Hatrack River Writers Workshop   
my profile login | search | faq | forum home

  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» Hatrack River Writers Workshop » Forums » Fragments and Feedback for Short Works » My First Story: REVISED

   
Author Topic: My First Story: REVISED
Wenderella
Member
Member # 2464

 - posted      Profile for Wenderella   Email Wenderella         Edit/Delete Post 
I tried to write this version with more description and feeling:


"Leah lay quietly on her straw mattress, fingering a silver medallion hanging around her neck. The raven-haired beauty was deep in thought about her crystal-blue eyed love living far away in his elven land. His promises to her have kept her warm at night, and her hope to see him again, has kept her breathing. Her delicate fingers danced over the luminous amethyst, when she heard a woman's blood curdling scream followed by a ground shaking growl. She rushed to the window, and through the twisting branches of her family's oak tree, she saw a large towering beast, he raised a great axe and sliced the head off of her neighbor. It threw aside the neighbor's body with a tremendous force and then reached down and grabbed the screaming woman that was hiding behind the neighbor. The woman shrieked and pleaded for her life as the beast began to drag her away. Leah grabbed the window sill and dug her finger nails into the wood. She strained to see who the woman was, when she finally realized, it was her mother."

[This message has been edited by Wenderella (edited March 30, 2005).]


Posts: 43 | Registered: Mar 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
HSO
Member
Member # 2056

 - posted      Profile for HSO   Email HSO         Edit/Delete Post 
Wenderella, I know you are new, so I'll be gentle.

Ease off a bit on the adjectives. Some are good, but too many detract from what's happening.

Neverthless, let's look at the first few sentences and dissect them thoroughly.

quote:
Leah lay quietly on her straw mattress, fingering a silver medallion hanging around her neck. The raven-haired beauty was deep in thought about her crystal-blue eyed love living far away in his elven land

First thing: Never use the word "fingering" in fiction. Trust me, it's not the word you want to use. I am reluctant to expand further on that, but just take my word for it. There are hundreds of words that will work better and not... (nope, not going there... stop that, HSO)

Next, the medallion may indeed be hanging around her neck, but do you think of medallions that way? Probably not. Chances are, you see it as: "wore a medallion." So, why not use that instead? Hanging and neck are typically reserved for the gallows -- people about to hung by the neck for whatever they did to upset someone.

Second sentence: Does Leah think of herself as a "raven-haired" beauty? I ask because, whether you realize it or not, you're writing this scene in her POV. Do you think of yourself by your hair color when you're lying around dreaming of boys? I would think you don't -- but I can't be sure; I never know what any woman really thinks. Still, my belabored point is don't tell us what Leah looks like. Just tell us what she sees and feels and thinks. Anything that is outside of this, typically personal description (except when relevant, say like: weight) should be excluded from the narrative.

Interestingly, that second sentence packs a lot of information in one hit. The trouble is that it is too much information for one sentence. Consider using at least two to bring these details out. But, doesn't her "crystal blue-eyed elf" have a name? Wouldn't she think of his name? I would, if I were dreaming of a woman I loved. I'd be thinking about her name a lot, and, of course, what she looks like. But I'd always have her name on the brain. Always.

Bear with me, I'm going to rewrite these two sentences (and make an assumption or two) to illustrate my points:

** As she lay quietly on her straw mattress, Leah gazed at the medallion she wore around her neck. Luke had given it to her, and touching the medallion now made her feel closer to her elven love so far away. She missed looking into his eyes: crystal-blue, like jelly-roll, like sculpture (sorry, I was just listening to the Pixies while writing that bit, but you get the point. Forgive my silliness, please.). She missed him.
***

Now, I made this longer on purpose... not to show that my way is better, but to show you to take a little time to setup the information. There's time. Not a lot, but don't cram it all in at once. Also, note how I make 'Luke's' eye color relevant. Because Leah is thinking about them right then; she misses his eyes -- the way he looks at her when he's feeling happy, sad, amorous. Whatever. Make the descriptions relevant for the moment.

Does this make sense?


[This message has been edited by HSO (edited March 30, 2005).]


