Basically a slice of life romantic comedy genre shift away from the epic space war.

Now however I'm left with a dilemma that I think some of the cynical of you are probably already guessing at.

I am not a song writer and have never written a song before.

So I am left with a choice, do I write around this "Light Novel" style (like in The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya) where you describe a concert scene and peoples reaction and elaborate on the mood step by step but run the risk of making them Mary Sueish by never showing them actually singing (because while amateur they have talent) and yet having everyone they meet congratulate them on how good they are for their age.

Or do I put in some effort and actually write some songs but run the risk of breaking peoples suspension of disbelief by the songs not being all that special or even good?

There's always the third option of doing a mix of both and then finding someone who can songwrite and have them do it if I get serious about this but that presents other problems.

Here's a song I wrote using this song at the 24ish second mark as a beat.

quote:

---

Enjoying our crazy ride.

Threatening our very lives.

Forcing. Us. To Substantiate.

Pooling our reckless resolve to reciprocate.

To delay our beleaguered fate.

When will we ever learn some caution?

I suppose we never will so what would we gain?

Spiraling forth, because we can.

Do not stop us! You can't stop us! Why are you trying!?

Please why won't you just go away?

We would love to never see you ever again. (cry)

But you will never leave us the hell alone.

So here we are, just you and me.

---

I completely lack music experience, and don't even know how to play guitar, I have one but haven't gotten around to learning it yet :sadface:

Thoughts?

quote:

---

I'm thinking that the above song is longer than 13 lines.

---

Along those lines quote just a line or two of a couple of songs. Too many songs would get boring and break up the action too much, I would think.

Most songs are rhyming poetry. If you need the words, write a poem. Let someone else come up with the tune. Describe the effects on the audience and the band.
The band played the love song he wrote for his girl. The young ladies in the audience swooned and cried as if he sung to each one of them.

As for how the band can be used, one idea is that you have the band going on stage and doing a concert with their newest song.
Then have the actual characters quote parts of the song as they are going through their actions. You might have it be sort of a group anthem, possibly adjusting the words slightly to fit their situation

Example

My eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the lord
he has trampled out the vintage where the grapes of wrath were stored
he has loosed the fateful lightning of his terrible swift sword
his truth is marching on

changing it to something we sun as kids

My eyes have seen the glory of the burning of the school
we have skipped all the classes and have broken all the rules
we have hid behind the door with a loaded forty fours
there ain't no teachers any more.

You show the poetry of the song as the band sings it.
Then you show the people modifying the song for their use
then you show it used as an anthem.

If you need a song, you might try taking somebody's tune and writing your own words to it---avoiding any word choice similar to what's right there, so you're not writing a parody...as "rstegman's" schoolboy version of "The Battle Hymn of the Republic" is.

I think songs that are over a hundred years old are awesome to read, they are poetry. Modern songs skip the poetry part. It is really difficult to write a modern song, and still be a poet, most current song writers can't do it.

I suggest skipping the song, and maybe just show the words on a good chorus. If you want to go with the song, then i suggest writing out some songs in the genre of music you will be writing, and analyze the poetry structure(or lack there of) and focus on the rhythm of the words.

For example; I had the time of my life, and I never felt this way before, and I swear, this is true, and I owe it all to you.

Notice all the breaks. All the broken grammatical rules. The focus on the rhythm, and on the pauses.

You are writing a book. A book is restricted to the written word, so music has to be described verbally. Yes, you could put lyrics in - but it's a rare lyric that comes over well on the page, where you don't get the mood set by vocalisation or instrumentation.

In my opinion, regardless of how good a song might be, most lyrics come across as rather silly when in print without the accompanying music.

I would suggest a compromise - include some lyrics, perhaps just the chorus, tempered by the audience's reaction. For instance, a high energy scene which shows the band is performing, the audience is keyed up singing along to the chorus and to avoid a 'Mary Sue' moment have a band member notice some people walking out of the concert. Or a scene where the band reacts to a music critic's scathing review and it hurts their egos.

In the 90s just about everyone called Oasis the second coming of the Beatles but I know plenty of people who didn't like them. No band is perfect, not even in fiction

*****

quote:

---

Or do I put in some effort and actually write some songs but run the risk of breaking peoples suspension of disbelief by the songs not being all that special or even good?

---

Don't you really mean that you'd be writing some song lyrics? That's far different from writing songs in my opinion.

I've contemplated this issue at some length. For me the idea that the lyrics of a song capture its essence doesn't work. I wouldn't dare put lyrics in a story I wrote. Maybe others can pull it off, but I can't.

The lyrics communicate a part, and the music communicates a part, and the combination of the two convey a feeling when done correctly. I don't believe this effect can be duplicated in prose, or in poetry.

Music is a different medium. If the characters were illustrators would it make sense to interrupt the narrative and insert drawings into the story? I don't know many writers would would think this a wise decision.

I don't know what a "Mary Sue" is, but I do know that I skip over the "songs" in stories because they are usually no more than poetry, and usually bad poetry in my opinion, even in the hands of masters. Songs are not simply poetry set to music; they are far more than that, and the words of a song fail to convey the emotional impact. If words alone were sufficient then one would be better off simply reading a poem without the distracting background noise.

Personally, I would find a story more believable if it conveyed the effect of music on the musicians, or on the audience, or both, and left the actual crafting of the music (and lyrics) to my imagination. The same goes for any art; auditory, visual, etc. I wouldn't throw a story down if a writer attempted this, but I would feel somewhat cheated.

When you design an alien culture or environment, you can also design a lyrical style to give depth to the construction world or differentiate between age groups. You do not have to be a musician to be a lyricist and for a written story there is no accompanied music (unless your as ambitious as Ursula K Leguin) with the text.

The question I would put forth is: Which comes first - the song or the story? Do you write snippet of songs and then write scenes around them; or do you write the songs afterwards to enhance the understanding of the atmosphere of the story?