posted
This is from a flash challenge. Total about 860 words. I know the end is weak. Can you comment on how to make it stronger?
Email me if you want to see the whole thing.
Thanks
mm
quote:“OK sport, need a ride?”
The kid looks closely at me before getting in. He’s wary. He should be.
“Yessir”
I slam it into 1st and we’re off to the races. Well, kinda. My old ’34 won’t ever make it into any races ever again. Huh! We’re lucky it goes at all.
“Sir?”
This kid is all serious.
“Yeah, kid?”
Now we’re hitting 20. Time to shift.
“What’s in that?” He points at the manila folder on the seat.
“Just pictures, is all.” Geesh. I shoulda hid them before I stopped.
We’re in 3rd now and the old boat-tail settles down like she should. Soon we’ll start to float a little and I’ll push her into 4th. That’ll have to be all, there’s no road short of heaven that’ll hold her in 5th.
“Can I see them?” he asks.
“Hell no! Leave them alone.” I shouldn’t have yelled at him. Now he’s looking scared.
On the whole, I think you did great. The premise you're setting up left me wanting to climb into the story.
That being said, I think there are a few tweaks you could make that would pull me in even better.
Starting with dialogue is always tricky, but I think it can work for you here. You're first line strikes me as an odd thing to say to a hitchhiker, though. When I first read it I thought the character was being familiar with someone. After I finally got the context though, I thought it was sarcastic. That may be fine for where you're going, but it might work better something like: >"C'mon, Sport. You need a ride or what?"< That would support your second line well, especially with a tweak like: >The kid stares at me a little longer before...<
The line: We're lucky it goes at all, hitched me a up a little. If you mean him and the kid, you're probably better just saying: I'm lucky it... If you're talking about someone not yet introduced, it needs a bit more clarity.
You're use of the vehicle is interesting and full of potential, but you lose me toward the end with it. We used to call great big cars boats, and I thought that's what you meant with "the old boat-tail." Why it floats when it needs to go into fourth was confusing. I would've loved what you said about 5th, if it didn't negate "We're lucky it goes at all." If you're going somewhere odd with that statement, it might need to be handled a little differently.
All in all I really like this. Send it over, I'd love to give it a read.
Joe, good points. I look forward to seeing more from you.
Most of your issues are made more clear when you read the complete piece, although most of the clarification is inferred.
For example, you later learn the car is about 25 years old, so it is indeed lucky that it goes.
As far as floating, have you ever driven on dirt roads at a speed at which you feel the car start to float a bit? That is, to skip over the lows and ride the highs of the washboards? Later on it becomes apparent that he is driving dirt roads.
In the 30s there were some sport cars that were boat-tailed.
The comment on "passing 20" confused me. 20 mile marker? 20 mph? Either way it hardly seems noteworthy enough to mention. You might just say the clunker is getting up to speed, and drop the detail about the gear shifts, which someone who drives stick hardly notices anyway. It's the kid and the pictures that are of interest.
posted
I keep coming back to this, wondering if I should comment. The present tense makes it feel experimental, and the narrator's choppy voice on top of the first person narration adds to the effect.
I keep on thinking I'm missing things. I didn't think the kid was a hitchhiker. The relationship seemed too familiar to me for that, but I could be wrong. I think my main concern is that I have no idea who the "I" is. I assume he's male, and strange character. I feel like I'm trying to piece it together, and that takes away from the action.
It's interesting, and I want to read on, but your admission that the ending needs work makes me wary.
posted
True about the OK bit pointed out. In Scrabble, "Okay" is an acceptable word, while "OK" is not. [Interestingly, to me at least, "KO" is acceptable; if memory serves it's a digging stick of sorts.]
Anyway, I think I meant to point that out in my critique, Mike... but forgot to do so. Glad Hoptoad caught that.
posted
Now why would you do more to that guy's reputation? That's pretty cool. I mean he does the best with his instrument. I'm sure if his parents got him guitar lessons instead of flute lessons, he'd be more popular
Posts: 341 | Registered: Jun 2004
|
posted
So how did MY car get into your story? Mike, I knew exactly what you were saying all the way through and loved the way you said it. You excel at genuine POV. Rip on, tiger! Judith
Posts: 142 | Registered: Jan 2005
|
posted
Mike, you didn't know who Kenny G. is in real life? Ah, I thought you did. I thought you despised him and that's why you went with that name... (I don't want to spoil your story, so I'll stop here.)
Posts: 1520 | Registered: Jun 2004
|
What's kinda funny though is that my last choral instructor in high school knew Kenny G's brother (his real last name is some Italian name that starts with a G, but is hard to say, thus the G part), who is some kind of music teacher here in NC.
posted
Since a live musician is not the way to go, how about if I use a dead one's name? I could go here http://elvispelvis.com/causesofdeath.htm , and find the names of dead musicians and learn something about them.
