posted
Hi This is a story I finished a while ago. I like the voice, but I think it's missing some real action and plot. It has a distant feel to it that sounds good but doesn't grab the attention of the reader. It's also description heavy. That said, I'd like comments on the first thirteen and readers for the whole story. It's around 2400 words long. Any imput on how to revitalize the plot will be welcome.
In the meadow of Putkam, there was a village, and in that village, there was a rock that resembled a tree or a woman, depending how one looked at it. Legend had it that if you rubbed the surface with your hand on the day of the Pentecost the rock would bring you luck for the rest of the year. The legend also said that when the rock was rubbed smooth, an ancient being would emerge and grant a single wish to the person who released her. Their lives would become enmeshed and their mutual obligations would extend beyond death. * As you know, the meadow of Putkam is a verdant garden, crossed by the river Teresias that flows into the Black Sea. It was not always so. At the time of the Putkam Wars, the Farong had placed a dam far up in the mountains and the river flowed shallower every year.
EDITED FOR SPELLING
[This message has been edited by Sara Genge (edited August 06, 2006).]
In the meadow of Putkam, there was a village, and in that village, there was a rock that resembled a tree or a woman, depending how one looked at it. Legend had it that if you rubbed the surface with your hand on the day of the Pentecost the rock would bring you luck for the rest of the year. The legend also said that when the rock was rubbed smooth, an ancient being would emerge and grant a single wish to the person who released her.
However, at the word "person", I kind of expected one of the characters in the story to be introduced--if not the character who eventually releases the ancient being, then perhaps someone else of importance. Because of that, the transition to a description of the meadow seemed a little abrupt.
posted
My brain came to a screeching halt when you tossed in the word "Pentecost."
That word to me denotes a specific, real-world, Jewish/Christian holiday. Yet your choice of place names, with the exception of "Black Sea" don't seem to be real-world. The mish-mash of real-world and fantasy doesn't work for me. As a reader, I want you to pick one or the other, but don't toss both into the mix unless you are going with alternative history (like the Alvin Maker series.) And if THAT is the case, establish the fact straight up to avoid confusion.
Another note: the word "damn" is a curse word. The word "dam" would be a structure that is placed as a barrier in rivers and streams.
I'm not hooked, and the above mentioned issues are why.
[This message has been edited by Elan (edited August 05, 2006).]
posted
I don't know why, but the first sentence doesn't seem quite right. The first two parts of it are very symmetrical: "In the meadow of Putkam, there was a village, and in that village, there was a rock..." It almost seems as if this part of the sentence forms a complete thought, sets a finite place for the rest of the story. But then the sentence goes on into a description of the rock, and loses the symmetry it started with. I expected it to continue, something like "...there was a rock, and the rock resembled..." and felt a little thrown off when it didn't. I can't say I found the change unpleasant, but it made me have to concentrate a little too much, to make sure I read it right. The change wouldn't matter so much if you split it into two sentences. (It might not matter to anyone but me, anyway.)
I'm never quite sure of using the pronoun "one". "...depending on how one looked at it." It always seems contrived, a way to avoid using the second person "you." As you go on to use "you" in the second paragraph, it would probably be fine in the first paragraph, as well.
I'm not a fan of "Legend had it..." Mostly because I can't figure out what the "it" represents, which means my dislike is based entirely on preference.
I think "ancient being" is a bit indecisive, even for legend. Is this "being" something like a god? or a witch? or a monster/magical creature?
I love the part about "their mutual obligations would extend beyond death."
As usual, because I seem to love commas beyond the taste of most writers, I'd add a few commas into this, for flow. i.e. "...on the day of the Pentecost, the rock would..." and "...would emerge, and grant a single wish..." etc.
I like this fragment, but I can't say I'm engrossed by it. Part of my hesitation is because you start it off in passive voice, and part is because the second person point of view is so unfamiliar to me. Everytime I saw "you", I thought, "Who? Me?"
posted
For me – my opinion – I liked the first sentence with the meadow and the village and the rock. It had a quaintness to it. I also accepted the “it” in Legend had it…. I see lots of openings with an undefined it.
