Hatrack River Writers Workshop   
my profile login | search | faq | forum home

  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» Hatrack River Writers Workshop » Forums » Fragments and Feedback for Short Works » Untitled story/fantasy/800 words

   
Author Topic: Untitled story/fantasy/800 words
Leigh
Member
Member # 2901

 - posted      Profile for Leigh   Email Leigh         Edit/Delete Post 
I haven't posted anything in this section for a while now. I guess I've been afraid to do so. Well, now I have something I would like critiqued. Just the first 13, if anyone else would like to read the rest I've done I'll email it to you as it's only around 800 words

Here it is:

Hans crept quietly up the game trail, hearing the soft patter of rain hitting the jutted rocks to his right. He was hugging those same rocks to mask his approach. His fellow hunter, Eric, Huntmaster to the Duke of Dralonias, was silently making his way through the large trees to his left. Hans had heard the loud echo of a cave lion, soon to be dead at his hands if it was found. The shy and elusive creature was a trademark hunted creature amongst the Dralonias Mountains where several species of large game animals existed. There was a year round food supply for the large creatures that inhabited the mountains, the food being large elk that never leave the confines of the mountains due to the winter snow melting and creating several large rivers, creeks and lakes nestled amongst the game trails.

----------
Note: Please don't hold back on the criticism, I actually work better under harshness


Posts: 384 | Registered: Oct 2005  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
oliverhouse
Member
Member # 3432

 - posted      Profile for oliverhouse   Email oliverhouse         Edit/Delete Post 
Hi, Leigh,

You're the victim of my procrastination. I should be doing something else, but this is more interesting. As usual, my caustic commentary is given in a constructive spirit...

You've got a fair amount of passive voice in here. I'll point it out as I go along. (I don't know you, so I'll overexplain at the risk of insulting your intelligence: Passive voice is the use of forms of "to be", usually "He was" "She was" and "They were", in third person limited.)

Richard Lanham's _Revising Prose_ and his so-called "paramedic method" helped me revise my prose (go figure) to avoid the passive voice. The relevant bit is excerpted here, under a section called "Who's Kicking Who?"

http://benninghoff.emich.edu/328/Lanham_on_Revision.html

(And yes, he knows it should be "Whom"... )

quote:
Hans crept quietly up the game trail, hearing the soft patter of rain hitting the jutted rocks to his right.

Rain tends to make noise on foliage, especially dead foliage, than on rocks. If there's a soft patter, I'd expect it to be on leaves, and the leaves to mask what's on the rocks.

I like the phrase "jutted rocks". Not one I would have thought of, but I think it works.

quote:
He was hugging those same rocks to mask his approach.

Passive voice: "was hugging". All else being equal, favor the active voice. For example, either "He hugged the rocks to mask his approach" or "he masked his approach by hugging the rocks".

I don't love "those same rocks". You've only mentioned one set of rocks, so we'll assume those are the ones you mean.

quote:
His fellow hunter, Eric, Huntmaster to the Duke of Dralonias, was silently making his way through the large trees to his left.

I don't love "his fellow hunter". It seems redundant, since you call Eric the Duke's Huntmaster, and you have the hunter / Huntmaster combination over the course of three words. I'm not sure I have advice to give you on that, but I'd consider playing with it.

quote:
Hans had heard the loud echo of a cave lion, soon to be dead at his hands if it was found.

This short bit of explanation uses "had heard" (i.e., it's a mini-flashback) and then jumps to the future ("soon to be dead"), but maybe not ("if"). I think it's more confusing than it needs to be.

(It also should use the subjunctive mood, since the future isn't certain: when using "I wish" or "if" you generally would say "if it were found" or "I wish it were found" -- I don't know why. That sounds a little funny because of the different tenses you're dealing with, but technically "if it was found" is grammatically incorrect.)

Maybe you take a slightly different tack. I'm trying not to simply rewrite the paragraph, but I'm thinking a structure like this: Hans and Eric had heard the sound of the lion.* Hans hugged the rocks on the right to cover the sound of his pursuit; Eric, Huntmaster, silently moved through the trees on the left.

* [Since that happened first, the past is in the past by the time you get to the "now", which is standard past tense.]

quote:
The shy and elusive creature was a trademark hunted creature amongst the Dralonias Mountains where several species of large game animals existed.

Passive voice again. Twice, if you count "existed", which is really just another way of saying "was".

I think that "shy" and "elusive", while not precisely redundant, are too similar. You're weakening your description with more words rather than enriching it. Pick your favorite and kill the other.

I'm not sure what a "trademark hunted creature" is. I have some guesses, but none of them are obviously true.

I think there should be a comma after "Mountains".

Do you say "where several species of large game animals existed" to point out that the cave lion could get food easily? If so, then it's a little clunky, and you might leave that bit to the next sentence. If not, I'm not sure why you do.

quote:
There was a year round food supply for the large creatures

Passive voice.

