Hatrack River Writers Workshop   
my profile login | search | faq | forum home

  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» Hatrack River Writers Workshop » Forums » Fragments and Feedback for Short Works » I'm Sorry

   
Author Topic: I'm Sorry
plmorgan
New Member
Member # 2341

 - posted      Profile for plmorgan           Edit/Delete Post 
I'm a newbie here. I have been following along for the last few weeks without comment. I have been impressed with the respect everyone seems to have for each other. These are the first thirteen lines of a short story I am working on and I would appreciate comments on them. Not ready to sendout entire story yet. Thanks in advance for your comments and help.


“Okay, let’s call it. Time of death is 1530. Thanks everybody,” Dr. Killian said. He went to the nurse’s station to write his note, anything to put off the scene that would take place when he went to talk to the family.
It was an impossible task. They would know the outcome as soon as he started with the “I’m sorry…” and then the crying and wailing would start, then the questions. Why did my father, mother, son, daughter die? What else could have been done? Why didn’t you do more? Why didn’t you do it sooner? Did you make a mistake?
And why didn’t you do it better, faster, more successfully? They’ll only be asking questions that you ask yourself. And you never have a good answer either. Except that you and your medicines are impotent against the ravages of time and disease. And did you make a mistake? Not in the code, that’s all protocol, automatic. But what if you had made the diagnosis sooner, started with different antibiotics, operated sooner? What then?


Posts: 5 | Registered: Jan 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
AeroB1033
Member
Member # 1956

 - posted      Profile for AeroB1033   Email AeroB1033         Edit/Delete Post 
“Okay, let’s call it. Time of death is 1530. Thanks everybody,” Dr. Killian said.

I know you're trying to let the reader know that this guy is a doctor, but they should pick that up from the dialogue. I'd suggest using the name of the doctor thinks of himself as instead of "Dr. Killian". Probably his first name, but that's up to you. There are two reasons for this... first of all, you want to establish a consistent tag for the character that you'll use to refer to him throughout the narrative. Secondly, it pulls the reader out of the point of view when the character thinks of himself as something as formal as this. It's like you're watching him from the outside, not inside his head. One other problem with this bit is the "thanks everybody" at the end. It immediately makes me lose sympathy for the doctor, because it strikes me as being a rather casual thing to say right after his patient has died. Maybe you intended it that way, but the following paragraphs don't seem to suggest that at all, so I have to treat this as an honest mistake. Maybe you could just cut that part out and end the line with "time of death is 1530."

He went to the nurse’s station to write his note, anything to put off the scene that would take place when he went to talk to the family.
It was an impossible task. They would know the outcome as soon as he started with the “I’m sorry…” and then the crying and wailing would start, then the questions. Why did my father, mother, son, daughter die? What else could have been done? Why didn’t you do more? Why didn’t you do it sooner? Did you make a mistake?
And why didn’t you do it better, faster, more successfully? They’ll only be asking questions that you ask yourself. And you never have a good answer either. Except that you and your medicines are impotent against the ravages of time and disease. And did you make a mistake? Not in the code, that’s all protocol, automatic. But what if you had made the diagnosis sooner, started with different antibiotics, operated sooner? What then?

Okay, this isn't bad, but I do have some quibbles. For one thing, the reader is certainly wondering who died. He'll expect that this event is important to the story, because you open with it and devote the first paragraphs to it, yet he doesn't know anything about it. Who was the person that passed away? Why was the death significant? Or if it wasn't significant, then why are you beginning the story with it?

As it is, it's just a vague death in a hospital. Certainly we understand what the doctor is feeling after having lost a patient, but it's a cold understanding, because to us it's just another scene where somebody dies on the operating table(?). We need details, something to give us an emotional anchor about the character who died, or why it's so significant to lose a single patient to this doctor.

The way it reads now, the doctor is just wallowing in self pity about something we don't yet care about. We understand how bad he must feel and we don't necessarily blame him for that, but at the same time, we don't really care, either.

Anyway, that's my 2 cents.

[This message has been edited by AeroB1033 (edited February 12, 2005).]


Posts: 233 | Registered: Mar 2004  | Report this post to a Moderator
Warbric
Member
Member # 2178

 - posted      Profile for Warbric   Email Warbric         Edit/Delete Post 
I think starting with dialogue is the difficulty here. If you had Dr. Killian do anything at all that made him more sympathetic and then pick it up with the dialogue, I would like it better. I'll leave the what up to you, as you're more qualified to know what would work.

Maybe the "Thanks everybody." line is realistic, and maybe it could be modified to something that communicated that Dr. Killian appreciated their efforts, that they had given it their best, or some such. I don't know what goes on in operating rooms, having always been under whenever I've been in one myself.

The remainder of the piece is good for me. I feel for the doctor. I would never want that part of his job. Writing a letter to a soldier's parents was rough enough, and Casualty Notification duty was unbearable, but having people look at you as if you had betrayed their every trust in your skills would be Hell for me personally.


Posts: 151 | Registered: Sep 2004  | Report this post to a Moderator
Survivor
Member
Member # 213

 - posted      Profile for Survivor   Email Survivor         Edit/Delete Post 
Killian might not even really know who just died, if this was an emergency operation. He could be going to find that out himself at the nurse's station before talking to the family.