It all began on Wednesday.
Works for me…as long as you don’t overdo the it-ness of “it”s.
He snapped a photo of it and showed the print around for days. Everyone admired the composition. “Italian houses are so quaint.” No one said anything about the green object hovering in the background over the garden wall until Sunday when John took the print, studied the landscape intently while he sipped beer and then said. “That isn’t real now, is it?”
“What’s the matter? You don’t believe in ghosts?”
Well, anyway, real object “it”s do need to be eventually be clarified. Yours worked okay. Legend had [often said] that if you…. is what I take your “it” to mean.
Or whatever.
What DID bother me was the second paragraph. That paragraph ‘feels’ to me like… “oh, no, here we go off on a lecture and a boring one at that.”
Your first bit of narration had a light tone, was specific, and read delightfully. Having gotten the legend of the rock out of the way, I was ready for the story to open, not to have a history lesson. I think it may be the very lightness of the first paragraph that makes the second one seem boring and stodgy to me.
If we really need this geo-political lesson, could you perhaps begin the story and insert it a bit later? After I’ve been entranced by your eloquent prose and riveting story. Hmmm?
[This message has been edited by arriki (edited August 05, 2006).]
In the meadow of Putkam, there was a village, and in that village, there was a rock that resembled a tree or a woman, depending how one looked at it. Legend had it that if you rubbed the surface with your hand on the day of the Summer solstice the rock would bring you luck for the rest of the year. The legend also said that when the rock was rubbed smooth, an ancient being would emerge and grant a single wish to the person who released her. Their lives would become enmeshed and their mutual obligations would extend beyond death. * This is the legend of the Kings of Putkam. You ask me now, why I won't go to war. I tell you now, you are not Putkam, for all Putkams know the myth. This tale should not need to be retold to anyone but children. I will tell it now to grown men.
Edited for blunder [This message has been edited by Sara Genge (edited August 09, 2006).]
[This message has been edited by Sara Genge (edited August 09, 2006).]
posted
My two cents on either version are: the first two paragraphs are great (with the provisio over "Pentecost", with which I whole-heartedly agree. BTW, "Putkam" to me sounds more Cambodian than Eastern European). But once you're past those, you have to give us something to hang on. A cool situation and an intriguing legends are not going to be enough. I want a character. And in both cases I don't get one. I get the beginning of a legend as told by a story teller. The thing is, you've already told me the beginning of a legend--in the two paragraphs that preceded. I think it would be better if you cut to the real beginning of the story than start recapitulating the situation of Putkam. Not sure if I'm making sense Anyway, if you need a not-very-fast reader, send it my way.
Posts: 1075 | Registered: Sep 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
What is Ella Enchanted? The character is in the next paragraph. Kind of late? I've sent it off to those who offered.
Posts: 507 | Registered: Jun 2006
| IP: Logged |
posted
I love the legend part, but I almost think the third paragraph should go first. I don't like third paragraph how it is know, it doesn't flow for me.
If your still looking for readers, send it my way.
posted
Ella Enchanted was a girl whom a fairy cursed to do everything she was ordered to do - it had to be an order, like "eat"..and she had to obey it.
The story starts off similar to yours, and The Princess Bride...they were both wonderful stories
posted
Sent it to Kings_Falcon Wbriggs: write me so I have your mail to send you the story. Thanks everyone! I'll look at the third paragraph thing
Posts: 507 | Registered: Jun 2006
| IP: Logged |
posted
I would like to read it also. And only because no one said it before (or maybe I didn't see it) Soltice in summer and winter, equinox in spring and fall. At least on this planet.
Posts: 84 | Registered: Feb 2006
| IP: Logged |
posted
Kathleen, do you have any idea why my email address link isn't showing up? When I go to edit my profile, the email address is there.
Posts: 2830 | Registered: Dec 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
Will, just to double-check the easy stuff... At the bottom of your profile is a button, "Keep your email address viewable to other users when you post notes?" Have you checked to see if it is set to "yes?"
Posts: 24 | Registered: May 2006
| IP: Logged |