000
| IP: Logged |
quote:I couldn't do this particular diet, though. I'm just too enamored of fruit. I like bread, and I'd miss it, but without fruit...no, it's too bleak to contemplate.
Noemon, from what I've read online so far, certain fruits are allowed. I have to get into more detail once I get my hands on the book, but it sounds like you eliminate grains, potatoes and certain fruits/veggies in stage 1, then start to slowly reintegrate certain items as you progress from there.
posted
My latest sorry attempt is to follow Andrew Weil's 8 weeks to optimum fitness. He breaks it down into small lifestyle changes. The first thing I had to do was throw out anything with hydrogenated oil, and use only olive and safflower oils. I have to eat fish once a week. I'm supposed to walk for five minutes. Do some breathing exercises. Actively think happy thoughts.
I can do those things.
Posts: 10890 | Registered: May 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
My doctor recommended this diet for me too. I'm buying the book today. I'll let you know what I find out!
Posts: 862 | Registered: Oct 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
This diet physically makes me sick. Both my mother and father-in-law are on it and love it, though. They haven't really lost weight, but say they feel more active and healthy.
Elizabeth, I like the sound of your diet. As feeble as it may seem, you just might find that the habits stick.
While I agree with Trevor to some extent, good eating habits and exercise are both good ways to maintain a healthy weight if you really do make the lifestyle change. Be realistic about what you can live with. Few people are able to maintain a 7 day a week workout regime in the long term and few stick with a diet that deprives them of the foods they love.
posted
My father in law did South Beach and it turned out *very* well for him. He's lost something in the neighborhood of 40 pounds and looks great. I've tried it as well, but have found that it doesn't fit my mindset very well - I enjoy good bread, potatoes, pasta too much - whereas actual exercise fits me very well. I just have a salad for lunch, watch what I eat otherwise, and exercise as my hours allow.
Seems to be working.
*blink*
Anyway, if you can do South Beach, go for it. It's a heck of a lot healthier than Atkins.
Posts: 753 | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
Teaching fifth graders is actually really good exercise. There is much more movement than in the self-contained classroom I was in, where we did most things around a table. I am wiped out, physically, at the end of the day, but I feel much better emotionally. I also don't have as much time to sit and eat lunch, and tend to have something healthy on the fly. This makes me want a healthier dinner, and I also feel more like going out and walking in the woods or biking after work than I do hanging around the house.
I have worked with emotionally disturbed kids almost exclusively for nineteen years. I did not realize how much emotional energy I had siphoned out to those kids. Now, teaching 110 students, I am more physical, and get to use my brain more, and save more of my heart for my family. (This does not mean I do not have heart as a fifth grade teacher, just that the kids don't demand as much of it because they are generally less needy.
I can already feel my body reacting to my mood. I just hope it lasts!
Edit: Thanks Christy and Trevor
[ September 07, 2004, 10:38 PM: Message edited by: Elizabeth ]
Posts: 10890 | Registered: May 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
My mom wants our family to eat something closer to this diet, but I'm sorta loath. I have a hard time eating a lot of vegetables. I'm mostly a meat person, and when I was on the Atkins diet, I avoided veggies to an unhealthy extent, to the point where the diet made me sick.
Posts: 4816 | Registered: Apr 2003
| IP: Logged |
Printer-friendly view of this topic