As I see it, you're currently setting Killian up to have a story critical confrontation with the family. The story is going to be about what happens when a doctor walks into the waiting room and says "I'm sorry...." With that purpose in mind, I'll make a couple of comments.

The first is that the story title is a bit...unsuited for the structure of this work. Traditionally, a title that directly addresses the audience this way dispenses with the fourth wall inside the text as well (whether because the author is directly addressing the actual audience or having them play the role of a fictional audience). For example: a fictional "It is with the most profound regrets" or "Dear John" letter might be titled this way.

For this work, you might want to consider rephrasing the title as a noun of some kind, like "Regret" or something like that.

Also, this story clearly starts in the operating room, with the death of a patient. But you haven't described either at all. I can see that you hid details about the patient on purpose, possibly to make it more of an "everyman" situation (though we'll run out of patience real quick if when he talks to the family you keep trying to hide the relationships in order to avoid giving away information about the patient). But neglecting to establish the setting in which the story begins is probably just a mistake. Even if you hide all the details about the patient (not too hard since the patient is a covered body at this point), we want to see the place where the story begins.

This is one reason that I usually don't like stories to begin with a line of dialogue. Before the scene is set, anything said is being spoken into a vacuum (in space, nobody can understand your opening lines, or something like that).

There is also the fact that, because Dr. Killian currently goes right from pronouncing death to dreading his task of informing the family, he seems to be wallowing in self-pity rather than any sorrow that he couldn't save the patient's life. By giving him a moment of reflection in the operating room before he goes to collect the personal information and tell the family, you can forestall some of that by showing that he would feel bad about letting someone die even if nobody was waiting for answers as to why.

As for calling him "Dr. Killian", I'm not a telepath or anything, but certain institutions do encourage people to think of themselves by specific designations. A hospital is one such institution, as is the AMA, or medical school, etc. I don't have a problem with Dr. Killian being his POV designation in this context (though if he went home and was still thinking of himself as "Dr. Killian" with his wife and kids, I'd think he had a kink in his pink or something).


Posts: 8322 | Registered: Aug 1999  | Report this post to a Moderator
wbriggs
Member
Member # 2267

 - posted      Profile for wbriggs   Email wbriggs         Edit/Delete Post 
I don't have much problem with this. It could be improved by having Killian think less abstractly. As in, who died, what did he die of, and who's grieving, and what questions she'll ask, specifically.

>"Thanks everybody," Dr. Killian said. He
Maybe "Thanks, people," would ease the problem others referred to. I didn't have a problem with it.

>It was an impossible task. They would know
Well, no, merely an _unpleasant_ task.

>Why did my father, mother, son, daughter
In this case, the question will be "Why did my father die?" (or whichever it is) since there's only one corpse.

>And you never have a good answer either. >Except that you and your medicines are >impotent against the ravages of time and >disease.
Hey, that's a good answer.


Posts: 2830 | Registered: Dec 2004  | Report this post to a Moderator
plmorgan
New Member
Member # 2341

 - posted      Profile for plmorgan           Edit/Delete Post 
thanks to all. Its enlightening to see how others view your work an the unintended results. All your comments will be helpful as I continue.
Posts: 5 | Registered: Jan 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
NewsBys
Member
Member # 1950

 - posted      Profile for NewsBys   Email NewsBys         Edit/Delete Post 
I agree with Survivor, this is happening in a vacuum. You probably should set-up the scene first.
I'm guessing it is in a hospital, but where within the hospital?
I don’t see any definite clues to that. Is it in a patient room, ER, OR? Maybe this is not even a hospital; maybe it is a nursing home?
Is the team working on someone fresh off an ambulance, or did they suddenly crash?
If they are in a patient room, then chances are that some family members were there, or just outside the room. So he would not be able to put off the chore of telling them. Same probably in the ER. In the OR, or late at night, or if this is a long-term care facility of some sort, I could believe that the family might not be nearby.
FYI - He better not wait too long or the family is going to get really pissed, it has been my experience that they want to know right away, or better yet, they want to be notified as the person is crashing. Most patient families will get angry later simply because they were not told in advance how bad the patient’s condition was. Most complaints I receive after a patient dies are guilt based. They feel guilty because they were not present for the "passing".

I agree with Aero that the patient’s identity is important, even if it will have no other bearing on the story. If a person dies, they deserve to be recognized in other character's minds. It would not be unusual for a doctor to think briefly about the patient’s history and name. He may even think of something like – “He was glad Mrs. Cleaver’s suffering was over. She had been quite a fighter, but in the end the cancer won the war. Now, he wondered how her son would react to her death. He had the feeling he would not take the news quietly. Most of all, he worried about the grandchildren. They seemed to love their Mawmaw, so much.”

I understand the feelings the doctor has. It would be nice if he showed more emotion over the actual death as opposed the chore of informing the family. I'm sure some doctors feel this way after so many deaths of patients. They do get burned out. It does make him a bit less sympathetic though. If however, this is a Character story about how he regains his compassion, then it would work.


Posts: 579 | Registered: Mar 2004  | Report this post to a Moderator
   

   Close Topic   Feature Topic   Move Topic   Delete Topic next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:


Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2