Posts: 1520 | Registered: Jun 2004  | Report this post to a Moderator
Jaina
Member
Member # 2387

 - posted      Profile for Jaina   Email Jaina         Edit/Delete Post 
Not having read the other post, and not having read your first version, here's my thoughts:
quote:
The raven-haired beauty was deep in thought about her crystal-blue eyed love

Yuck. Sounds dangerously close to a Mary Sue, if you ask me. If she has purple eyes, I'm outta here. Seriously, though, I'm reading this and thinking that she's going to be way too perfect for her own good. The kind of girl who's full of herself and cries when she breaks a nail, yet is willing to go into battle with the men of the community. Look out for her. She's too good be true. And her dreamy elf love is probably just as perfect...

In other words, I don't trust your character at all after this. I'm afraid that she's going to be so perfect and self-centered that she's going to make me sick.

After that, you get better, although you need to watch out for the adjectives (I'm thinking specifically the "blood curdling scream followed by a ground shaking growl" because both of those -ings are cliché and they're close enough together within the text that they're distracting).

I am curious to see what happens to her mother, and what it was that took her mother, but I don't think I would read past this point because I'm too afraid of your main character becoming annoying.


Posts: 437 | Registered: Feb 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
Crotalus
Member
Member # 2345

 - posted      Profile for Crotalus   Email Crotalus         Edit/Delete Post 
I'll use < > to enclose words I would delete and ( ) for other comments.

Leah lay <quietly> on her straw mattress, fingering a silver medallion hanging around her neck. The raven-haired beauty was deep in thought about her crystal-blue eyed love <living> far away in his elven land. His promises to her have kept her warm at night, and her hope to see him again<,> has kept her breathing. Her delicate fingers danced over the luminous amethyst, when she heard a woman's <blood curdling> (CLICHE, either describe the scream another way or just delete those two words) scream followed by a ground shaking growl. She rushed to the window, and through the twisting branches of her family's oak tree, <she> saw a <large> towering (redundant-scratch one of these adjectives. I suggest 'large' since it's the more bland of the two) beast,(comma splice) he raised a(n) <great> axe and sliced the head off of her neighbor<.>, <It> threw aside the <neighbor's> body with a tremendous force and then reached down and grabbed the screaming woman <that was> hiding behind the neighbor. The woman shrieked and pleaded for her life as the beast began to drag her away. Leah grabbed the window sill and dug her finger nails into the wood. She strained to see who the woman was, when she finally realized, it was her mother."

other critiques: show up front that there are two women threatened by the beast. It was kind of jarring to see the beast slay the woman and then go after another woman that we didn't even know was in the scene until he decided to go after her.

Cut some of the adjectives, and when you do use an adjective make it count, don't necessarily go for the first descriptive word that comes to mind.

Too many instances of 'was'.

hope this helps

[This message has been edited by Crotalus (edited March 30, 2005).]


Posts: 46 | Registered: Jan 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
wbriggs
Member
Member # 2267

 - posted      Profile for wbriggs   Email wbriggs         Edit/Delete Post 
What's a "Mary Sue"?
--
I think this is much improved, and I'm beginning to feel hooked by it. Here are some comments. [] around things you might cut, and ** or ALL CAPS for additions or comments.

Just some nit-picks.
--
Leah lay quietly on her straw mattress, fingering a silver medallion hanging around her neck. The raven-haired beauty was deep in thought about her crystal-blue eyed love [living] far away in his elven land. His promises to her have kept her warm at night, and her hope to see him again, has kept her breathing. Her delicate fingers danced over the luminous amethyst, when she heard a woman's blood*-*curdling scream followed by a ground*-*shaking growl. [PARAGRAPH]

She rushed to the window, and through the twisting branches of AN [her family's] oak [tree], she saw a [large] towering beast, he raised a great axe and sliced the head off of her neighbor. [THAT LAST SENTENCE IS A COMMA SPLICE; SEE THE THREAD IN OPEN DISCUSSIONS ON WRITING. ALSO, HOW DOES SHE KNOW IT'S A "HE"?] It [IT, OR HE?] threw aside the neighbor's body with a tremendous force and then reached down and grabbed A [the] screaming woman that was hiding behind the neighbor. The woman shrieked and pleaded for her life [KEEP US IN THE MOMENT: IF SHE'S GOING TO PLEAD, LET US HEAR HER WORDS] as the beast [began to drag] DRAGGED her away. [PARAGRAPH]
Leah grabbed the window sill and dug her finger[ ]nails into the wood. She strained to see who the woman was*.*[, when] she finally realized[,] it was her mother."


