Hatrack River Writers Workshop   
my profile login | search | faq | forum home

  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» Hatrack River Writers Workshop » Forums » Open Discussions About Writing » Hold back nothing. Be Vicious, cruel and unmerciful. (but only if you have to)

   
Author Topic: Hold back nothing. Be Vicious, cruel and unmerciful. (but only if you have to)
Gorditio
Member
Member # 1451

 - posted      Profile for Gorditio   Email Gorditio         Edit/Delete Post 
Just something I've been throwing around to keep myself busy in the idle summer hours between semesters. I know there are plenty of mistakes hiding in there, but since it's my own work I'm having trouble finding them. If anyone could find the time to have at it and post some responses it would be much appreciated.
_____________

Kennedy Roberts had always enjoyed watching the sun rise, it was one of a dwindling few daily rituals he still allowed for himself at the age of 59. Not that it even bore a remote resemblance to his old vices, but so much of his past had been swept away in recent years that it felt good to cling to something old. He could still remember vividly his childhood on the Aisysian Coast, watching as the gold and crimson rays became entangled upon each wavecrest whereupon they danced and sparkled betwixt air and water until the wave dashed against the pearly white cliffs with such thunderous force that it burst up into the air to create a million tiny suns, each a beautiful mimicry of the aureate ball that had borne it. Kennedy had not seen the coast of his birth in what seemed to him a dozen lifetimes, one of the casualties that lined the path he had chosen, yet the smell of salt was thick in his nose and it was with great remore that he focused his thoughts back onto the present. There would be time for such things later, once all was said and done and his world was free from the iron grip of Sol.
That brought him completely back to reality, and he turned his face away from the rising sun towards the east, where a new light was rapidly gaining altitude over the distant horizon. Not the light of Demeter’s second sun, for Demeter had no second sun.
________

By the way, this is my first posting around here, and all the other forums seem quite empty so I wasn't quite sure where to stick this. If I've erred in dropping it here, please be so kind as to redirect it elsewhere =p


Posts: 18 | Registered: Jul 2002  | Report this post to a Moderator
ZoVet
New Member
Member # 1414

 - posted      Profile for ZoVet   Email ZoVet         Edit/Delete Post 
Actually, submissions for critique generaly go in the 'Fragments and Feedback' forum. The other option is to join a private critique group, at:

http://www.hatrack.com/writers/writers/how-to-join.shtml

-Zoe

[This message has been edited by ZoVet (edited July 08, 2002).]


Posts: 5 | Registered: May 2002  | Report this post to a Moderator
Kolona
Member
Member # 1438

 - posted      Profile for Kolona   Email Kolona         Edit/Delete Post 
OK, Gordito,
I've had a frustrating day and I need to take it out on someone, and I can't resist your invitation (I am only marginally kidding. ), particularly since I just accidently erased this entire message and am re-entering it.

First off, watch sentence lengths.

Let's number the lines in your excerpt.

Line 1: Get rid of "had," add a comma after "rise," and get rid of "it was."

Line 2: Get rid of "still" and "for." Transpose "even bore" since "even" modifies "resemblance" not "bore."

Line 4: Get rid of the vague "it" and change the words after "that" to something stronger like "clinging to something old felt good." Get rid of the weak "could" and add an "ed" to "remember." I would transpose "remembered vividly," but that's me.

Line 5: Sounds like he spent his entire childhood watching rays on the coast. Change "watching" to "when he watched" and limit that little boy's idle time. Get rid of "the." Get rid of the weak "became" and release the stronger "entangled" of

Line 6: to do its job, maybe with something like "gold and crimson rays entangling themselves on the wavecrests." Period after "wavecrests." You're better off with the plural of "wavecrest," else it sounds like the entire body of water had only one wave.* Get rid of "whereupon."

Line 7: Change "wave" to a plural. *Even if you keep your original wording, "wave" would still be plural here. (If you give a bone to each dog, then they all have one. I had to think about that, but I believe that's right.)

Line 8: Change "it" to "they" due to previous plural changes. Get rid of "up."

Line 9: Change "it" to "them" because of the plural strategy. New paragraph at "Kennedy."

Line 10: Change the comma after "lifetimes" to a dash and the same with the comma in

Line 11: after "chosen." Period after "nose." Avoid the vague "it" again and change the sentence that straddles lines 11 and

Line 12: to something like "He focused his thoughts back onto the present with great remorse." ("Remorse" was a typo in the text.)

Line 13: Get rid of the first seven words. They're cliched and prevent your sentence from being as strong as it could be. Add "when" before "his world."

Line 14: New paragraph. Get rid of the also vague "That" and change to something like "The thought of Sol." Get rid of "completely." Adverbs are not your friends.

Line 15: Change "towards" to "in," unless the sun was rising from west to east, in which case you'd have to rework that.

Line 16: Change the period after "horizon" to a dash.

Now read it all out loud and see how it sounds. Not perfect, but better, no?

In spite of my red-lining, I thought the excerpt had a nice style to it--a relatively minimum number of words to convey a lot of information.

[This message has been edited by Kolona (edited July 15, 2002).]


Posts: 1810 | Registered: Jun 2002  | Report this post to a Moderator
Gorditio
Member
Member # 1451

 - posted      Profile for Gorditio   Email Gorditio         Edit/Delete Post 
Well, I never claimed to be talented, did I? Thanks for the feedback, albeit much belated it is going be helpful (not directly here, as that intro has been scrapped, and I believe you've edited my other already) in the coming weeks/months/years depending on how I decide to finish this. Some of those are just my goofy stylistic quirks, though, and I think they add a bit of 'me-ness' to the writing. Although the technical errors certainly will go...I was always a better writer than editor..which should say something of my editing skills, eh?
Posts: 18 | Registered: Jul 2002  | Report this post to a Moderator
Kolona
Member
Member # 1438

 - posted      Profile for Kolona   Email Kolona         Edit/Delete Post 
Gordito,
Nonsense, you are talented. With the couple leads I've seen, you've got a great sense of flow. Those "goofy stylistic quirks" are good, but only up to a point, e.e. cummings notwithstanding.

And I know these are first drafts, which beg a lot of rewrite. I tend to start a piece by going over the beginning a lot--sort of like a race car rocking and revving--before I find traction with a super-clean opening. Not that that doesn't still get re-polished.

Keep writing.


Posts: 1810 | Registered: Jun 2002  | Report this post to a Moderator
   

   Close Topic   Feature Topic   Move Topic   Delete Topic next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:


Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2