Hatrack River Writers Workshop Post New Topic  Post A Reply
my profile login | register | search | faq | forum home

  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» Hatrack River Writers Workshop » Forums » Writing Challenges » ENTRIES: Ice Dragon Challenge (Page 2)

  This topic comprises 2 pages: 1  2   
Author Topic: ENTRIES: Ice Dragon Challenge
philocinemas
Member
Member # 8108

 - posted      Profile for philocinemas   Email philocinemas         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Please excuse any the format and any mistakes on my part - I am writing this with my iPad while on vacation.

1 - liked the geneticist approach but felt the scenery was more of a distraction than establishing milieu.
2 - liked the imagery of the eye opening to surprise them but the last line confused me.
3 - nice prose but a bit info-dumpy and a very long paragraph.
4 - liked the unique take on the "dragon girl" but felt the narration did not match the dialogue in attribution.
5 - the statue was an interesting take but not sure if the MC is good or bad and confused about the monk.
6 - liked the title and the idea of a dragon-riding witch but felt the prose were a bit clunky.
7 - liked the comic tone and creative use of pun but was a little forced.
8 - liked the morphing dragon and direction of the story but the looking in the mirror was a bit cliche.
9 - really liked the imagery but a little confused about setting (circus?) and details like the gun and the dragon's question.
10 - liked the modern take but not sure where this would go as a story
11 - liked the wry twist but not sure about the use of second person.

- I will have to finish this later - family takes precedence and not sure how to copy and paste with Pages.


Posts: 2003 | Registered: Jul 2008  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
NICKOFSTEEL
New Member
Member # 9488

 - posted      Profile for NICKOFSTEEL   Email NICKOFSTEEL         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
I apologize for the time it took me to post my responses. I honestly had no time to critique in this past week of mine. With five separate midterms to study for and two term papers due, my time was severely limited. But, of course, you didn’t come here for excuses, you came for my results:
1st Place: Entry #12 “Ariadne”
2nd Place: Entry #1 “EVERLASTING”
3rd Place: Entry #17 “Lost in the Mists of immortality”
4th Place: Entry #33 “Last Entry”
5th Place: Entry #25 “Blink”
Best Title: Entry #4 “The Shape of Salvation”
1. “EVERLASTING”: I loved this entry especially the final sentence. However, the main character mentioned that calling creation “playing God” was idiotic, yet later the main character called it “God work”. Seemed contradictory.

2. “The Cold Walk”: This entry disappointed me. I was really interested for the first half, but when Melar was introduced it made me go back to the beginning to see the first character’s name. It detached me from the story and I didn’t like the way the characters were introduced. Also, the final sentence seemed to contradict itself (unless I read it wrong). I was under the impression that they came upon a dragon, but then the statement was that there weren’t any left on the world.


3. “Apostate”: My beautiful infodump. ;P

4. “The Luster in Her Eyes”: I enjoyed the contrasting images of hot/cold; reminded me of the last challenge. However, the dialog seemed random and it was hard for me to tell at first who was saying what. I loved how intimidating the Dragon Girl was. It made me feel slightly frightened in my dimly-lit living room. Nice title.


5. “Dragonic Possession”: I felt this one stuck with the prompt than most others. I, however, didn’t particularly like the main character very much. Also, I felt the phrase “little Chinese monk” was a bit condescending. There were too many questions left over from reading it, and I don’t know if I would have the desire to read on to find the answers.

6. “The Black Witches of Doon”: This is an honorable mention. I liked how candid the main character was. This was refreshing after reading so many of the other darker stories. I would definitely keep reading to find out why and how long this person was trying to flee from the “Blacks”. The only negative was that the candidness of the story had a few moments where I was distracted from the story by the reference to me as a reader. Made me feel a bit violated when addressed in the story.

7. “The Last Dragon”: I really like the idea of, what seems like, putting a dragon on trial. The names were a bit much for me, but they were realistic nonetheless. I personally really liked the dragon’s personality. He seemed so nonchalant amidst all the accusation.