Posts: 2830 | Registered: Dec 2004  | Report this post to a Moderator
Wenderella
Member
Member # 2464

 - posted      Profile for Wenderella   Email Wenderella         Edit/Delete Post 
"Yuck. Sounds dangerously close to a Mary Sue, if you ask me. If she has purple eyes, I'm outta here. Seriously, though, I'm reading this and thinking that she's going to be way too perfect for her own good. The kind of girl who's full of herself and cries when she breaks a nail, yet is willing to go into battle with the men of the community. Look out for her. She's too good be true. And her dreamy elf love is probably just as perfect..."

First of all, this is actually a nightmare she is having about that night. She is getting close to giving birth to a half-orc which was conceived that night she is dreaming about.

In the coming paragraphs the nightmare is actually what sends her into labor.

Secondly, I was trying to build-up her innocence because the beast ends up doing something to her in the coming paragraphs that will forever change her life. I was just trying to show that she is lost in her own world until this event occured.


Thank you everyone for your comments. And yes HSO, I think I understand what you are saying.

[This message has been edited by Wenderella (edited March 30, 2005).]

[This message has been edited by Wenderella (edited March 30, 2005).]


Posts: 43 | Registered: Mar 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
Jaina
Member
Member # 2387

 - posted      Profile for Jaina   Email Jaina         Edit/Delete Post 
Okay. I think what turned me off was the raven-haired beauty and the crystal-blue eyes. The wording is pretty cliché, there. Perhaps I was a bit cruel about it. And it makes sense that you were trying to make her seem innocent. Sorry if I sounded harsh--I think I went a bit overboard there.

wbriggs: I don't know if they use this term in real fiction so often as they use it in fanfiction... I should have thought of that before I wrote it, but I thought I'd seen it on this board a couple of times. Basically, a Mary Sue is an angelically beautiful girl with either jet black or platinum blonde hair and radiant blue (or in the worst cases, violet) eyes. She's the kind of character that's so perfect she makes you want to gag. Leah isn't a Sue yet, but I saw a lot of Sue potential in this paragraph, and I tried to head it off as soon as I could.

But now, since I know that Wenderella is trying to contrast her innocence here with what the beast does to her, it works better for me.

I owe you an apology, Wenderella. I shouldn't have torn you to shreds like that without understanding what you were doing. I'm sorry!


Posts: 437 | Registered: Feb 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
mikemunsil
Member
Member # 2109

 - posted      Profile for mikemunsil   Email mikemunsil         Edit/Delete Post 
We've previously had discussions regarding over-use of adjectives. You're not the only writer confronting that issue. Here is a link to one of our previous discussions: http://www.hatrack.com/forums/writers/forum/Forum11/HTML/000595.html , other Hatrackers might be able to refer you to some other posts as well.
Posts: 2710 | Registered: Jul 2004  | Report this post to a Moderator
Kolona
Member
Member # 1438

 - posted      Profile for Kolona   Email Kolona         Edit/Delete Post 
Definitely not a synopsis anymore, so good job. Still some work needed in keeping to POV, and in using only the words you need, but this is an improvement over the first version.
Posts: 1810 | Registered: Jun 2002  | Report this post to a Moderator
Wenderella
Member
Member # 2464

 - posted      Profile for Wenderella   Email Wenderella         Edit/Delete Post 
Thank you all for your input! I'm working on it again. Hope to post again soon.

Jaina: Thats okay!

[This message has been edited by Wenderella (edited March 31, 2005).]


Posts: 43 | Registered: Mar 2005  | Report this post to a Moderator
   

   Close Topic   Feature Topic   Move Topic   Delete Topic next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:


Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2