They're helpfully categorized by how they died:
drowning stabbing inhaled their own vomit car crash aids friendly fire brawling shooting poison golfing electrocuted airplane crash mysterious circumstances heroin farming suicide motorcycle accident eating or not eating etc
Which exit stratgegy do you think best fits my story's ghostly character?
posted
Mike? Put down that open bottle of white-out right now! You're worrying me. Hey. That's it. Death by white-out!
Posts: 142 | Registered: Jan 2005
|
Since you're a white-out user also, can you tell me what I'm doing wrong here? I put the white-out on the screen really carefully and make sure not to get it on the words I want to keep, but then when I type some more it moves!!
posted
Mike, I read through the words and had a couple of comments...
first, things I liked:
1. The line about the kid looking in scared and he should be. That's good, sets the tone of the character and the scene. As the reader you are the kid and feel that tension throughout the scene.
2. I get a little lost on what's going on in some of the mechanics of the scene. Can you convey more information than just old 34...seems like there would be a better/cooler way to talk about a vehicle with that much history/character.
posted
Ok, I've read about 100 posts now and have gotten a better feel for what this particular forum is all about. (sorry to anyone who was a little peturbed with my original posts, which in retrospect were a little off-topic). That said, I've critiqued two pieces posted in this section and would now like critiques for a 13 line piece I wrote, let me know what you think...this is the opening passage: -------------------------------------------- Rome, Italy 1945 In the middle of the bridge, at the highest point of its ascent over the murky waters of the Tiber River, one street lamp threw light in all directions. The light darted upwards to the towering support cables and downwards to the fast flowing river beneath. As the light scattered shadows just below the dark underbelly of the bridge, it exposed a black figure, swinging from the end of a rope. A corpse, long dead, had been hanging for hours. It swung peacefully. The leisurely movement and tiny creaking sounds of the rope stood in stark contrast to the screaming countenance frozen on the victim’s face. The only light reaching the victim reflected from a set of cold, lifeless eyes, decorated underneath by a small scar. -----------------------------------------
Posts: 40 | Registered: Feb 2005
|
posted
Okay, Mikemunsil I am wondering about this story. There is clearly some supernatural thing going on but Higgot doesn’t bat an eyelid, I want to know why. This Jnr Dt. Is more interested in the car he’s driving than anything else in the story. I like the tone, Dragnet-ish, but I have no-idea what a boat-tail-cop-car is and when you ‘float’ in 3rd and pull-up at the bridge I was wondering what the heck was going on.
I get the feeling Sloane may be our man.
So to sum up: maybe let us know Higgot’s reaction to some of the weirdness around him, he is a bit flat/2 dimensional right now. And the staging in the car was a bit hard to follow.
Hope this helps.
BTW I like your name too, how'd you come up with something so -- kooky.
[This message has been edited by hoptoad (edited February 24, 2005).]
posted
Thanks, Hoptoad, I appreciate the comments.
No, you guys got the same one to look at. My take on the differing perspectives is that the writing, characterization and plot are not tight enough to avoid confusing the readers. Also, as I was participating in a flash challenge when I wrote this, and because my 'style' seems to have gravitated to the sparse, I believe that the lack of 'flesh' in the story is also a problem.
My ideas were as follow:
'Kenny G' was murdered by Sloan in the boat-tail cop car over 20 years ago while it was parked on the bridge where Higgot let Kenny G. out. Sloan is a psycopath, is arrogant, and likes to dangle hints about his kills in front of the other cops, sure that they will never catch up with him. Higgot has a bit of a past history with Sloan, who, although he could not deny Higgot's advancement within the force, was able to assign Higgot his old cop car rather than give him a new one. That was a mistake. The presence of a sympathetic cop in the same car, taking the same route as the night that Kenny G. was murdered has 'activated'Kenny G.'s ghost, who pleads with Higgot to expose his murder and give Kenny G. final rest. Kenny G. is not a whole personality, however, nor is he fully conscious in the 'normal' sense, so he cannot address the issue the way one of the 'live' would. He is essentially reliving the event, and to the extent that something changes from the past event he is able to react to the change. That is why he asks the things he does in the car while riding and why he mouths 'Thank you." as Higgot drives off. More than that, he cannot do. Finally, although I will never make it overly clear, I will try to indicate in a subtle way (if I can) that the car is not just a passive hunk of machinery. This last is very self-serving, as I would like to write a series of Higgot stories, and the car would take a more central role as the stories move through Higgot's career.
Anyway, that was my intent. Hard to create on the spot and to write as much as I did within the time frame of a flash challenge (1 hour), but at least I tried.