8. “The Shape of Salvation”: I was intrigued about the feeling Sertia got when a dragon dies. I would like to see this more when I, undoubtedly, read further. There was a little more description than I normally like, but it was necessary I suppose. I’m curious to know why the human world is below-ground. I liked the idea of transforming into a dragon and I think the way you illustrated it was creative.

9. “Ten Gallon Tallons”: I don’t know why, but this one didn’t really do it for me. I think I found a mistake, but can’t be sure. You said there is a curtain surrounding the cage, but Katie can see her open jaws. Unless Katie is in the cage, in which case I eat my own words.

10. “Truth or Dare”: I was slightly intrigued. Reminded me a bit of Jumanji actually. I’d want to kep reading to know how a simple game of truth or dare happened to unleash a dragon; the most I ever managed to obtain was a kiss. Ha. I was a bit distracted by the sentence structure though, and I’d have to say that’s why it didn’t make Top 5 for me.

11. “White Lies”: I liked the title for this one a lot; really fit the story. The writing seemed a little weak to me. Could have been amped up a bit and could have dropped a few clichés. I think this would have interested me more had I not read 10 others before it. I would possibly continue reading if I had the chance.

12. “Ariadne”: Wow. This one has to be the most well-written out of the bunch. I never paused for a single moment to determine what the author was trying to convey in that sentence. Each transition was flawless and the concept of a Dragonborn was done nicely. I almost considered putting it in second place because the reference to “Dragonborn” reminded me of the new Elder Scrolls game coming out in November, but I decided the story was strong enough to garner 1st place. The only thing I didn’t like was the title. I love the name, but it made me feel like the author just watched Inception.

13. “Yin Yang”: The title fit the story very well. I liked the idea and the execution wasn’t distracting. I felt the dialog was flat though. It didn’t seem realistic to me. Constable Kim threw me out of the story for a moment too. Nice job spelling Yin Yang right, though. Not many people can do that.

14. “REVELATION”: I felt like this one was really rushed. The action seemed to occur really sudden and the build-up/reaction was lacking. I didn’t feel like there was immediate danger, just an immediate rush. I felt it struggled to maintain a sense of science fiction rather than fantasy, which I liked, but it ultimately fell short.

15. “Cheater”: I felt like there was no respect for the dragon. Likewise, I didn’t feel like there was any danger at hand either. It seemed more like she was playing fetch with a dog rather than battling a “400 pound” beast. I liked the description of the dragon, especially when you called it “The White”. But, in the end, I didn’t think this battle contained enough adrenaline for me.

16. “White Dragon”: I really enjoyed this one. Moreso than I think I should have. I enjoyed your description of the girl in hunt. A few parts could be re-written, and the structure could be organized better, but generally it was good. Also, your ending sentence, while confusing to me at first, made me like the story even more. Well done.

17. “Lost in the Mists of Immortality”: I’m actually a really big fan of infodumps. I’m sure other people will comment on it being so, but I felt that your execution of it was stellar. I’d like to learn more about this and hope you continue the story in the future. Beautifully written.

18. “Her Lost Love”: I wasn’t a big fan of this one for several reasons: The descriptions, while admirable, seemed to fall short. I think your use of adjectives could have been better. I think your ability to craft an intriguing, creative story is stronger than your ability to describe it. It wasn’t bad in the slightest, I just felt more time could have been added to make a truly compelling thirteen.

19. “A Chilling Reception”: Wow, I really wanted to place this one as my first place. After careful consideration I decided to not place it at all, though. I loved the little twist at the end with the cigarette. I honestly laughed for a good 20 seconds. However, I felt that the story reached its high-point there and I don’t think I’d read on after that. I did, though, enjoy the inclusion of names of people from the boards. I hope to have my name in your stories one day!

20. “Explore the Nebula”: I was highly intrigued with your having the nebula fulfill the roll of the dragon in this challenge. That hooked me from the start. However, after that point I became disinterested in the story and characters. I felt it originally had promise of being a good sci-fi story, but the dialogue seemed flat and unrealistic.