You used "creature" and "creatures" pretty close together, which caught my ear. Maybe consider different word choices here: "quarry" instead of "hunted creature", for example.

quote:
that inhabited the mountains, the food being large elk that never leave the confines of the mountains due to the winter snow melting and creating several large rivers, creeks and lakes nestled amongst the game trails.

A few problems here.

I think you're trying to pack too much into one sentence (clause, really, I guess). I'd break this up.

I also think that "the food being" (note: passive voice again) is clunky and should be incorporated into the previous clause, something like: "Large elk provided food year-round for the large creatures of the mountains. They never left the confines..."

Technically speaking, "due to" means something owed (as in, "The $200 fee is due to this office by May 20th"). It often gets used in the way you have here, but I try to avoid it because it makes some nitnoid people go buggy -- and because it's my job, I now get a little buggy, too. Your call, of course, if you want to ignore the buggy people. I usually substitute some form of "because" or "resulting from" if it's necessary, but often you can reword the sentence altogether to get a better result. In this case, for instance, you could say, "They had no need to leave the confines of the mountains because..."

Assuming I'm guessing your intent correctly, you might condense even more. I have a version of the paragraph that's 28 words, down from 47. I won't poison the well with it, but if you're interested I'll pass it on. While conciseness isn't everything -- far from it -- I'd say that for a fast- paced hunting scene, with the smell of blood in the air, so to speak, that's one objective to shoot for.

Speaking of concise, I haven't been. Time to shut up.

Regards,
Oliver


Posts: 671 | Registered: May 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
tchernabyelo
Member
Member # 2651

 - posted      Profile for tchernabyelo   Email tchernabyelo         Edit/Delete Post 
If this is an 800-word story, I am really not sure you should spend some of those words on giving us an ecology lecture. The entire sections from "They shy and elusive creature..." onwards is exposition that, so far as I can tell, we don't really need. You appear to be trying to justify the existence of the cave lion, the terrain, and so forth... but since there doesn't seem to be anything particularly out of the ordinary about these things, I just found it unnecessary. The story (presumably) is about Hans and Eric, not about whether elk never leave the mountains throughout the year.
Posts: 1469 | Registered: Jun 2005  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Novice
Member
Member # 3379

 - posted      Profile for Novice           Edit/Delete Post 
Oliver and tchernabyelo have provided good comments here, and I can't add much. I completely agree with Oliver concerning the passive voice.

And I agree with tchernabyelo, in that there's a bit too much description in the last part. However, given that your characters appear to be career hunters, their POV would necessarily include some knowledge of terrain, and the habits of their prey. The problem here is that you have, in a sense, dumped their combined experience into a few complicated sentences.

On the whole, your scene lacks tension. Mostly because your characters lack tension. Everything feels detached, which is exacerbated by your use of passive voice and blunt description. Your concept has great potential...I mean, really...hunting cave lions? That's a good tale just waiting to be read.


Posts: 247 | Registered: Apr 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Leigh
Member
Member # 2901

 - posted      Profile for Leigh   Email Leigh         Edit/Delete Post 
I see where I've gone wrong. Well I did say don't hold back on the criticism, lol. Well, it's only a first draft at the moment, so I can always rewrite the entire thing. I haven't written more since then anyway.
Posts: 384 | Registered: Oct 2005  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
wbriggs
Member
Member # 2267

 - posted      Profile for wbriggs   Email wbriggs         Edit/Delete Post 
My suggestions:

* Tell us in line 1 they're hunting cave lions
* Tell us why we care. Are the cave lions hunting them right back? Will the king kill them if they don't come back with a mane? Something to make us care about the struggle.

It's sort of like putting a ball game in a story. You can do it, but nobody will care about the plays. They'll care about the relationships of those playing it, the grudge in the grudge match, etc.


Posts: 2830 | Registered: Dec 2004  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
oliverhouse
Member
Member # 3432

 - posted      Profile for oliverhouse   Email oliverhouse         Edit/Delete Post 
> I see where I've gone wrong. Well I did say don't hold back on
> the criticism, lol. Well, it's only a first draft at the moment,
> so I can always rewrite the entire thing. I haven't written more
> since then anyway.

Don't feel bad. I wouldn't waste my time critiquing something that wasn't fixable. The basic premise is interesting -- it's lion hunting, for Pete's sake! -- so fix the writing and try again.

Regards,
Oliver


Posts: 671 | Registered: May 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Sara Genge
Member
Member # 3468

 - posted      Profile for Sara Genge   Email Sara Genge         Edit/Delete Post 
I'm willing to read the rest. I want to know how it ends.

Posts: 507 | Registered: Jun 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
   

   Close Topic   Feature Topic   Move Topic   Delete Topic next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:


Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2