posted
Hi, this is something new I'm working on. I originally started it in third person before deciding to switch to first, and I'm unsure if it's working for me. Would this opening entice you to read on? All replies appreciated!
-----------------------
Once, when I was young, I was told my name meant courage. But, on the morning I was to brave the flames, I knew if such a noble substance ever resided within me, it had withered long ago and now languished in some dark, forgotten place with a deaf ear to my summons. Her sister, Fear, I knew well. It was she who lurked in the early morning shadows, whispering doubts as the scent of sandalwood and smoke drifted up from the river. There, on the bank of the Ganges, India's holiest of rivers, my husband Gopesh waited. Through a narrow window, a gentle current wafted the sound of beating drums, and with it, the low murmurings of onlookers eager to see if I would prove myself a virtuous wife.
posted
I would absolutely read on. This is very nicely written.
You might drop a couple of commas after 'But' and 'There' and 'drums'. The sentences are all the same pattern with comma'd inserts. You could mix it up a little.
posted
Yeah, agreed, this is an effective opening.
One thought: While I enjoy all the characterization of emotions, etc., I wonder if it is a little distracting to a non-writer who's trying to get their bearings in your world. You might be better off starting the story with the "There, on the bank of the Ganges, ..." sentence before slapping us with all the raw emotion before we get a sense of why we should care. Then you can sprinkle in all the pretty stuff after that.
posted
Thanks for your feedback, genevive42 and alliedfive! I tend to get carried away with commas, so I will definitely drop a few of those. Also, I'll play around with rearranging that opening paragraph.
I thought that if you capitalize Fear that you should capitalize Courage.
I thought the sentence with the gentle wafting of the beating of drums didn't quite work for me. This was a stumbling block for me... the gentle wafting of drumbeats is, to me, discordant.
posted
Hi Owasm and arriki, thanks so much for the feedback!
quote:Do women's names in India mean courage?
According to those Indian/Hindu baby name sites, they do.
quote:I thought that if you capitalize Fear that you should capitalize Courage.
Thanks for bringing this up. I've been seriously wondering about this. My husband agrees with you that it should be capitalized. But, capitalizing it in that first sentence somehow doesn't seem right to me, though I can't explain why. To me, it would only look right capitalized if it were used in the second sentence: ...I knew if Courage ever resided within me, it had withered long ago...
Any grammarians around with insight on this? Help!
quote: It was she who lurked in the early morning shadows. It was the tiniest bit jarring the way you phrased this.
Thanks, I'll see what I can do to tweak this.
And, I'll also rework that last sentence since it tripped you both. In hindsight, "gentle" isn't really the tone or mood I'm trying to convey here, so I'll get rid of it.
Thanks so much to everyone who took the time to read and give feedback. Your insight was really helpful. You guys are awesome!
[This message has been edited by Word Weaver (edited August 17, 2009).]
I would read on wondering whether she would throw herself on the funeral pyre. However, she is narrating, which indicates she did not or that she is talking to us from the afterworld.
Second up:
I found the following to be a bit heavy on the pathos, a touch of purple prose:
quote: But, on the morning I was to brave the flames, I knew if such a noble substance ever resided within me, it had withered long ago and now languished in some dark, forgotten place with a deaf ear to my summons.
I like your single strong words. The words that attracted me were:
flames fear doubts drift sandalwood scent smoke drums
Double-barrelled descriptions draw my attention away from a story and make me focus instead on the craftsmanship of the piece and prove a distraction.
Phrases like:
noble substance dark, forgotten early morning narrow window gentle current beating drums low murmurings
IMO: See if there is a single, more powerful word to replace them or choose the one idea that is most important to your intent. If you are going to err, err on the side of simplicity.
I hope this is useful.
[This message has been edited by Andrew_McGown (edited August 18, 2009).]
quote:If you are going to err, err on the side of simplicity.
Sage advice.
Hmm... double-barrelled descriptions. I've never heard that term before, but what you say makes a lot of sense. I'll have to go back through this story and see if I can find any more of these that could possibly be replaced with a single, more powerful word.
Thanks for reading, Andrew. Your comments were really helpful.
posted
I agree with Andrew and alliedfive most (Andrew, I love your reference to "double-barrel" descriptions).
I too found myself in analysis mode rather than entertained mode. I couldn't understand why, but "placing" us in the scene in the first line would better allow you to delve immediately into Courage and Fear. The way the fragment reads in the first post is very interesting, but it feels like emotion without reference.
Please post again when we can read the whole thing. I am interested in reading more .
posted
You would capitalize courage if you had personified it (as you do with Fear), but in the first sentence courage is not a character, just a description. Probably a nit, but you never really make courage a character, you also reference it as a "noble substance" that is deaf to her summons (a deaf substance?), then contrast it with "Her sister, Fear...". This may be an inconcistency. Perhaps if you said "noble spirit" instead?
As with everyone else, I am also intrigued and would read on.
posted
Hi Word Weaver! As an avid reader and a hopeful writer, I am much better at reading than writing, so I will post accordingly.
First of all, great description and prose – grabs my interest.
I agree with a few of the earlier comments, too many commas make long sentences and chop up the first few lines for me. I had to reread first couple of lines to get the full gist of it all. This is a problem I always have with my own writing, using too many commas. Try to break down into shorter sentences, then the occasional longer sentence with many commas stands out and works better (at least that's what I've been told).
Also, I’m no pro at grammar but I also think Courage needs to be capitalized. When I read Fear capitalized, this caused me to do a double take and consider whose sister was Fear? I looked back, saw courage, and was disturbed that it was not capitalized as well.
After I finished reading and thought for a second, the concept of the Fear and Courage being sisters and made personal for the main character really grabbed me and made me want to read on, so this definitely works for me.