21. “The Hare and the Taxonomist”: This story, hands down, had the best opening sentence of the bunch. I enjoyed the dialogue as well. The town seemed simple and the neighbors quaint. However, I was wondering from the very beginning for the dragons to come in. It wasn’t until the third-to-last word that it was mentioned. I felt it was a bit tacked on to apply to the prompt. I would read on, but only because I enjoyed the way you tell a story.

22. “Fortunes of War”: Maybe I’m not getting something. I think the writing was well-done. However, sadly, I think I need a little more backstory for this one. I want to know more, but I also wasn’t really intrigued by the story at hand. I honestly feel like I am missing something, so I’m sorry that my inability to accurately read your story is impairing my ability to provide a useful criticism.

23. “MAD MEN OF THE HIMALAYAS”: Reminded me a bit of the entry before it. Again, this didn’t intrigue me as much as I hoped it would. I felt like I was placed halfway into the action. I once again would like to provide a better critique, but I couldn’t because I didn’t comprehend it well enough I suppose. Certain aspects of the story kept pulling me out of it. Maybe I’m just tired.

24. “Harbinger of Spring”: I loved the opening paragraph. This isn’t normally my type of story, but I felt you did a really great job of telling it. So much so that, if given the opportunity, I would continue reading it. The descriptions seemed simple and, usually, I dislike this. However, I felt this was intentional on your part and it worked well for you.

25. “Blink”: I loved your take on this challenge. The title, thoughts, and final sentence all stay true to what has been said in the story. It’s simple at its core, but beautifully written nonetheless. Well done, the last sentence was great.

26. “The Melting-Cauldron”: I felt this was one of the better fantasy stories of the bunch. I think you assume that the reader knows to much about this world, though. The only thing I didn’t like was, oddly, the inclusion of the dragon. It felt added on and I didn’t like its addition to the story.

27. “The Crystal”: There were a few dialogue moments where it was hard to read what they were saying. Clarity is something I struggled with in this one. Also, Brian’s response to “the voice” seemed out of character at the end. I fail to see a hook, but I did laugh out loud at the “impress the ladies” part.

28. “Visionary”: I think I’m getting the twist here, but—because it’s vauge—I’m going to have to not give this a Top 5 entry. Count me interested, but to fit this story into 13 lines is daunting and needs to be better developed outside the challenge. To do it in such a short space creates a jam-packed few lines.

29. “Second Life”: The premise seemed a bit cliché. I believe this happened to Captain America. Also, the reaction of the Doctor at the end seemed contrary to what I would imagine. She doesn’t sound amazed at the find, instead she seems annoyed. This in turn makes me, as a reader, not astonished at the discovery of a frozen dragon.

30. “DRAGONS OF BALDERDASH”: I thought this story was really interesting. Like I said earlier, I’m a fan of infodumps. But, after re-reading it a few times, I was wondering how the “primitive people” were able to see “star ships” assuming that star ships would most likely be among the stars. In this case, it’d be more accurate to say airplanes. Also, I don’t know what business star ships would have swiping cattle off the land of the primitive people.

31. “The Attack”: I enjoyed this action story. I think the first-half was definitely stronger than the second. However, you didn’t really leave much resolution to the fight with the dragon. “Sent it back” doesn’t imply immobilization. I would like to read more, for sure. Also, the change in point of view really messed with me. I didn’t like being drawn out of the action like that.

32. “Net the Queen”: For some reason I really, really liked the title to this story. A pre-flight checklist didn’t really intrigue me. I was however drawn to the idea of, what I thought would be, an attack to the queen dragon (as cliché as it sounded). However, the last sentence revealed that the queen was on their side. This made me wonder what the purpose of this dragon-flight story was about. I don’t know if it is enough to make me read further though.

33. “Last Entry”: Of course, the one that best pertains to the prompt also happens to be the one who created it. Very well done! The build-up definitely beckons me to read further. I didn’t particularly like the change in POV, but it wasn’t enough to pull me out of the story for long. That speaks well about your ability to keep the reader entertained. Again, well done on, not only the story, but on hosting this challenge (which just so happens to be my first).

A very special thank you to Josephine Kait for her patience and creativity.
Great posts by all. I love working with such creative minds.

[This message has been edited by NICKOFSTEEL (edited May 04, 2011).]


Posts: 5 | Registered: Apr 2011  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
aspirit
Member
Member # 7974

 - posted      Profile for aspirit   Email aspirit         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Here are my votes. I'm not sure I can finish critiquing all the entries by the new deadline, but I will try.

1st - #24, "Harbinger of Spring"
2nd - #12, "Ariadne"
3rd - #7, "The Last Dragon"
4th - #10, "Truth or Dare"
5th - #1, "Everlasting"

Best title: "Harbinger of Spring"


Posts: 1139 | Registered: May 2008  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Ethereon
Member
Member # 9133

 - posted      Profile for Ethereon   Email Ethereon         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Entry 1: Very intriguing and well written. "Entropy sucks." Great line! It sure does.
Entry 2: A bit of confusion over who's who. Nothing major, but could be a bit clearer. Dragon rising out of the earth sounds cool, but genre isn't my personal cup of tea.
Entry 3: Was not particularly into it, until the last line pulled me back in.
Entry 4: Nice imagery. Intriguing relationship.
Entry 5: Interesting situation. The character's actions initially made me dislike him/her, but then I realized he/she is under the influence of the statue… so maybe he/she's not such a jerk.
Entry 6: That the MC would choose to bury him/herself is intriguing. I know your last line has nothing to do with race and is referring to a type of witch, but it's very jarring and disconcerting.
Entry 7: Clever double meaning made me chuckle. I already like the dragon and hope he/she is the hero.
Entry 8: Didn't become particularly interested until the second paragraph. It's a bit tell-y, but I'm not sure how you'd get around that as it's important and interesting information.
Entry 9: I always like a plucky young heroine. Very curious what Katie's intentions are and what will happen next. Nice title too.
Entry 10: Social dalliance! Ha, love that line. Opening was a little awkward, but I'm very curious to find out more about Sheila and her heritage.
Entry 11: Didn't particularly care for the voice (personal preference), but the last line was interesting.
Entry 13: Suggestions of torture conjure some gruesome images, but very intriguing nonetheless. Cool twist on the challenge criteria.
Entry 14: Action packed opening. The second sentence technically should be two sentences, which tripped me up a bit.
Entry 15: Cool. That they both seem to be enjoying a contest that could turn deadly piques my interest.
Entry 16: Fun
Entry 17: Cool. I like the transition from classic fantasy-seeming setting to modernity. Imminent discovery provides the hook. Nice.
Entry 18: Nicely done LD.
Entry 19: Hehehe. Very amusing snapper. And clever.
Entry 20: Rather "as you know, Bob."
Entry 21: Cute. Has potential with the mix of neighbourhood characters.
Entry 22: Good tension in the relationship.
Entry 23: Not really my thing. Just personal preference.
Entry 24: Very cool. Of course you had me right away with the image of vibrant green emerging from prairie snow. Close to home for me.
Entry 25: Nicely written and a great interpretation of the challenge criteria. Out of the context of the challenge the metaphor might be a little heavy though.
Entry 26: Arctic elves, an ice dragon and a scientist—very interesting combination!
Entry 27: Interesting idea, but needs some editing for flow etc.
Entry 28: It could be clearer who Nokos and Seleukos are and if anyone else is with them. "Only Seleukos knew the plan," makes me think that others are there who do not know. Not sure if this is the case or not.
Entry 29: Why would she assume it's a dragon? Why not some kind of dinosaur?
Entry 30: Interesting idea, but the way it's told doesn't draw me in.
Entry 31: Good action-filled opening, but kinda clunky.
Entry 32: Unique take on the challenge criteria. Cool. Some mild confusion, but I trust it will sort out shortly as I learn more about the world.
Entry 33: Cute.

Votes:
1st: Entry 1 – Everlasting
2nd: Entry 25 - Blink
3rd: Entry 32 - Net the Queen
4th: Entry 9 – Ten Gallon Talons
5th: Entry 26 – The Melting Cauldron
This was really tough. There were a number of others I really wanted to vote for!

Are we doing best title? If so: Ten Gallon Talons


Posts: 291 | Registered: Jun 2010  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Matt.Simpson01
Member
Member # 8937

 - posted      Profile for Matt.Simpson01   Email Matt.Simpson01         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
1. 24
2. 30
3. 17
4. 1
5. 8

those are my votes


Posts: 53 | Registered: Dec 2009  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
philocinemas
Member
Member # 8108

 - posted      Profile for philocinemas   Email philocinemas         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Started on critiquing the rest, but haven't finished. Here are my votes:

First - 9
Second - 17
Third - 21
Fourth - 25
Fifth - 12

Title - Lost in the Mists of Immortality


Posts: 2003 | Registered: Jul 2008  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
rstegman
Member
Member # 3233

 - posted      Profile for rstegman   Email rstegman         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Entry # 7
The Last Dragon

Entry #15
Cheater

Entry #33
Last Entry

Entry 18
Her Lost Love

Entry 19
A Chilling Reception

best title
Blink


Posts: 1007 | Registered: Feb 2006  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
Josephine Kait
Member
Member # 8157

 - posted      Profile for Josephine Kait   Email Josephine Kait         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Voting is officially closed and I want to thank you all for getting your votes in!

<drum roll> And the winners are…


Tied for first place, shimiqua with Ten Gallon Talons and Ethereon with Ariadne – 32 points each

In second place, RoxyL with Harbinger of Spring – 31 points

In third place, History with Everlasting – 23 points
In fourth place, RoxyL with Blink – 22 points
In fifth place, Brendan with The Hare and the Taxonomist – 21 points

HMs, Dark Warrior with The Last Dragon – 19 points
Brendan with Yin Yang – 18 points
Corin224 with Truth or Dare – 16 points
Owasm with Lost in the Mists of Immortality – 15 points

Best title – Ten Gallon Talons – 3 votes
Runners up – The Shape of Salvation, Lost in the Mists of Immortality, Blink – 2 votes each
And third was a 9-way tie of 1 vote each (lol)

I have to say that as much fun as I thought multiple entries were, I will probably never do that again. Still special congratulations to RoxyL for whom both entries made the top five, and Owasm whose third entry was his best.

Well done, all! I have to say that there wasn’t a single entry that I didn’t like. Of course it was my prompt, so the odds were already good. But really, these were amazingly strong entries, very creative and well written. I have enjoyed this so much. Thank you all!

In fact I’m so pleased that I’m going to make a blanket offer to crit any short story or first chapter that begins with an intro from this challenge. Just e-mail me, and I'll get it back to you as quickly as I can.

Congratulations once again, and thanks for making this so much fun.


Posts: 456 | Registered: Aug 2008  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
RoxyL
Member
Member # 9096

 - posted      Profile for RoxyL           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
This challenge was a ton of fun. There were so many good and uniquie ideas.
Thanks so much to Josephine Kait for all her hard work and such an inspirational prompt.
And thanks to everyone for the best part of all, the fabulous crits.

Posts: 266 | Registered: Apr 2010  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
History
Member
Member # 9213

 - posted      Profile for History   Email History         Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Hey! I placed!
Guess I need consider actually writing the story sometime.

Thanks for the opportunity to play, Josephine.

Respectfully,
Dr. Bob


Posts: 1475 | Registered: Aug 2010  |  IP: Logged | Report this post to a Moderator
  This topic comprises 2 pages: 1  2   

Quick Reply
Message:

HTML is not enabled.
UBB Code™ is enabled.
UBB Code™ Images not permitted.
Instant Graemlins
   


Post New Topic  Post A Reply Close Topic   Feature Topic   Move Topic   Delete Topic next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:


Contact Us | Hatrack River Home Page

Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2